Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Beware the Golden Compass!!

By CosmicConservative
From FoxNews: A children’s fantasy film that stars Nicole Kidman and features a little girl on a quest to kill God has some Christian groups upset over what they believe is a ploy to promote atheism to kids. The movie, “The Golden Compass,” is adapted from the first novel in a trilogy called “His Dark Materials” by English author Philip Pullman, an outspoken atheist. Critics fear that the film, due out in December, will encourage children to read the anti-Church series.
If you read the article you'll see that that author, Philip Pullman, is a devout atheist who "loathes" the Narnia series by C.S. Lewis, and who wrote the "Golden Compass" novels to attempt to offset the Narnia books. I read "The Golden Compass" a long time ago. I thought it was OK. Not great, but not bad either. I didn't like it enough to go read the sequels, so apparently I missed out on a great opportunity to examine an atheistic indoctrination attempt. The Cosmic Daughter, a good Catholic girl, has read all of them and enjoyed them thoroughly, but she either did not catch the atheistic overtones, or else she simply enjoyed the story without caring about the implied theology. The Cosmic Son is reading them right now. These furors raised over books because of the politics, ideology or theology of the author usually just make me laugh. To me both sides are just working themselves up into a frenzy for nothing. Books are powerful means to introduce and reinforce ideology it is true, but not nearly as powerful as parental advice and example. So if your kids read a book like this and turn into atheists, then it's a pretty good bet they weren't far from atheism before they read it. I may go ahead and read the other books, just to see what my kids have gotten into. Hat tip on this story to Pace... who was reading Fox News? really?

Comments (24)

pace
So my thoughts on this were firstly to thank the 'Christian groups' behind this story for alerting me to the existence of these books. I was aware of the movie (thanks to CC) but did not realize it was based on a series of novels. I'll be sure to read them. ;) And secondly I'll just make the observation that I do not recall any atheist lobby groups petitioning against the recent Narnia movie and noting that it subversively waters-down Lewis' Christian message. I'm sure they were out there, but likely not being given a national platform on which to gnash and wail. Really, I don't see what the fuss is about. Sure, the underlying message of the books will prove extremely offensive to some people who will undoubtedly make a point not to read them. But I wonder if the sort of people who would find such distaste in a fantasy work of fiction grounded in anti-theism would have been reading this type of work anyway. I suspect not. And as you noted, CC most kids and many adults would not pick up on Pullman's underlying agenda. You know.. I was raised in the Church of England schooling system, receiving religious instruction from the age of 5 through 16. I absolutely LOVED the Narnia books as a kid. I still read and enjoy fictional authors like Robert Jordan who draw heavily on monotheistic doctrine and tradition. It hasn't changed the fact that I reject the notion of a supreme being - or certainly of one who can interact with our universe. Incidentally, my parents identify themselves as Christian (like most Brits) but gave us no religious instruction whatsoever, although they did make materials available. I have no doubt that my mother's indifference toward religion allowed me sufficient room to engage critical thinking. My kids will be raised in an atheist household, but our plan is to follow a similar approach. I believe they'll ultimately have access to any PG material that they request. So the fear that religious fundamentalists express toward humanism is baffling to me on many levels. I know that many religious individuals believe that they are under attack from extremely vocal atheist lobby groups, but I try to keep things in perspective. I think it is difficult to be discriminated against in this country when you are in the overwhelming majority, and the dollars available to secular lobby groups are orders of magnitude smaller than that which the religious right has at its disposal. I tend to view Christian alarmism over the prospect of a secular America as just not being borne out in reality. For the record; I'm not a one-news-source kinda guy. Although truth be told, it's my wife who usually alerts me to the interesting stories on Fox. :)
CosmicConservative
