Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Eating out cheaper than eating in?

By CosmicConservative
Story at MSN.com:
By the time he's driven to the farmers market, bought the organic veggies and spent an hour cooking a meal for himself and his wife, Mark Chernesky figures he's spent $30. That's why recently, after fighting rush hour, the Atlanta multimedia coordinator dashed in to Figo, a pasta place, for hand-stuffed ravioli slathered with puttanesca sauce. "I'll get out of here for $17 plus tip," he said.
So this is interesting to me, since just over a month ago the Cosmic Wife and I sat down and examined our budget in great detail, discovering to our dismay that we were spending more each month on eating out and seeing movies than we were spending on groceries. And were weren't eating out at fancy Italian bistros that make "hand-stuffed ravioli slathered with puttanesca sauce." Our average "meal" was closer to $5 than $10 per serving. In the last month we sacrificed and ate out as little as possible and didn't see any movies, and ended up saving enough money to pay one of our car payments and have a little left over. And you know what is amazing? Our grocery budget did not increase appreciably. In other words, we ate more at home, but didn't spend any more money doing so. Why is that? I assume it is because it is still a whole lot cheaper to make your own food than to eat out. Last night we made hamburger helper for three. The box of hamburger helper cost $2.50. The hamburger we put into it cost about $2.50 more. Add to that a can of black-eyed peas at $.65 and a tin of biscuits at $1.25 or so, and our entire meal cost us around $7.00. Compare that to a meal at, say, Burger King, for the three of us which would cost around $15.00 and it's already half price. But guess what I'm having for lunch today? Yep, hamburger helper. So that will save me at least another $5.00. And there's at least enough for one more meal left after that, so figure another $5.00 saved. So that $7.00 meal provided essentially five servings that would have cost us $25 minimum if we had eaten at the cheapest fast-food place available. Had we gone to a place like our buddy Mark did, the average meal is more like $10, so five servings would cost us more like $50. When Mark says that his "home-made pasta" cost him $30 to make a meal for two, I have to wonder what kind of idiot he is. What does he do, drive to the farmer's market, buy 1 tomato, and individual sprigs of other herbs? And he drives there to buy the food for one meal? If that's how he manages his kitchen, he probably should be kept out of there. MOST families would buy a bunch of tomatoes and a bunch of herbs and make several meals to get the price down to that magical $2.00 or so per serving that is quite easy to achieve. What this story is essentially saying to me is "if you are such an incompetent shopper and cook that you are spending $30 to make a meal for two in your own kitchen, you're probably better off just buying food from someone who isn't likely to put rat poison in the food when they are reaching for the salt. Save yourself, stay out of the kitchen..."

Comments (16)

