Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Cosmic's Narnia Review

By CosmicConservative
OK, just got back from The Lion, The Witch and the Wardrobe. I'll try to avoid spoilers, but can't promise anything. First, the theater was full, we were early and still had to get seats in the front of the theater, which meant craning my neck for the whole movie. I loved the start of the movie, with the bombers flying over London. This was something that CS Lewis simply assumed his readers would know and immediately understand, but was not described in the book itself. For audiences today who might wonder why four kids would be sent away from their mother, the terrifying bombing sequence put some rationale behind that basic story device. Beyond that, it allowed for the demonstration of the sibling rivalry between Peter and Edmund that becomes so critical later in the story. Overall I was surprised by how well the story stuck to the book itself. Having just read the book last week, I was pretty familiar with the story and feel that I spotted most of the differences between the book and the movie. In general I would have to say that I thought the movie did a good job of fleshing out parts of the story that the book should have expanded. The Christian symbolism was quite evident, even heavy-handed, but so it was in the book. I think CS Lewis would have approved of this movie. I won't go into the story, but if you haven't read the book you will probably find parts of the movie straining your willingness to suspend disbelief. Peter's remarkable swordcraft being perhaps the most obvious example. But those same parts strained suspension of disbelief in the book too, so I don't hold that against the movie, that's just part of the story, and after all, it is a children's story, for and about children. The story was definitely a slow-starter, and developed slowly right up to the battle where it finally took off. The battle scenes were almost ignored in the book, but were lifted to prominence in the movie, which I thought was the right choice. The battle scene action was excellent, although not up to LOTR levels of grandeur and carnage. But much better than I had expected. But I wish they had shown Peter leading more of the battle and acting more like a general instead of a foot-soldier. Aslan was a bit of a disappointment to me. He should have been more dynamic. Liam Neeson may be a fine dramatic actor but his voice work came across as disembodied to me. On occasion he came across as ponderous. His mightiest roars also seemed a bit flat to me, they should have shook the ground and rattled the trees. The close shots with Aslan were some of the few times that the computer animation intruded into the story. Of the kids I felt that all of them did passable jobs, although I found Susan to be more irritating than appealing. Tumnus, the faun, was among the characters I thought had been handled the best, although I forget the actor's name. The score was competent, but did not inspire me the way it should have during the climactic moments of the movie. Still, I liked it. My family really liked it, and my wife now says she plans to read the book. I suggested that she read The Lord of the Rings instead, but that's just my bias speaking. There are definitely some rough moments in the movie for younger children, and some of the Witch's followers were suitably grotesque, but overall the story is uplifting and carries a solid message of hope, courage, loyalty and redemption. Of those, the least common quality found in movies these days is probably redemption, and TLTWATW does a fine job of showing the power of redemption, and the price.

Comments (0)

No comments on this post.