Fundamentalists of any stripe (including atheistic ones) live according to an underlying dogma. the more firmly they have placed their personal self-image into that arms of that dogma, the more threatened they are when the dogma is challenged. This is true whether you are atheistic, global warmingist, vegetarianist or humanist. To say that the U.S. is an "overwhelmingly majority" Christian nation is to wander perilously close to the same sort of simplistic view of things as the fundamentalists themselves. Just because a majority of Americans label themselves as "Christian" on a census does not indicate any true commitment to that dogma. My personal opinion is that far more of a majority of Americans actually follow a secular humanist dogma than follow a "Christian" one, especially a "fundamentalist Christian" one. For example, if you took a survey of how many people believe the earth is billions of years old, you'll get a much better view of how "fundamentalist" the majority of Americans really are. I actually do recall a lot of stories complaining about both the Narnia and the LOTR movies. Perhaps it's because I am sensitive to those sorts of stories, but both of those movies got blasted from the Left and the Right. I remember lots of stories about churches telling their members not to go see LOTR because it was all about "wizards and sorcery" which they view as "paganistic" or "demonic." The fact that the books are acknowledged to be deeply Christian stories which use the time-honored techniques of allegory and metaphor to make their point is lost on people like that. From the left the hammering was precisely because the movies were so steeped in religious symbolism. "The Golden Compass" is also getting hammered from both sides, from the Left they are saying that the story has been "watered down" too much to disguise the atheistic symbolism and from the Right they are saying the underlying story is a typical secular humanist attack on religious authority. And you know what? They're both right. And they're both wrong.
pace
That was poor wording on my part. My intent was not to convey that religious fundamentalists are the overwhelming majority in this country, but rather that they are part of a larger group - those who hold to some degree of Christian dogma - who are. What is it, eighty some odd percent of people in this country identify themselves as Christian (I think Atheists are in the low single digits)? Sure, many aspects of our lives might be considered very secular in nature but likewise I'd observe that religion pervades American society in many ways that it does not in many other developed western nations. The church likes to point to destructive and amoral behavior as being some result of removing God from our schools and government, but on the contrary; if anything our cultural icons are more apt to display their supposed faith loud and proud, dangling on the end of a heavy gold chain or decorating the small of their back, while they gyrate their 'booty' on stage or throw a sports tantrum on the sidelines. Religion, faith, spirituality, or the lack thereof all seem to me in practice to play very little role in how a person conducts themselves in their interactions with others. It is something you learn from your parents, whether that be couched in the platform of Christianity or Humanism. My underlying guiding principle is that of reciprocity, not a hope of reward or fear of punishment.
pace
Just a little substantiation of my 'majority' statement: http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,99945,00.html >Fully 92 percent of Americans say they believe in God, 85 percent in heaven and 82 percent in miracles, according to the latest FOX News poll. As a side note, I found the following observation rather humorous: >An 86 percent majority of adults between the ages of 18 to 34 believe in hell, but that drops to 68 percent for those over age 70. More: http://www.harrisinteractive.com/harris_poll/index.asp?PID=408 http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/politics/polls/wat/archive/wat042400.htm http://www.usatoday.com/news/religion/2006-09-11-religion-survey_x.htm
Dadman
Religion, faith, spirituality, or the lack thereof all seem to me in practice to play very little role in how a person conducts themselves in their interactions with others. This strikes me as something only a person who does not base their life or actions on religion, faith or spirtuality could say. Until you've adopted the tenets of a particular religion, or made an important decision based purely on faith, or modified your lifestyle to attain a higher level of peace and serenity (spirtuality), how can you possibly say (with a straight face) that religion, faith, and/or spirituality play no role in how someone treats others? Because these things are not part of your life you really can't speak with any authority or experience on how or why they are powerful forces in people's lives. But they are whether you understand it or not. Now, I understand agnostics because for them the jury is still out. I can understand that. The existence of a supreme being or supreme guiding force cannot be empirically proved one way or the other. Atheists, on the other hand, I just don't get. The notion that this vast, complex universe we find ourselves in (ourselves included!)is just the product of a series of serendipitous events is a leap of pure faith I just can't make. At the most fundamental level, I believe in a supreme designer and that our lives have an eternal purpose. In my view, that's frankly a more logical position to take than the idea we have no real purpose at all. But, to each his own...