Andy
This guy is an idiot. Mrs. Andy & I shop once a week for groceries. We have two boys still at home, and another teenager living with us. Check-out is normally $80 to $120. That pretty well does it for 5 of us every week. Occasionally we order a pizza, or go out. $30 bucks for one dinner? How did this guy get a job...or how does he find his way home?
CosmicConservative
In the story itself one of the people interviewed appeared to count time preparing the home-cooked meal as if it were work time, and applied his hourly wage to it. But he did not apply his hourly wage to the time he spent waiting for his food in the resaurant while someone else was preparing it for him. This is the same sort of false economy that is used when people try to equate a "homemaker's value" by calculating the value of the work the average housewife does by comparing it to market prices if you paid someone to do the same thing. That's an absurd comparison for so many reasons I can't even begin to address them here, but I have to assume our "Mark" used the same logical fallacy to calculate the cost of his preparing a meal. The logic is something like "well, it's work, and when I work I get paid for it, so if I do it without getting paid, it's costing me money." This is fundamentally invalid because it assumes that if he wasn't making dinner he would be earning some money when it is obvious that if he weren't making dinner he'd be sitting in a restaurant, or sitting on the couch at home watching "Soprano" reruns.
Dadman
Umm...but you're eating Hamburger Helper leftovers. Ugh...
CosmicConservative
What's wrong with Hamburger Helper? It's just noodles and dehydrated sauce mixes. I've never understood the problem people have with Hamburger Helper. The difference between HH and spaghetti or linguini or some other pasta is negligible. It's not like pasta is some sort of complicated, delicate foodstuff to get right. I'm not a huge fan of hamburger helper, but I prefer a hot microwaved container of HH to peanut butter and jelly, or a cold ham sandwich. HH is the Cosmic Wife's "quickie" dinner which she makes on nights like last night (World Series game on TV). When she has time she makes a huge tray of home-made lasagna which I cut into about six or eight chunks and freeze. I take those in for lunch quite a bit too. Or she will make chicken or beef fajitas, or roast beef. Roast beef is another meal I can turn into about six or seven lunches... Although I really don't have a problem with HH, it's not our regular fare..
mark nelson
I love our local Farmer's Market (which sadly, is done for the season), but not as a place to buy staples. I mean, if you can afford to do the bulk of your shopping at a Farmer's Market, you're either too rich or very savvy. For me, the FM is a place for special treats that i can't get at the grocery store (even the Wild Oats kind). We have organic farmers who stock a wide array of mellons and other hard-to-find veggies, mushroom farmers with incredible choices and best of all...three different custom meat butchers! Yes, i tend to spend $30-40 at the FM each week, but it's not just for one meal, although with the meats it certainly can be.
CosmicConservative
Mark: If the other Mark is making an evening ritual out of preparing some special meal using Farmers' Market ingredients as a culinary event, then the story is essentially doing an incorrect analysis. The point of the story is not to compare cooking as a hobby with eating out, and doing so is to compare one entertainment expense with another. The story is supposedly saying that it is as cheap to eat out as it is to eat in. I suppose you could argue that to be true for people who go out and buy special ingredients for one-time preparation of a single meal for the purpose of impressing a date or engaging in a bit of gustatorial extravagance. But the story wasn't about that, it was about being able to eat out as cheaply as you can make it yourself. If the reporter restricted his/her interviews to people who would turn their nose up at Kroger brand rice, then the whole story is about rich people and their odd habits. And that's not the context it is claiming to have. So I stand by my statement that if you are actually worrying about a budget, then eating in is still at least 1/4 the cost of eating out for comparable meals, and is probably closer to 1/6 the cost if you make any real effort to cut down on things. So the entire premise of the article is false. It's bad reporting. And it will be used to justify irresponsible behavior. "But honey, I just saw a story on MSN saying it's just as cheap to head out to Domino's, so hop in the car and let's go! Isn't it great! It's easier, cheaper AND we don't have to clean up the kitchen!" Followed a few months later with "I don't know why we're so broke all the time! Dang, what's going on here?!"
Andy
What I wonder is why the reporter even did the story. Was he trying to convince people that it's cheaper to eat out??? Anyone over 21 knows that Ramen is 1/20th the price of McDonalds. It seems like a big waste of fabulous journalistic talent to me. Maybe tomorrow he can write an article about how it is really cheaper to drive a semi than a Taurus.
CosmicConservative
To people who pay $4.00 or more for a cup of coffee this sort of thing probably seems reasonable. Some people are so divorced from reality that they actually believe that the only way to eat a hamburger is to go to a burger joint, or to pop a pre-made burger into the microwave. And in that comparison, it really is pretty close. There are a whole lot of people who buy "convenience groceries" instead of staples. In other words when they want to eat something, they don't want to make it "from scratch" they want to throw something in the microwave. And those sorts of portions do cost a lot more than making it from scratch.
Andy
$4 for a cup of coffee? (do they give free refills?) Heck, I wouldn't pay $4 for a can of coffee.
Dadman
Hamburger Helper sucks! I hate it! The Boston Red Sox sucks. I hate them too...
Andy
I am a vegetarian now for 18 years, so I don't really remember Hamburger Helper...but I am sure that it, and the Boston Red Sox suck. We hate them. And we really hate that miserable excuse for a home-plate ump...we really, really hate him.
ams182764
I make all sorts of homemade stuff myself. I even like some of it better than eating out. It costs me about $70-$80 in groceries per week, but what I make on saturday feeds me all week.
Dadman
So, Andy, do you eat fish? Why did you decide to become a vegetarian? Is the whole family vegetarian?
CosmicConservative
Vegetarians are pure evil. At least the food I eat has a fighting chance to run away.
mark nelson
CC, I agree with you on all points. I was just waxing poetic about our local FM. I've actually had this conversation with quite a few snobby vegetarians who are way too "bleeding heart" about the plight of the "poor". One in particular kept saying that it's more expensive to eat 'healthy' than to eat fast food (so many lower income people eat mostly fast food that it has to be, right?). I asked her where she shops and what she eats. Turns out she shops at only the small, green, organic/natural foods places, so of course HER diet is more expensive. I know from personal experience that what i spend on a single one-person meal at Mc Donalds will otherwise feed me for a couple days if i shop carefully, and i'm not talking Top Ramen, either.
Andy
Okay, I will answer: I became a vegetarian because we were so darned broke that meat was a luxury...not really, but it is a lot cheaper if you don't buy meat. I really became a vegetarian for health reasons. My family has a long history of heart disease, and way back when, a limited meat diet was advised. After a while, the smell of meat cooking made me queasy...then after another little while the idea of eating meat just sort of turned my stomach. I do eat fish. I mean...Jesus fed people fish, so who am I to argue with Him? I am not a political vegetarian, or a religious vegetarian. I just got to the place that I didn't care for it any longer. Mrs. Andy is a vegetarian also...but a closet chicken eater. We never made the boys go without meat if they wanted it. My oldest son eats a little bit of meat, but really prefers not to (chicken is his favorite)...#2 doesn't like it so much, but will eat a hamburger in a pinch (chicken is his favorite, too). #3 son is a true carnivore. He will consume large quantities of any beef, pork, or chicken that happens across his path (of course, his goal in life is to be an Army Ranger and kill people). #4 son hates meat. The only meat he will eat is a hot dog...and it has to be a certain brand of wiener (that is strange to me...we have always kept meat around, but he just refuses...I think it is the smell...he has been diagnosed with Asperger's, and aversion to particular smells is common). Well...Go Rockies! (I bet there ain't no vegetarians in the lineup tonight)