Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

ESPN - Maddux earns record 17th Gold Glove - MLB

By CosmicConservative
This is great news, both the Gold Glove and the contract extension. Another year for Maddux at least!!
ESPN - Maddux earns record 17th Gold Glove - MLB Greg Maddux now stands alone among Rawlings Gold Glove winners after earning his record-setting 17th defensive award Tuesday. Maddux, 41, broke his Gold Glove tie with former third baseman Brooks Robinson and former pitcher Jim Kaat to highlight the list of 2007 winners, as voted on by the managers and coaches in each league. The San Diego Padres right-hander, who reportedly agreed to a one-year, $10 million deal Monday, has now won four Gold Gloves in a row and 17 in 18 years, all in the National League, to go along with his 347 major league victories, four Cy Young awards and one World Series title.
This, however is a travesty:
NL Gold Glove: SS Jimmy Rollins
It's hard to even appreciate Maddux's record Gold Glove when the award is tarnished so thoroughly by giving it to a man who came in second place or worse in EVERY FIELDING CATEGORY to Rockies Rookie shortstop Troy Tulowitzki. This is an embarrassment to the league, to sports in general, and to the human capacity for reason and fairness. Just to be sure you get the message, check out the concluding paragraph of the story:
While the Mets, Braves, Phillies, Twins, Tigers and Mariners each had two Gold Glovers, one team not represented among the winners was the Colorado Rockies, which set a major league record with a .989 fielding percentage in 2007.
Booooooo!!!!!

Comments (17)

Andy
Cosmic: We was robbed! Tulowitzki should definitely have been awarded the GG. Well, we can take solace in the fact that Cabrera didn't play in The Series, and is heading into the "old age" of baseball. Tulowitzki is the real deal... If we didn't have football right now, I would say "I can't wait 'til next Spring." The Rockies are much better than anyone will give them credit for. But you know that it doesn't really matter who gets credit, as long as the job gets done. Cabrera will fade away as all old guys do. Troy will have his "day in the sun" soon. If history is true to form, Troy will win several GG's and a Golden Glove 10 years from now that he really doesn't deserve. That is just the way things go. Hopefully he won't win all of his Golden Gloves playing for Boston (we hate them). I have to take issue with you on one thing. MadDog's Golden Glove can never be diminished by the bad decisions of MLB (leaving the Rockies Golden Gloveless). You are treading on dangerous ground...thin ice...(pick your own "worn out" expression). Maddux can never be subjected to the miserable, lowly standards of MLB. Greg is other-worldly (I guess I have a man-crush).
CosmicConservative
Heh, I don't use phrases like "man-crush" because they belittle the proper word, which is "respect." I have tons of respect for Greg Maddux. In a period that will one day be known as the "steroid-soaked" era, when pitchers I won't name (Clemens...) used steroids themselves, Greg Maddux set record after record by PITCHING the ball past those chemically enhanced, over-muscled freaks of nature that were blasting the ball out of the park in historically ridiculous numbers. Had Maddux pitched in an era where human beings were swinging at his pitches (and other pitchers were also human beings) he would have been acknowledged as one of the greatest pitchers in history already. The one year he did not win a gold glove in the NL (ex-Rockie Mike Hampton won it in 2003) you could make a strong argument that he deserved it that year too, but that people were hoping Hampton would become a perennial winner himself, which never panned out. Maddux is one of the great pitchers of all time. And he never threw the ball much more than 90mph, even in his heyday. I think that's awesome. Today he throws in the mid-80s and still wins.
Andy
Cosmic: Okay, I understand, and agree with the term "respect"...but I still have tons of a man-crush on Maddux. He is the second best pitcher I have watched in my baseball-watching life...well maybe the best. The other guy was just as great, but with a really different approach to pitching. I am really glad that MadDog is coming back to pitch again next season. The only bad thing about his new $10 million contract is that it will set him back another year going into the HOF. I think they should waive the rules for guys like Maddux. He should be able to announce his retirement at his induction ceremony.
CosmicConservative
I messed up anyway, in my anger I grabbed the wrong short stop. I better go fix that. Cabrera is in the AL. Duh.
Andy
Well, that one went right over my head, too. He's with the Angels...is that right? The other pitcher was Nolan Ryan. I don't want any arguments about it, either. I love finesse guys like Maddux. But I really love intimidation guys like Ryan. I know that Clemens, and Gibson, and on and on, could be considered more intimidating, but Ryan is best in my book. It's a toss-up in my mind between those two.
CosmicConservative
No arguments? Who do you think you are dealing with? I do put Nolan Ryan in the same category as Clemens or Gibson, and Nolan may have finally won 300 games, but he lost nearly as many as he won.
