Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Death to the Teddy Bear Namer!

By CosmicConservative
Teddy bear teacher appears in court as Islamic fanatics demand execution| News | This is London Mrs Gibbons faces 40 lashes and a year in jail after after being charged with insulting Islam. Reports today suggested the complaint against her had been made by a secretary at the school. She was charged after behind-the-scenes political moves to avoid a court case collapsed amid growing Islamic anger in the east African country. A Sudanese official said it was "unlikely" that Mrs Gibbons would be convicted. A powerful Sudanese newspaper urged authorities to call a hardline Islamist leader linked to Osama bin Laden to give evidence at her trial, to stress how offensive the case was to Muslims. Extreme Islamic groups said Mrs Gibbons "must die" and urged Muslims to hold street protests after prayers tomorrow.
I have a suggestion. If your religion tells you that someone should die for naming a stuffed animal after one of your religious figures, your religion should be expunged from the universe immediately.

Comments (31)

Andy
I can't remember what company it was, but they manufactured a Jesus Teddy Bear several years ago. As I remember, it was a big hit with Christian parents wanting to teach their kids that Jesus is a lovable, consoling friend. Well...off with her head I guess...Islam at it's best!
CosmicConservative
This is why I maintain that there are qualitative differences between Islam and the other "major" religions on this planet. Islam is the only one that would call naming a Teddy Bear "Mohammed" an insult, and is the only one that would demand the death of the namer for the insult. No other religion on earth is so intolerant, so insecure and so fascist. None.
pace
CNN is reporting that she has been convicted, with a penalty of 15 days in prison followed by deportation. Based on what we've seen of the judicial system in Islamic states, I guess she should count herself fortunate.
Andy
Pace: At first blush, I think "She should fall on her knees and thank God for her 'light' punishment." But 15 days in a Sudanese prison...she may prefer the 40 lashes. That is not meant as a joke. I will be praying for the lady, and hope that maybe the International Red Cross can monitor her time in prison. Cosmic: Intolerant, insecure, and fascist...I think you hit the nail on the head pal. "Insecure" is a fabulous description of Islam.
pace
I'll try posting this comment logged-in, as it keeps refusing to appear. --- From CNN: "UK Foreign Secretary David Miliband called Gibbons' actions an "innocent misunderstanding," following a meeting with the Sudanese Ambassador to Britain, Omer Siddig, who was summoned to the Foreign Office in London." The British really need to cease with this language of appeasement toward these religious extremists. What he should have pointed out, is that in Western nations the teddy bear is a symbol of childhood innocence, and love, and comfort, and that for any group to express offense to school children naming it after a religious figure only speaks volumes about their intolerance of others and of the negative culture they have built up around their dogma.
Drax
All belief in supernatural beings requires the willing suspension of disbelief, a faith in something which, by its very nature, defies reason. This is why I believe that anyone who believes in a supernatural being is just a bit insane. Normally, this "insanity" is harmless and, in many cases, even beneficial to humanity. But, these fundamental islamic people have gone completely over the edge, and no Western leader has the intenstinal fortitude to call them on it. We're not going to get anywhere with this fight until we realize (as a nation) just what we're up against..a well organized, well funded group of people who are collectively insane and who have focused that insanity on the destruction of all things "western."
Dadman
Drax: Well, I'll try not to take offense to the notion that people of faith are insane; in principle I believe I know what you are saying... I learned as a parent that when temper tantrums are appeased in any form or manner it inevitably results in even more tantrums. On nearly a daily basis now, Islamic extremists are throwing metaphorical fits over one thing or another and Western nations, like really bad parents, appease these raging maniacs through word and deed. The result will, of course, be more rage and more outrageous behavior.
Drax
Heh. I knew that I would take some heat by saying that, but, that's okay. I don't really know how else to describe belief in supernatural beings.
