Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

ESPN - Barry Bonds indicted on perjury, obstruction charges - MLB

By CosmicConservative
ESPN - Barry Bonds indicted on perjury, obstruction charges - MLB SAN FRANCISCO -- Barry Bonds was indicted Thursday for perjury and obstruction of justice, charged with lying when he told a federal grand jury that he did not knowingly use performance-enhancing drugs. The indictment, unsealed Thursday by federal prosecutors in San Francisco, is the culmination of a four-year federal probe into whether he lied under oath to a grand jury investigating steroid use by elite athletes.
So, do we need an asterisk now? Or do we wait for a conviction?

Comments (8)

Andy
Okay...we do not need an asterisk. A while back, I heard Tommy Lasorda talking about Bonds. He said that he would never use his vote to put Barry into the HOF. I suspect that Tommy is in the HUGE majority. I would not be surprised to see MLB expunge Barry completely...maybe even buy up his rookie cards on Ebay. No sane baseball fan could possibly believe that Bonds didn't "drug up" to pass the great Hank Aaron...or the Babe...or even his godfather, Willie Mays. We all remember that he was "washed up" 6 or 7 years ago. It's a darned shame for Barry, but this kind of prosecution is ridiculous. Why do you expend the resources of the court...the time of the people on the grand jury...and no telling how many thousands of hours of investigation by federal prosecutors on something as stupid as Barry Bonds and steroids? YOUR TAX DOLLARS AT WORK!
Drax
I'm all for spending tax dollars to prosecute people who lie and obstruct justice in a criminal investigation. Barry will almost assuredly make the Hall, maybe even on the first ballot (depending on who is on the list at the time he is eligible). Whatever asterisk which might exist on his records will be mental ones only.
CosmicConservative
Why would major league baseball HOF voters reward Barry Bonds for his illegal behavior while continuing to punish Pete Rose for his? If you say that Pete Rose's gambling on baseball undermines the fundamental integrity of the game, what do you call using drugs to artificially enhance performance? Which of the two do you think actually affected the outcome of more games, or had a bigger impact on baseball history? It doesn't make sense that one would be punished and the other rewarded.
Drax
Well, there are a couple of things: 1.) Steroids weren't against the rules of MLB when he was taking them; gambling was against the rules of MLB when Rose gambled. 2.) Absent evidence that he took steriods prior to 1998 (really 2001, I think) a time when he would be a 1st ballot HOF'er, his subsequent actions (especially when there were so many doing likewise -- including those who were pitching to him) shouldn't disqualify him. I HATE Barry. I HATE it that steroids and other performance enhancing drugs are/were so ubiquituous in all sports. But, while gambling on the sport brings into question the integrity of the game itself, the use of performance enhancing drugs does not, rather, those who use it are (one would think) doing it to be BETTER...to WIN, whereas gambling could be such that people purposely lose. Different crimes.
CosmicConservative
Steroids were against the LAW when Barry Bonds took them. Gambling on baseball wasn't against the law when Pete Rose did it. To me that sounds like putting rules of a game on a higher ethical plane than actual statutes of law. I don't think I agree with that. As far as I know Pete Rose's proven gambling all took place well after he broke Ty Cobb's hits record. So why should his gambling keep him from the Hall of Fame if the timing of when he did it was after he achieved the levels that should have granted him the honor? I absolutely disagree that taking steroids does not bring into question the integrity of the game. I think it brings into question the integrity of the very athletic performance of the individual upon which the game itself is based. Nobody will argue that gambling can make a player perform better in order to affect the outcome of a game. Gambling is always associated with an athlete purposefully performing WORSE than they are capable, in order to "throw" a game to win a bet. Steroids turn a long fly ball into a home run, throwing a game turns a home run into a long fly ball. There is virtually no difference to me in the effect on the "integrity" of the game in both cases. Games that should have been won are lost, and games that should have been lost are won, based on the unfair, unethical performance of the person who is violating the rule or law. I really don't see any difference. I'm not making a judgment call on whether Barry SHOULD be in the Hall or Pete SHOULD NOT, I'm just saying that to me the argument for both is pretty much the same, so if one gets in and the other doesn't, I think that means there is something else going on than the first-order analysis would indicate.
Drax
I wasn't attempting to make a case for keeping Rose out...rather a case for allowing Bonds in, distinguishing between the crimes they committed against baseball. Behavior which is "illegal" hasn't been any bar to being voted into the Hall. (See,e.g., Orlando Cepeda...) Gambling, due to the Black Sox scandal, occupies a unique place in Baseball, giving to that activity a special "don't do this" that NO other activity has. I agree that steroids puts into question the individual performances...but not the fundamental integrity of the GAME, i.e., whether one can trust that the result on the field is the result of the people on the field actually TRYING to win, rather than trying to LOSE.
CosmicConservative
OK, here is what I can see in the argument that could mean gambling is "worse." Not that I agree with it, but I can see this in the argument.
If you are betting on a baseball game, and someone in the game is taking steroids, their enhanced performance is, in effect, "factored in" to the odds, so that the actual bet still is "fair" because Barry is going to try to hit home runs and his 'roided up body is going to deliver them at a "predictable" rate based on his past performance (while taking steroids) so the bet is only affected by how well he and the other players succeed in their attempts to do the best they can. So the "bet" isn't affected by the outcome, preserving the integrity of the act of gambling on the game. BUT, if someone on the team is purposefully UNDER-performing, that is throwing off the odds for the specific purpose of having a different outcome than the odds would predict.
OK, I see that argument. I don't like that argument because what it says to me is that gambling is more important than the game itself. And I just don't like to think about what that actually means about baseball (or other sports) in our society, and our society in general. It's like the whole "we can't forfeit the Patriots game against the Jets because that would cause the international gambling market to go all higgledy-piggledy". I can see that it is probably necessary to think that way, but I seriously, profoundly don't like it.