Andy
Damn right he lost almost as many as he won...a microcosm of all the rest of us. But he would throw at the head of a guy he thought was going to go yard on him. He would rather give up a HBP than a homer. My kind of guy. And, yes I know who I am dealing with...
Andy
Cosmic: Ryan was to me the kind of pitcher that my Dad and Granddaddy told me about when I was a little kid. They didn't have a great understanding of the game, but they did understand that winning was as much about intimidation as performance (my words, not theirs). Ryan always seemed to me like the kind of guy that went to the mound with the goal of making a batter pee his pants. I always imagined that Nolan was thinking "okay...I need to make this guy at the plate wonder if his helmet is thick enough to avoid brain damage, or if my next pitch will shatter his elbow or knee, and end his career." I don't have the stats, and don't really care to look them up but...I would bet that Ryan threw as many no-hitters as anyone. I would bet that Ryan lost more 1-0 games than anyone. I would bet that Ryan was lifted in the late innings of more 0-0 games than anyone. And, I would bet that Ryan showed up for practice early...did his job without controversy...kept his mouth shut when he was hurting, or thought he was playing for a stupid Manager...helped the terrible teams he played for sell tickets (and be less terrible)...didn't take 7 months off every year, only to take a mid-season job for millions (like Clemens does every season)... Plus, he's bald...and doesn't sell his name for Hair Restoration Clinic. He's just my kind of guy. But it is a toss-up between Nolan and Greg.
Drax
Ryan had 7 no-hitters, 3 more than anyone else (Koufax had 4 in his injury shortened career, no one else with more than 3...)
CosmicConservative
And Maddux had zero. What does that tell us? It tells us that pitchers who throw no-hitters don't win any more frequently than pitchers who don't.
Andy
Cosmic: I didn't know that Maddux never threw a no-hitter. And, you are exactly right! Guys that throw no-hitters don't eclipse guys that don't in wins. I don't know the career percentages, but I would bet that Maddux's is far above Nolan's...but I would also bet that Maddux helped himself with the bat more than Nolan...not sure, but I think probably. Maybe I should revise my remark that Maddux and Ryan are "the best" pitchers I have watched. I probably should have said that in my baseball watching years, Maddux and Ryan are the most interesting, and entertaining pitchers to watch. The styles are so different, but they are both extremely hard workers...really focused on using their particular style to mess with the mind of the hitter...and real competitors. It would be hard to find two guys that hate to lose as much as Nolan did...and as Greg does still. They are my two favorites for multiple reasons.
Andy
Okay, I finally decided to do some research. Maddux has a .619 career winning pct. Ryan's is .526. Almost .100 is a big difference. But Ryan played 27 seasons. Maddux has pitched 21 years now...If he pitches 6 more years will that winning pct. difference be a little closer? I think probably so. I would love to see Greg pitch 6 more years...the win numbers could be mind-boggling, regardless of the career win pct. Just from memory, I think that Greg has played with much better teams than Nolan did, so the win/loss difference could be due to the pure power of the guys behind you. (Not dissin' Greg here...just a thought) Their ERA stats are almost identical. Ryan has a career 3.19, and Maddux a career 3.11. Again, I wonder how 6 more years at his age would change Greg's stat (as impressive as it is). The batting avg. allowed stat is vital. Maddux has only allowed a .217 in his career...darned impressive. Ryan is the King. He allowed a .203...damned impressive. But, Maddux pitched a good number of games at Coors...and at Enron Field (they have changed the name, but you know...the new stadium in Houston), and at other NL parks that seem to me to be easier for a hitter than AL parks. Those were true hitters parks, so his .217 avg. allowed could have been as low, or nearly as low as Ryan's .203. I mean, Ryan pitched several years in the Astrodome, and at the BiG A...the pitcher's best friends. Again, the "wild card" is Ryan's 6 extra years...out there pitching as an old man against young arms, and legs. Maddux definitely helped himself with the glove and the bat much more than Ryan did...but Ryan pitched several seasons with a DH (so you have to measure the talent of his AL teams against the league at the time...the other pitcher had a DH, too). And, you have to measure the strength of the AL vs. NL during the years that Ryan switched back and forth. So, the conclusion is that it would take a stinkin' genius to really figure out which was better. So, I conclude that those two guys were just really fun to watch.