Dadman
I frankly don't believe in the 'supernatural'. I believe there are aspects of the natural world we simple don't understand...yet. I have difficulty believing that a trained legal mind such as your own cannot come up with another way of describing people of faith. Perhaps you should try harder. ;)
CosmicConservative
I agree with Dadman on the "supernatural" thing. I don't think a definition of "supernatural" exists that cannot be demonstrated logically to be self-contradictory. If God exists, he is natural. If ghosts exist they are natural. Our entire history has been one long journey of explaining through natural means things that were once considered to be the province of the "supernatural." I fully expect that we are not at the end of that journey yet. Will we find "God" at the end of it? I dunno, but if we do, he'll be a natural thing.
Andy
Drax: These comments you have gotten don't sound like "heat" to me. They sound like well reasoned, civil responses. I think that you have explained what you mean by that before, so I won't bother you about it again. As I remember, the explanation was pretty sound. The only thing that I would add is that faith does certainly defy reason. This is an old example, but it has roots in reality: I sit in a particular chair every day. I sit down in it without thinking once that it will not hold me up. But one day I sit down, and the chair collapses beneath me. My faith in that chair has been destroyed by the reality of it's failure. I could have "reasoned" each time I sat down in it that it might collapse, but my continued experience with this chair caused me to abandon reason, and just go ahead and sit my butt down. So, faith does defy reason. That is the nature of faith. The Apostle Paul wrote "faith that is seen is no faith at all." 2,000 years ago (and long before that I am sure), men understood this. It is not a new revelation. I do like the fact that you distinguish as "insane," those that believe in a supernatural being...not using the term "god." Because, everyone has a god. Even those that reject the God of the Bible, or of the Quaran, or whatever...still have a god. If you had defined those that believe in a god as "insane," then EVERY human would be classified as insane...as we all have a god.
CosmicConservative
Andy: Mostly I agree with you, but a few points. I completely disagree with your comment that "everyone has a god." That is simply an assertion of your own belief and is not provable nor even demonstrable. In fact I might go so far as to say that it is a platitude, rhetorically empty of semantic content. However, I do not believe that it is "insane" to believe in God. Not that I completely disagree with Drax, but it is a strange definition of "insanity" that would make the great bulk of the population "insane." If that were the case the word "sane" would pretty much have no meaning. This actually cuts very close to the liberal contention that Bush is deranged because he once said that he "talks to god." That sort of statement drives good liberals insane. (yeah, that's a pun...) Many of them seem to be unable to process the concept that a man might believe that God is listening and that God even speaks back in some way but still be sane. Men who publicly made comments that they believe that they talked to a listening and responsive God include, but are not limited to: - Albert Einstein - Thomas Jefferson - George Washington - Charles Darwin - John F. Kennedy - Bill Clinton Now, Hillary Clinton has made no such statement that I recall, but she DID say that she spoke with the spirit of Eleanor Roosevelt, which is far closer to "insane" in my opinion than the belief that one can talk to an omniscient being who hears every sparrow fall.
