The Game Table, Update #2
By CosmicConservativeWow, did you know that overhead projectors were complex optical devices? I had no idea...
I picked up an overhead projector for $20 (a new one costs from $150 - $350 or more). I could have gotten one for $10 but there were complications in the transaction (someone else had promised to buy it, but didn't show up, then called again.... ) and I ended up not buying it. Driving out to pick it up would likely have cost me another $10 or so anyway. The one I got is an old tank-like Bell and Howell model. For the purposes I'm going to put it to, it's probably a much better option than a new plastic-bodied model.
I also picked up a used 14.1 inch LCD monitor for $30 or so. Added to my lens I purchased last week (but which hasn't shown up yet) that's a total of $57.50 so far. I still need to figure out what wood I'm going to use to build it, I've got a lot of scrap wood, but I'm not sure I can get by without buying some lumber. But the largest remaining expense is almost certainly the acrylic top I am going to have to have on the top of the table. That may be as much as $20 all by itself, although I'm hoping I can find one cheaper.
My initial design isn't going to work. The dang overhead projector was about 2.5 inches taller than I expected, which will make the image just about that much too high to be comfortable to play. So I'm back to using a mirror to reflect the image up to the table and mounting the OP sideways. That will complicate the design of the optical path, but will simplify the design of the table top. Still it will end up being more complex overall... But not too much. I'll post the new design once I've modified it.
Back to the complexity of overhead projectors... See, I knew that OPs used a fresnel lens. Anyone who has ever worked with an OP remembers the concentric rings that are visible under the glass where the transparencies are placed. That's the fresnel lens. But I made a significant assumption that turned out to be wrong. I thought the fresnel was designed to collimate the light, sending a beam straight up through the glass instead of spreading throughout the room.
Well, it turns out that OP makers are smarter than that. They use a more powerful fresnel lens which actually concentrates the light back into a cone that meets the lower lens of the overhead part of the projector. It's really rather ingenious. And obvious, now that I realized it.
But it creates a problem for me. Since the light is in a cone focused on the overhead part, it ends up being twice as high as I need it to be for my purposes, and the result is that the light from the edges of the image simply miss my lens more or less entirely, creating an image that drops off rapidly after a bright central portion.
So that means that overhead projectors fresnel lenses are designed in a way that won't work with my lens position. And if I move my lens out to where it is designed to provide full illumination of the entire staging area, well, that means my optical path is going to be 45" long, which is way too long to try to work with, even with mirrors.
The obvious answer is to get an even more powerful fresnel lens that will lower the light cone to where I need it to be. But guess what? They don't make fresnel lenses with a 3.75" focal length to fit an overhead projector. And even if they did, they would cost more than I spent for the lens and OP together. Which would blow my budget.
So what's a gadget-obsessed tinkerer like me to do?
Well, one option is to try to change the nature of the light that the fresnel lens is refracting. My theory is that if I place a diffusing layer between the fresnel lens and the OP bulb, that will actually become the light source for all practical purposes, and the fresnel lens will no longer be refracting from the bulb back to the lens, but from the diffusing light source to the lens. That essentially will shorten the light cone by about half. Or so I hope.
So I put some wax paper under the fresnel lens and fired it up. Bingo, a slightly dimmer image, but the light cone was now roughly where I needed it and the full field of view was illuminated. But wax paper melts. So I need to find something that will provide the diffusing behavior I need, and is translucent enough to be bright enough to form an image, and is tough enough not to burn or melt in the blistering hot interior of an overhead projector... Oh, and it has to be about as thick as a couple of index cards on top of each other. At least to fit in the existing mounting it does. If I have to I can mount something thicker below the mounting, but that wouldn't be nearly as elegant as I want it to be.
So, once I get all that figured out, I need to design a lens/mirror combination that moves the lens and mirror together. Which is, of course, exactly what the OP's "overhead" part does, but it's lenses are not nearly strong enough for my needs. So I'm still working on it....
Comments (0)
No comments on this post.