Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Obsessive/Compulsive

By CosmicConservative
Is this obsessive compulsive behavior? Everyone has their hobbies. I have too many, but one that I spend a lot of time on is role-playing games. And although I am not currently running a campaign, I do run a lot of them. For years I have contemplated means to use the computer to make the job of running a role-playing game easier. There are all the obvious ways to do it, all of which I've done off and on, including using the computer to look up critical data quickly and to maintain updated records of players' and NPC characters. But the most convenience I've gotten out of the computer over the years has been in creating, saving and updating the never-ending horde of maps that are needed to play. That culminated in my last campaign in me spending $20 on printing out a huge map for the final campaign-ending confrontation. I did that because it gets very old drawing maps on white board, or trying to describe details verbally. That sort of thing really slows down the action, and action is what it's all about. So one of my fellow DMs and I have been discussing for about a year the creation of what can effectively be called a "computer gaming table" which would create a dynamic game-play environment where you could literally use the table as an extension of your laptop. There are some folks who have done this. I saw one a few weeks ago. He had used a high-quality LCD projector which he had mounted on a large vertical scaffold that he had tweaked to look like a guillotine. In fact he called it the guillotine. I'd post a photo of it, but I don't have his permission to do so and would prefer to make sure he is OK with it. But imagine a guillotine with a projector and a mirror at the top and you'll get a pretty good idea of what it looks like. The device (and I use "device" in a technical sense, a more proper word might be the "imposing construction") projects a computer image down onto the table and allows the players to place their miniatures on the table in a dynamic grid. So as he manages the game, he either scrolls the map around, or pops up other maps, or even just pulls up relevant photos (he might pull up a photo of a mountain range to give the players a visual of what the area there characters are in looks like). All of this happens right in front of the players on the table in real time. I was really impressed. But it had two major problems from my perspective. 1. The projector itself must have cost near $1,000, throw in the wood and other materials used to make the guillotine and he probably had near $1,500 invested in the thing. 2. The device is literally huge, it's about seven feet tall and includes a built-in desk for him to sit at. It looks like it probably takes two or three people to move it around and set it up. 3. (Yes, I know I said two...) The projected image creates shadows and can be obstructed by people leaning over the table to manipulate their miniatures. So for two weeks now we (my DM buddy, who used to frequent this blog but has not been around much lately, and I) have been working through ways to do this without taking a second mortgage out on our houses. And I think I have a way to do it on the cheap. Basically it is a whole lot like a Do It Yourself Projector (which is why I posted the earlier message on that subject). Here is what you do: 1. Find a cheap old LCD monitor, preferably one that has cosmetic damage or has the backlight burned out so you can get it cheap. Currently I'm watching several on eBay in the $20 - $40 range. 2. Find a light source that provides bright, even illumination, much brighter than a standard LCD screen so you can project it and have it be readable in normal lighting situations. Currently I am thinking the best way to do this is to get an old overhead projector, hopefully for about $10 (I found one for $10 in Boulder, but the owner has one other person who expressed interest shortly before I did, so he's giving him one day to make up his mind on purchasing it. Regardless I think it should be possible to get one fairly cheap.) 3. Build a table that houses the overhead projector and LCD and projects the image UPWARDS to a plexiglass or plate glass top where the image is viewable, but is not projected from above. That's something that will just have to be built, and the most expensive part of it will likely be the large plexiglass or plate glass top. The goal is to have that be at least 20" x 24" so that it is a large and inviting play area. Now, I have gone so far as to build a small prototype to prove the concepts work. Basically I have a fresnel lens I purchased for $2.50 and I've used some things I had laying around the house (including a suitable lens, I actually have lots of lenses laying around the house). The result was of a high enough quality that I am now pretty much determined to complete this effort. But that means I spent about four hours yesterday and a few more today scouring the internet for overhead projectors and LCD screens. So now I am using Excel to do optical calculations, and am trying to find the cheapest ways to get the components I need. If I can get my hands on them, then I'm going to build the table and put it on wheels so I can move it around easily. The end result I envision will be a long, skinny table with the plexiglass viewable area, and large "wings" that swing up on each side for play space once I get it through doors. Basically think of a large fold-out card table with a power and VGA monitor cable coming out of it. The overhead projector will be mounted directly under the center of the table, on its side, with the image being projected up to the table. The resulting image should be bright enough (I hope) so that highly detailed images will be viewable on the top of the table. If this works out, then people could lean all over the table without having any shadows obscure anything, and it would react just like an external monitor to show anything I wanted it to show. So, how obsessive is it to spend hours doing calculations and design layouts for something this weird? If I can get the components I need for under $50, it seems to me to be a huge win. If it does work out, I could easily remove the overhead and put it into a darkened room to watch movies on a very large screen as well. So, am I nuts?

Comments (11)

Andy
Cosmic: The question was: "Is this obsessive compulsive behavior? Yes.
CosmicConservative
Well, I finished the calculations for the optimal focal length to accomplish my goals, and found one to match it for $12 at my favorite optical surplus store. It's an enlarging lens, so it is designed to take a flat object and render an equally flat image, so I have high hopes it will work. I still need the LCD screen... Working on it. And I need the light source. Working on that too. Will keep you all posted on my obsession.... What makes me think that this may be obsessive/compulsive is that I tend to do this, I'll get my mind all wrapped around a project and it will more or less consume my free time for days until I either decide it's too impractical or too costly, or until I actually make the thing I'm obsessing over. Over the years this has led me to make furniture, telescopes, games, clothes, artwork and even food. If it is obsessive/compulsive behavior, I have to think there is something positive in that condition since I have enjoyed the heck out of most of the things I have made. Now one day I'll get back to that homemade guitar....
Andy
Cosmic: OC behavior is always positive, if the victim has a good heart and motive. I think that you do. You could be a lazy under-achiever...like some people we know ;) Hey...if you still care to build furniture, you might want to check out Hillary's insurance of her legs... http://www.thepeoplescube.com/red/viewtopic.php?t=1518
Dadman
Why does it really matter what we or anyone else thinks about your obsessive behavior. I personally would not spend that much time figuring out a way to improve my D&D campaigns (because I don't play D&D), but hey, you've got to follow your own bliss... My current time consuming projects include: digitizing and cataloging all of my family videos, transcribing my personal journals for publication (via blurb.com), little league baseball games... Oh yes, and getting ready for a February wedding of my oldest daughter...
CosmicConservative
"Little League Baseball." Where do you live? The Bahamas? It's ice skating on the frozen lakes around here... I don't so much care what you think about my obsessive behavior, I just wonder if it really IS obsessive/compulsive. Seriously, do other people get so wrapped up in a project like this that they literally do algebra in their heads while driving to work out things like optimal optical paths? Or am I the only one?
Andy
Dadman: February wedding? It might be all the way down to 75 degrees in Phoenix by then...
Kevin in WI
Well, wouldn't that new fangled whatchamatable that is supposed to change the world that Microsoft came out with a few months ago do the job?
CosmicConservative
Actually my DM buddy and I figured they stole the idea from us. But you think Microsoft is going to sell that thing for less than $100? That's my goal for this. $100 or less. If money were no object, I'd just buy a $1,600 LCD projector and be done with it.
Dadman
The problems I tend to obsess over are visual design problems and tend not to require much algebra. When I was quarterbacking my college flag football team I would obsess over the Xs and Os of the plays we were running. When I was coaching my son's baseball team I found myself dreaming about line-up variables the night before games. I obsessed over my daughter's swimming which led me to create spreadsheets charting her progress in various events. I could go on... We all have our obsessions I guess.