Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Awesome Cosmic Theory Dude!!!

By CosmicConservative
Garrett Lisi, 39, has a doctorate but no university affiliation and spends most of the year surfing in Hawaii, where he has also been a hiking guide and bridge builder (when he slept in a jungle yurt). In winter, he heads to the mountains near Lake Tahoe, Nevada, where he snowboards. "Being poor sucks," Lisi says. "It's hard to figure out the secrets of the universe when you're trying to figure out where you and your girlfriend are going to sleep next month." Despite this unusual career path, his proposal is remarkable because, by the arcane standards of particle physics, it does not require highly complex mathematics. Even better, it does not require more than one dimension of time and three of space, when some rival theories need ten or even more spatial dimensions and other bizarre concepts. And it may even be possible to test his theory, which predicts a host of new particles, perhaps even using the new Large Hadron Collider atom smasher that will go into action near Geneva next year. Although the work of 39 year old Garrett Lisi still has a way to go to convince the establishment, let alone match the achievements of Albert Einstein, the two do have one thing in common: Einstein also began his great adventure in theoretical physics while outside the mainstream scientific establishment, working as a patent officer, though failed to achieve the Holy Grail, an overarching explanation to unite all the particles and forces of the cosmos.
He bases his theory on a geometrical shape represented in this two-dimensional diagram, but actually existing in a few dozen dimensions. e8.jpg (click on the image to see a large diagram). Then there's this story:
A scientist has put forward the bizarre suggestion that there are two dimensions of time, not the one that we are all familiar with, and even proposed a way to test his heretical idea next year. Time is no longer a simple line from the past to the future, in a four dimensional world consisting of three dimensions of space and one of time. Instead, the physicist envisages the passage of history as curves embedded in a six dimensions, with four of space and two of time. "There isn't just one dimension of time," Itzhak Bars of the University of Southern California in Los Angeles tells New Scientist. "There are two. One whole dimension of time and another of space have until now gone entirely unnoticed by us."
Now I really like the surfer-dude theory, although I cannot claim to understand it. I do understand enough to know that he has returned to the very core of physics by using pure symmetry arguments as a foundation for his theory. Over the course of physics, symmetry has been one of the most profoundly powerful tools used to explain everything from the laws of motion to general relativity. I tend to stand up and take more notice of theories that have such deep-rooted symmetrical roots. BUT, the MAIN thing I like about both of these theories is that they are both directly challenging "string theory" dogma and addressing the key issues I have with "string theory" which are: 1. String "theory" is NOT a "theory" in the scientific use of the word "theory." It's more a "hypothesis". 2. String "theory" is not falsifiable, and so far has proven to be untestable, meaning that it remains in the realm of meta-physics as far as I am concerned. Both of these new theories (although both need work to actually qualify as a "theory" but I think they'll get there) do predict testable outcomes. So in that sense both of these are better "science" than string theory whether they turn out to be on the right track or not.

Comments (10)

pace
Way above my head, but intensely fascinating nonetheless. I am trying to understand more about this E8 pattern..
Dadman
Did the surfer-dude develop his theory using a spirograph? Who remembers those things?
CosmicConservative
Heh, I almost made a spirograph reference when I posted. I loved spirographs. We got one for our kids when they were younger. It's probably still around here somewhere. I knew that one day that game was going to explain life, the universe and everything. The reason I didn't end up doing it is because I couldn't keep the gears in the circles long enough to complete a complex enough pattern...
Andy
Cosmic: There ya' go, showin' off again! We could never afford a spirograph when our kids were little.
ams182764
I would think a whole physical dimension in the non-metaphorical, non-mathematical-substitute-for-something-else sense of the word would have to be something pretty hard to miss. Even if none of the matter on our subspace of the whole moves in those directions, it should be possible for stuff to intrude across it, or for conjugate pairs to form in reactions and "vanish" from our slice of the universe. So I'm waiting for math to formally describe string theory AND this guy's new idea, and provide a way to demonstrate the existence of these other dimensions. Hopefully as directly as possible.
ams182764
PS - math is a prerequisite for simulation. You need math to generate quantifiable expectations for an experiment, even if the expectation is as crude as the sign of a number. If the math is equivalent to the math describing current physics (sets of quantities that can be mutually transformed to each other, for example), then the two are essentially identical and nothing different is predicted.
ams182764
And about these other spatial dimensions, barring said metaphorical-ness or special-ness of the dimension, they should exhibit quite a few properties, such as influencing the divergence of just about everything (effecting everything from fluid dynamics to wave propogation) and rotation - there should be a way to freely rotate between these sets of dimensions, and hence we should expect the universe to be indifferent to the distribution of matter and energy within them, leading to outside matter freely crossing our subspace. (plus I'm pretty sure off the top of my head that it should factor into the rotation of an oblate object somehow)
ams182764
Also, in 4 dimensions the cross product is a trinary operator. We would require a whole other aspect to anything involving the cross product to come into play for it to be uniquely defined.
ams182764
Hmm, well I got to his paper and he does appear to be describe what he's thinking in very specific mathematical relationships. Now I'll have to start really paying attention to what it all implies.
ams182764
PPPPPPS - I find it annoying that the popularization of his theory makes it impossible to distinguish from that of any other kook having an "epiphany" from looking at a spirograph. We had another of these popularizations just the other day about some guy's "perpetual motion machine" driven by microwaving water. Same tone, same credulity, same total lack of real information content applied to ideas of completely different potential merit. And they're still hanging themselves up in denial on the grandfather "paradox" - an error in human perspective, not in any coherently described system.