Andy
Cosmic: You typed: I completely disagree with your comment that “everyone has a god.” That is simply an assertion of your own belief and is not provable nor even demonstrable. In fact I might go so far as to say that it is a platitude, rhetorically empty of semantic content. Semantic content: It depends on your defintion of god. I define god as any thing, or any one that one has faith in...looks to for their security. To some, the God of the Bible, or Quaran is their God. Those that reject the idea of a Supreme Being have other options. They either look to a "spiritual leader" as some Western cults do...or government...or their money...or their job...or devas, or "gods many" etc. Those that reject all of that become their own god...self-reliant, looking to themselves for their own security (in a strange way, those are the most insecure). Every human places faith in some thing, or some one for their security. I have yet to meet a human that defies that truth. It is semantics. But if you know any human that doesn't have trust in some thing, or some one (even if it is themself) , I'd like to meet them. (I say I'd like to meet them, but it might be pretty spooky) You can call it a platitude if you want, and it does not hurt my feelings...because it is undeniable truth. Every human has placed their faith in something, or someone (my definition of their god). If they don't, well...they are not human...they are spooky! By the way: Hillary and Eleanor...Man, do those two First Ladies (?) have a lot in common, or what? ;)
CosmicConservative
Andy: The difference between everyone "places faith in something" and "Everyone has a god" is the difference between belief and worship. When you say "everyone has a god" what I hear is "everyone worships something." That is what a "god" means to me. I place faith in a lot of things, many very mundane things (like gravity, for example) but that is not remotely saying that I put gravity on the same plane as "God." Maybe you are saying that my respect for gravity is the same thing as your reverence for God, and if so I would say that is nonsense. I know many, many people who don't have a "God" in the sense that they revere and worship something. And that's what I think most people mean when they say "everyone has a god." It is an attempt to imply that those who don't worship "God" instead worship "money" or "sex" or (most frequently) "themselves." I don't worship or "revere" anything Andy, and in that sense I don't have a "god" that I know of. And I know many, many people who are like me in that.
Andy
Cosmic: Like I said...semantics...my definition of a god differs from yours. It is not an attempt to imply anything when I say that "everyone has a god." It is a staightforward statement of truth. I have a different life experience from yours. My definition, and distinction between belief and worship is similar to yours. I would never worship gravity, even though I know it is an unfailing principle. I wouldn't worship the Sun either, even though I know it provides life to Earth. I believe that those forces are in place, and that they will be...I can rely on them, but not worship them. Humans that deny a Sovereign Being really do worship themselves. I know that it is hard to hear, but it is the truth. If there is not a God, then each man is the ultimate being. Every atheist I have ever known is arrogant, self-absorbed, and self-focused. Now, I'm not letting God-believers off the hook here...a bunch of us are guilty. It is the nature of man to give homage to "self," even if we believe in God. I am pretty sure that this is futile...just my last attempt (I promise) to explain where my soul is. I really haven't ever known anyone that doesn't revere anything (lovingly, I will tell you that I think you really do, because you aren't spooky). ;)
CosmicConservative
Andy: I know that this sort of debate can never be settled because you and I have completely different perspectives on the question. I do get "hung up" on semantics because I think words mean things. When a person says "I believe in God" that has a particular meaning. To say that "I believe in God" is the logical equivalent of "I believe in gravity" is, I'm sorry to say, nonsense. Maybe I am spookier than you think. In fact I think it is in large part that I find it impossible to worship anything, that I find it so difficult to believe in God at all. You and I simply are not going to agree on this Andy. By any generally accepted or reasonable definition of what a "God" is, I simply do not have one. You can believe it or not as you see fit, but you are assuming a lot when you assume that you know my mental state and my spiritual compass better than I do.
Dadman
Getting hung up on semantics or divergent defintions of specific words unnecessarily bogs down the discussion. God to Cosmic is evidently all about worship, but that was not Andy's point as I read it. If we have no faith in a supreme being, God, then we tend to place our faith or reverence on other things...like wealth, like youth, like personal power. I believe Cosmic when he says he does not 'worship' anything, but I think he has a certain reverence or deep respect for things like knowledge, reason, logic, the scientific method, empirical evidence and his own self-sufficiency. And I think Cosmic relies on these things in much the same way a person of faith relies on God...
Andy
Cosmic: Okay, I lied...I typed earlier that I would quit...I am a huge liar. Man...I am not assuming anything about your mental state or spiritual compass. I learned a long time ago what assuming will get ya. If I am assuming anything about you it is that you aren't as spooky as you let on. I guess I wasn't very clear with my definitions. I really think that a "god" is the one thing in our life that we would forsake everything else for. I've never known a person that didn't have one singular person, or thing (even if it is their self) that they would not "chuck it all for." If I ever run into someone like that...I shudder to think! I happen to be one of those that believe in a sovereign God of the universe. My experience has lead me to that faith. (a very, very long story) For about 20 years now I have marveled at (and found to be true) Leonard Ravenhill's simple statement, "A man with an experience is never at the mercy of a man with an argument." Ravenhill was brilliant (and provocative) in that thought. I have called upon that truth in situations ranging from sports, to politics, to faith, to fixing cars. Never have I heard a truer sentence from a human. But in that statement he left the hearer to learn for themselves the fact that a man without an experience is also never at the mercy of a man with one. You are right pal, we are not going to agree on this one for now. But, from one Cowboy homer to another I hope that we can agree...I see a Super Bowl in our future.