CosmicConservative
Hmm.... nothing like a baseball argument... ;) Andy, I respect you tremendously, and I think that Nolan Ryan was one of the better pitchers of my youth. But to suggest that Nolan Ryan and Greg Maddux are comparable pitchers is simply not credible. The difference between a career win %age of 62% and 52% is not just "100 points." Applied to 500 games it's the difference between 310 wins and 260 wins. That's a difference of fifty wins. Throw out Ryan's strike outs and no hitters, and that's the difference between "Hall of Fame" and "old timers game." It's the difference between being 120 wins over .500 and being 20 wins over. Maddux may have had several years with a good Atlanta club, but he also had lots of years with the mediocre Chicago Cubs. And before Maddux got to Atlanta, that team was decidely mediocre. The argument that Maddux benefited from a Braves team that helped pitchers win falls a little flat when you realize that the Braves were mediocre at best in their hitting, they won because they had the best pitching rotation in the league, a rotation that Greg Maddux anchored for nearly a decade. The rest of the team did not win games for Greg Maddux, Greg Maddux won games for the rest of the team. Nolan Ryan had a stretch of three or six years, depending on if you count a 14 win season in 1975, where he was one of the game's elite pitchers in terms of wins. Greg Maddux's stretch of belonging to the "elite pitchers" club went for 18 years before he won "only" 13 games, to follow that up with two more years of at least 14 wins. That alone is a stunning statistic. Maddux was a top pitcher at least 3 times as long, and I would say 15 wins is the real test, and using that he was an elite pitcher SIX times as long as Nolan Ryan was. Other than the stretch from 1972 to 1977 (which roughly coincided with our High School years, coincidentally) Ryan won as many as 15 games only three times (and 16 was the most he won). That means in his entire career he won 15 or more games a total of 8 times. Maddux won at least 15 games EIGHTEEN TIMES, and won 14 games twice more. Since his sophomore year he has never won less than 13 games in a season. But let's look at one of the reasons that Maddux wins so much more than Ryan. Walks is a big reason. Maddux has averaged 44 walks per year over 22 years. His worst year he walked 88. This year, at the age of 41, he walked 25. Nolan averaged 104 walks per year. He AVERAGED 16 walks more than Maddux's WORST year. In one year he walked 204 batters. That's FIVE YEARS worth of Greg Maddux walks. So what about strikeouts? Ryan averaged 211 SOs per year. Maddux averaged 149. Ryan struck out his batter 42% more frequently than Maddux. But Ryan walked his batter 136% more frequently than Maddux. Maddux walked an average of 1.37 batters per game and struck out an average of 4.63. Nolan Ryan walked an average of 3.62 batters per game and struck out an average of 7.4. When you factor in their nearly identical batting average against, that means that Ryan allowed more than two runners per game than Maddux did. If you want my personal opinion, I would bet that those two runners per game go a long way to explaining the difference in their winning percentage. By the way, as good as a strike out is, it's not common to get a double play with one. I liked Nolan Ryan, in spite of his style of pitching, which I generally do not like. But Nolan Ryan is a top 100, perhaps a top 50 pitcher in MLB history. Greg Maddux is a top 5, perhaps a top 3. That's the difference between them in my opinion. Heh...
Andy
Cosmic: I didn't suggest that they are comparable pitchers. In fact, I think I suggested that they were completely different in style, and played in completely different circumstances for the most part. I had revised my remarks by saying: "I probably should have said that in my baseball watching years, Maddux and Ryan are the most interesting, and entertaining pitchers to watch." And you are right about the walks. If Ryan had had a little better control, he probably would have won 360. But that was his style...that little bit of hardball wildness that kept batters off-stride. I'll go with you on a top 5, or top 3 for Maddux. But come on, at least give Nolan a top 20. Come on, Nolan loves you...give the guy a break!
CosmicConservative
Top 20? Let's see... Cy Young Christy Mathewson Walter Johnson Greg Maddux Roger Clemens Kid Nichols Sandy Koufax Warren Spahn Bob Gibson Lefty Grove ... Hm... I'm already to the "Tom Seaver" or "Steve Carlton" level.... so yeah, I'll give you that Nolan Ryan is top 20. Maybe even top 15. Just not quite top ten...
Andy
Roger Clemens? Sorry, not a Clemens fan. Don't get me wrong, he is a great pitcher, but I would bet that no one has had more "balls" called for "strikes" than Clemens has in the history of the game...well, I can think of one more guy (but I dare not blaspheme). If Nolan had friendly umps like Clemens has had, then he would be in the top two. Besides, Clemens is lazy. He retires every year or two so that he won't have to go to camp. He can goof around and play golf until June, then come back "one more time," for millions...while the rest of the guys have busted their rear-ends to win for months. Regardless, I appreciate you giving Nolan a top-20. He loves you man...I will let him know...it will mean a lot to him. ;)