Dadman
We are in agreement though about books. Books are the antidote for monolithic thinking, fundamentalism, and ignorance. A faith threatened by the ideas in a book is a faith not worth having...
CosmicConservative
Well, the whole discussion of whether it is more likely that the universe "just happened" or "was designed" is pretty much a major reason I am agnostic. The argument that the universe must have been created because it is so beautiful and complex is a self-defeating argument, unless you are arguing that God is not beautiful and complex himself. Because if he is, then that argument demands a creator for God, which is just the "turtles all the way down" argument turned into "gods all the way up." So since most people aren't willing to accept the concept of an infinite hierarchy of ever more omnipotent gods, then the argument that something that is beautiful and complex must therefore have been created is demonstrably falsifiable. The bottom line is that if something as "beautiful and complex" as God could "just happen" then it stands to reason that something as "beautiful and complex" as the universe could "just happen" too. And since most devout believers would argue that "God" is more "beautiful and complex" than the universe, then that makes it slightly more believable that the universe "just happened" than that God did. Welcome to the mental gyrations of an agnostic...
Dadman
It's odd. I'm a 'believer', but I don't think I've ever proffered one of the arguments you frequently ascribe to believers. For me, my faith is based on the 'designed' vs. 'just happened' question. In my mind, I just can't believe it just happened. Welcome to the fundamental question and answer for a believer...
CosmicConservative
You just proffered exactly the argument I frequently ascribe to believers and rebutted in the message above.
Dadman
Not really. I did refer to the universe as complex, but did not cite it as a reason I believe the universe HAD to be created, and I did not in any way elaborate on what I believe about the nature of God. You made that argument on my behalf and the behalf of all 'believers'. I just don't believe the universe and world we live in, or the existence of life itself, is a fortunate accident. It's as simple as that. The proposition doesn't make sense to me.
CosmicConservative
OK, one comment on this and I'll let it go. You said:
For me, my faith is based on the ‘designed’ vs. ‘just happened’ question. In my mind, I just can’t believe it just happened.
I can't read your mind and determine the intent of those words, but I can tell you how I read them. I read them to say that you can't believe it just happened. The logical inversion of that statement is that you DO believe it was designed. The context of the entire exchange was about the universe being complex and beautiful, so I think for me to read that as a reason for your believing the universe was designed is a completely reasonable interpretation. Now, if that is NOT what your statement meant, then what is it about the universe that compels you to believe it was designed if it was NOT it's complexity and beauty? If it is the sheer existence of it, then my rebuttal above is just as valid. The sheer existence of God would by the same logic demand that God have a creator. If God can simply exist, then why can't the universe? What aspect of God makes it more likely that He would simply exist than the universe? In short, what in your mind makes it more likely that God exists apart from the universe than that the universe exist apart from God? Or to use your final comment's wording, what about the universe makes it more unlikely to be a "fortunate accident" than the "fortunate accident" that produced God?
Dadman
I know you revel in logical gymnastics and this is a good example of that. Neither I nor you can prove or disprove the existence of a 'designer' using the argument you've presented here. It may be an argument that sufficiently persuades you that no God exists, or that God himself requires a creator, but I doubt that is so since you have proclaimed yourself an agnostic. Again, I have not elaborated on the nature of God so let's assume virtually anything is possible. Bottom line, my faith is not entirely the product of logical exercises. Certainly, believing the universe was created has logical and philosophical implications some of which you've raised. But your questions don't cover all the bases or possibilities. Ultimately, it's a mystery and when I ponder the mystery I am more inclined to believe that the universe and life itself are here for some reason. That we are here for some reason. You've described that as wishful thinking engaged in by beings who just happen to be aware of their own mortality. Maybe. But maybe not. And it's that latter possibility that I've personally decided to embrace.