Drax
I agree that the "heat" has been mild. (Truly, I expected it to have only a few degrees more than it has had considering the quality of people posting (for the most part) on this blog.) I agree that, if God exists, then he would likely be a "natural" being. (Of course, he could be otherwise, couldn't he?) But, I'm speaking of the God of the Bible, the Koran...able to raise the dead, see the future, destroy the universe, create the universe, do anything and everything. Period. No physical laws bound him. Time does not constrain him. He can do things which, by any definition, are "impossible." (Until we can create our own universes, I'll put that little ability in the category of "impossible to accomplish while following the rules of physical law....") A true "supreme being." A being who defies rational thought and reason, who is not constrained by the physical laws of the universe. You can call that whatever you like....but, I'll stick with "supernatural." And, why on earth would anyone find it difficult to believe that every person who believes in such a supernatural power is a "little bit insane?" Hell, I have ABSOLUTELY NO DIFFICULTY believing that every single person on the face of the planet is a little bit insane. The things we do to each other when ALLOWED to do so are so vile that it beggars the imagination. WHOLE COUNTRIES go insane when allowed to do so. Then, if the insanity passes, they look back at the gas chambers, the killing fields, the mass graves, and wonder "What the Hell was I thinking?" Society puts upon us constraints which keep our insanity in check, forcing us to reign in our baser impulses. Radical Islam allows for these baser impulses, this insanity, free reign, indeed, sanctioning it with an even greater power than could Hitler...
Dadman
Check out this statement for truth: women are hot... How does it rate to Ravenhill's statement?
Dadman
I am just a little insane in spite of my faith, not because of it. ;)
Andy
Dadman: Not all women are hot...ever see Oprah, or Hillary? Drax: Exactly...everyone on the planet is a little bit insane. But your first point was even more correct. These Islamic radicals are dangerous...over the top. Heck, I love Jesus, but I'm not going to go blow myself up to prove it...and I am darned sure not going to chop someone's head off if they don't get baptized. We are truly in a war that I never really imagined as a younger man. If you're a praying man, pray hard!
CosmicConservative
I am going to have to respond to a couple of things on this thread at the risk of offending a couple of commenters. It can't be helped, and if I wanted to, I could certainly be offended by some of the comments that have been posted, but I tend to try to keep things in a discussion or debate as unemotional as possible. We'll see how this goes. "A man with experience is never at the mercy of a man with an argument." This statement, as written, would give complete authority to the experience of every schizophrenic who hears voices and sees visions over the doctors who are trying to convince him that the visions and voices are only in his head. The fact that a person BELIEVES they have had an experience does not empirically PROVE that the event happened as the person believes it did. This is why there are so many religions, all of which claim to have miracle after miracle performed by their own "Gods." So this sort of argument may give comfort to the person with the experience, but not to the person who finds the experience to be something not believable, and whose experiences are completely the opposite of the claimant. This is pretty close to Drax's contention that there is a certain amount of insanity in religious experience, so I'm sure it will anger people, but I maintain that this is empirically proven by the number of schizophrenics whose visions and voices stop when they receive medication and the number of completely incompatible "proven, experienced" miracles that all religions rely on to provide credibility to their claims. So don't expect me to be swayed by any claims of "personal experience" to "prove" a religious faith. If there is one thing human beings are supremely good at, it is fooling themselves into believing what they want to believe. I do not say that God is all about worship as Dadman asserts. What I am doing is a logical comparison showing how vastly different the belief in a "God" is when compared to other phenomena that I DO believe in. It does not require "worship" to achieve this difference, but "worship" is the most obvious way to