CosmicConservative
See, I don't try to trivialize your arguments by claiming they are just "logical gymnastics." Nor do I belittle them by claiming they are "irrational statements of faith." I try to deal with them substantively and provide a reasoned and reasonable response. Seriously. At least I hope that's what I do. I don't argue that the more or less equivalent possibility and probability of the spontaneous and unexplainable existance of either God or the universe leads me one way or the other. I am truly agnostic, not because of any arrogance of assumed intellect, but because I can't believe either one. And that's the key thing, it's all about belief. When I consider the origin of the universe, I have to tell you, I can't believe it was created at all, either by God or out of random nothingness. Neither explanation makes any sense to me. My major problems with the God theory are really all tied up in the fact that nobody has yet described any omnipotent deity I can respect, much less believe in. But I have equal difficulties wtih believing that the universe just came to exist. It's a null set. There is nothing in my mind that allows me to support either contention, and belief in something requires higher credentials than just rationalizing it. To me believing that God created the universe is slightly less supportable from a logical perspective than that the universe simply came into being. The reason I think that is because God is demonstrably BIGGER than the universe, in every way. He is more complex than the universe, he is more powerful than the universe and he is more intelligent (and therefore more ordered) than the universe. So when I ask myself, what is more likely to have suddenly, spontaneously erupted out of nothingness, a random bunch of energy and matter, with a (very) few basic laws, or a fully formed, intelligent omnipotent being with a personality and plans, my idea of logic is that the bar is much higher for God to have spontaneously erupted from nothingness than for the universe to have done so. So far in my life I have not been able to comprehend any other means for God and/or the universe to have come into existence. If there was nothing, and now there is something, then there had to be a spontaneous creation of something. And it just seems to be more difficult to have spontaneously created a God, than to have spontaneously created a universe. So I give the likelihood that the universe was created out of nothing a higher level of credibility than that God was created out of nothing. But BOTH are so completely beyond my ability to comprehend, the difference in belief level is negligible. Thus I remain agnostic. There is a third option, and frankly I lean more towards it. That option is that God and the universe were created together, in fact they are the exact same thing. If I believe anything about theology, I would say I am closer to believing that than anything.
CosmicConservative
One part of your comments that intrigues me and that I would love to delve into is the part where you say that you believe the universe is here "for a reason." There are profound consequences to that statement that I have explored and worried over like a tongue with a sore tooth for most of my life. I somehow think that it would not be wise to pursue that thread though, no matter how it teases and tempts me....
Dadman
Explore anything you want... I believe some things may have indeed existed forever. Matter is one of those things. If I personally elaborated on the 'reasons' I think the universe exists, and why we exist, it would take us down a path very specific to my own brand of faith. That, of course, would not be a useful endeavor in this forum. So, I'll resist going there myself...
Dadman
Oh, I didn't mean to be dismissive with my 'logical gymnastics' reference. But it is what it is...a logical argument. When you're talking about God, the universe, and other things that are best described as incomprehensible such logical exercises are only so useful...
CosmicConservative
Well, I don't think this forum is a bad place to explore such things, but I respect your opinion. And logical exercises may only be partially useful in exploring the origins of the universe, but I'm afraid logic is the only tool in my toolbox. That's another reason I'm agnostic. Einstein said a lot of things, some profound, some just plain wrong, but one thing he said that has always resonated with me is this: "The most incomprehensible thing about the universe is that it should be comprehensible." There are so many levels of profundity in that statement that it boggles my little mind.