try to explain it. I could just as easily have said that faith in an "omnipotent" being is infinitely different from faith in an "omnipresent force" like gravity. But I thought the "worship" analogy was a more intuitive one. Basically it's all about scale. Believing in "God" is quantitatively AND qualitatively different from faith in reason, logic, gravity and the theory of relativity. Not to mention that they are experimentally falsifiable and therefore scientifically "provable." So to say that I "believe in something" so there's really no difference than believing in God is a fundamentally incorrect statement because it compares not apples to oranges, but molecules to galaxies. So it is definitely accurate to assert, as Dadman does, that I accept the value of and the "rightness" of logic, reason, the scientific method, etc. But here's the difference. I don't believe ANY of them are perfect. I don't believe any of them are "right." What I believe is that they are useful approximations of something profound about the universe and they provide us glimpses of the underlying fundamental truth of the universe, but it is looking through a very blurry lens. If there is anything that I "revere" it would probably be the concept of free will. I know you are all sick of hearing me harp on that subject, but the more I think about it (and I think about it a LOT) the more convinced I am that free will is the only important thing in the universe. The ONLY thing. Without it, nothing else matters. With it, everything matters. And that is about as profound and reverential as my limited brain can get.
Dadman
I don't think Andy was arguing there is an equivalency between belief or faith in God (capital 'G') and those things with which agnostics or atheists replace belief in an omnipotent being. The argument, I think, was simply that faith in God will be replaced by faith or reverence in other things (gods with a small 'g'). I totally agree with you on free will...
CosmicConservative
See, and that final assertion of your last comment is exactly what I disagree with. It is common for religious people to BELIEVE that "faith in God will be replaced by faith or reverence in other things" but that is merely an assertion, not a fact. It is, as I said in my first post, not provable. It is, and again this is going to sound harsh, but it is what it is... It is a platitude. A statement that sounds profound and meaningful, but which actually does nothing but assert a pleasant sounding personal belief. That's all it is.
Dadman
Man, you do like to debate don't you? What Andy is proposing is quite simple. Religious people believe in God. Secular humanists believe in the instrinsic potential of humanity. They believe we can make it all work independent of any diety if we rely on our own intelligence, talents and capabilities. That's just one example. Perhaps there are exceptions and perhaps it's those exceptions you are focused on. Or perhaps I'm just missing your point entirely. ;)
CosmicConservative
Yes, I do like to debate, but part of it is that I want to be sure the debate gets to the heart of the matter instead of getting hung up on something or sidetracked. I accept that there are SOME non religious people who have something else in their life that takes the place of religion. In fact for most "fundamentalist" liberals I think that's exactly what "liberalism" is, it's a religion, with dogma, schizms, purges and all the normal religious baggage that goes with it. And maybe it is a minority, perhaps even a miniscule minority of non religious people that are like me, but what I'm trying to say is that it is not accurate to assert that EVERYONE has something that takes the place of "God" in their lives. That I do not believe to be accurate.
Dadman
Of course, that was Andy's assertion, not mine. Perhaps you'll have a religious vision tonight while you sleep and decide to become a Druid. Do you have room for a Stonehenge like structure in your backyard?
CosmicConservative
Hmmm... I was a druid for about two hours last night.... What a coincidence...
Andy
Cosmic: I am assuming (never a good idea, I know) that I was included when you wrote about risking offending some. Don't ever worry about that pal. It is not possible to offend me. Now, I know that is not provable...you'll just have to take my word on that one. You know, there are a lot of things that are true that aren't provable. And I sure hope I didn't write anything that was offensive to you. Sometimes I don't measure my words very well before "popping off." Kiss Kiss :)