CosmicConservative
On the "things existed forever" front... Well we encounter exactly the same null set of options. My mind won't go there. Attempting to conceive of infinities simply breaks my brain. But I have to say, the identical argument applies. What is it about God that makes anyone believe that God is more likely to have "existed forever" than that the universe has "existed forever." They seem equally implausible to me because each rests on the foundation of an incomprehensibility, the notion of "forever" itself. My own opinion on this is that we are so far off the mark that it is hard to distinguish our efforts to explain the origin of the universe in any meaningful way from the Nordic myth of the Midgard serpent swallowing its own tail, or the Greek myth of the eternal existence of Chaos (personified, not a "thing" but an "entity") from which sprang Gaia, who then produced, among other things, the Titans... Seriously, I really don't think there's much difference at all. We are simply shooting in the dark and we can't even hear the arrows strike.
Dadman
I don't believe we know half of what we need to know to translate the incomprehensible into the comprehensible. I believe humanity is largely ignorant of important 'truths' that would begin to help us understand what's going on in our universe. When I speak of scientific hubris I'm talking about 'scientists' who tend to proclaim with great confidence we have most of the important stuff figured out and fail to recognize how much of what we think we 'know' may indeed be just plain wrong. Thoughts of infinity tend to break my fragile brain too, but until we can go there, intellectually, our knowledge and understanding of the universe is going to be constrained. The question is what is beyond the constraints.
CosmicConservative
Frankly I am glad it is still terra incognita. Science produces almost as much hubris as journalism. We need to remain down a peg or two until the singularity when the successor to humanity figures it all out and puts us on little protected reservations where we can run around in all our biological splendor....
Dadman
Will these successors to humanity provides us with ample opportunities to mate with young nubile females out there on the reservations? Just wondering. I have sons...
CosmicConservative
I don't know, they'll probably mostly leave humans to their own devices, so long as they don't screw up the reservations or build new AI systems...
pace
For the record, I really enjoyed this exchange. Not least because I lay awake at night pondering these types of philosophical questions with some regularity - I think just lack the intellect to explore them to the nth logical degree as does CC. Incidentally, CC has told me before that he considers my position as agnostic, although I self-identify as an atheist. I guess I view atheism as a scale or continuum rather than as a simple black-white classification. I believe I'm a little more firm in my belief that there is most likely not a god, at least not in the manner that I think most people understand the concept of 'God'. To answer a comment from Dadman above: >This strikes me as something only a person who does not base their life or actions on religion, faith or spirtuality could say. Until you’ve adopted the tenets of a particular religion, or made an important decision based purely on faith, or modified your lifestyle to attain a higher level of peace and serenity (spirtuality), how can you possibly say (with a straight face) that religion, faith, and/or spirituality play no role in how someone treats others? No, I am not saying that your religion does not guide the way that you behave as an individual. I am saying that I believe that religion does not demonstrably cause large groups of individuals to behave in 'better' ways than they otherwise would (in the absence of religion). I find this whole idea that moral direction can only be achieved through religious instruction to be absolutely ludicrous, frankly, and probably not borne out by the history of mankind. Groups of humans have behaved in generally 'good' ways toward their members because it is fundamentally constructive and conducive to the survival and prosper of their social unit, which in turn affects their personal survival and prosperity. That is not to say that people who show destructive behaviors cannot be set on the straight and narrow by introduction to religion. On the contrary, it seems to provide the purpose necessary for many to begin leading productive lives. It brings a very compelling message for a certain type of consumer, and I think that the majority of human brains are hard-wired for belief in a higher power. Whatever floats your boat, is really my take on the whole thing. Ultimately I just don't want it evangelized to me or mine, or to be marginalized or discriminated against because we don't subscribe to the groupthink.
Dadman
No one on this thread was arguing that 'moral direction' can only be attained through some brand of religion. Just know that the screeching religious zealots you see in the media, on TV, in the movies, or blowing themselves up on buses are not representative of the VAST majority of religious adherents. In my own life, the impact my faith has on my behavior, and the behavior of my family, is so nuanced and profound it would frankly be difficult to describe it without making it seem trite. It's also deeply personal. We don't go around proclaiming to the world with every breath how the practice of our faith makes us better people. To each his own is also my take on the whole thing too.