Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Why I hate insurance companies

By CosmicConservative
As many of you know, I recently started a new job. That means I recently changed health insurance providers. I was at Blue Cross/Blue Shield. Now I'm at United Health. Part of the process of changing jobs is choosing from among several health plan options. And the insurance companies and the Human Resources dept. of my company have done a good job of providing solid, basic information about the plans. Unfortunately, my health needs are somewhat... specialized. The basic info, and the normal contacts, don't really give me enough information about the plan to figure out how to deal with all of our health expenses. Invariably we don't realize we have a problem until our claims are rejected due to some technical interpretation of the byzantine rules that they enforce. This usually bites us in the area of psychiatric health care for one of our children who has, as they euphemistally put it, "special needs." Well, we just got our claims rejected again, so now I have been on the phone with our insurance, our doctor and our psychiatrist for several hours over the past few days and have finally (I hope) figured out what the process is for our "special" claims to get through their bureaucratic barriers. This has taken us about six weeks from the initial phone call to United Health Care to try to figure this out BEFORE they rejected our claims. This is not some academic exercise. The charges we are talking about here are monthly therapy charges at $260/hr, plus medications prescribed by that therapist that can run up to over $100 per pill. Now, it is invariably the case that we end up getting this resolved, but it has taken us up to six months or more after we switch providers. And even then we frequently have to resubmit and walk our claims through the process after they have been initially rejected. We have two such claims from our old insurance that we are still fighting, even though I have been in my new job for two months. Now I am a good conservative. I believe in free markets and market-based health care. But I will tell you this... I am sick of this mess. My family is definitely one who would benefit greatly from a socialized or nationalized health care system. We are one of those families whose special needs are expensive under the current system, but would in effect be subsidized by "normal" families in a nationalized system. I have always voted against such systems in the past and probably will well into the future. But if ANYTHING makes me change my mind and vote in ways to secure a nationalized health care system, it will be my extreme frustration with the existing system when you have special needs like we do. Dealing with our insurance is causing our family mental health problems, and I'm not exaggerating for effect. You have no idea how stressful it is to deal with this crap EVERY SINGLE TIME anything changes with our insurance, or just because our insurance company hires a new person who doesn't know their own rules. I frankly don't know how much longer I can hold out on this subject. I have had it with insurance companies. I have come to believe that other than the mafia, there is no other organization on earth that does so much harm and so little good to the general population. They make life miserable for the very people they are supposed to be helping. And not for free, I might remind you, I PAY for my insurance, and still get treated like a criminal every time I have to deal with this mess. In the past three days I have had to call six different phone numbers, and have been transferred internally at least two or three times on top of that. And that was what it took to finally get me to the one person in the organization that seemed to know the proper process to deal with our situation. And why did she know? Because, as she told me, she has a very similar situation in her own family, so she has had to go through the same thing herself.

Comments (7)

Drax
The thing that gets me is that people think that private insurance companies are a "good thing," or that governmental subsidized/provided health care is a "bad thing." Both can be true; neither is necessarily true. Insurance companies, by their very nature, visit evil upon us on a daily basis. They have, as their goal, to make money. The way they make money is to take in more premiums than they pay out in claims. This puts the adjusters in the position of doing everything they can (and the horror stories of some of the things they do are legion) to delay or to deny legitimate claims. If they delay a claim long enough, the broke, sick, and out of work claimant may settle for far less than he is entitled to simply because a dollar now may keep his house when ten dollars later would be too late to do anything worthwhile. It's hard to "hold out" when your kids are hungry and you face the prospect of losing your house. Claims that new procedures are "experimental" long after they have become accepted medical practice are commonplace. Etc. Etc. State sponsored health care? When I hear of people dying in the streets in Canada as a result of sub-standard health care, I'll believe that it is the "evil" that it is touted as in the U.S. Can it visit evil upon people? Sure. And, for the same reason....money. The problem with both systems is essentially the same. The vast majority of people get adequate care, but those with special needs (regardless of reason) are those who COST THE MOST, and have their claims/services denied or delayed.
Andy
CC: Man...I'm sorry you are going through this. I wish that I had some experience to offer, but I don't. I understand the frustration with insurance companies (not personally, but from horror stories like yours). I stopped buying health insurance myself about 20 years ago. The deductibles and premiums were too high (a cost/benefit analysis convinced me to roll the dice), and Doctors don't charge much when they know that you don't have health insurance. Example: 2 years ago, my youngest son developed a urinary problem. Mrs. Andy took him to a urologist for tests due to the recommendation of our family doc. The tests were normally about $900. They charged us $385 when she told them "no insurance". With health insurance, I would have had to pay the $900, because of a normal deductible schedule on most insurance policies that are affordable. It has worked out for me personally, but I know that it does not for everyone. Over 20 years I can not even calculate how much I would have spent on premiums, and deductibles (but it would have been a good chunk of my income). By thumbnail, I have probably spent about $20,000 on medical care in that time for me, Mrs. Andy (2 pregnancies since then), and the 4 boys ($1,000 a year ain't bad). We have been blessed to be very healthy. I do feel for you though. There is a reason that insurance companies are some of the most profitable companies in the world...
pace
My wife was recently diagnosed with cancer. Her internist is in network. The endocrinologist she referred us to is in network. The oncologist is in network. The hospital at which the surgery to remove the tumor was performed at, is in network, as is the surgeon. So last month we received a bill for some $300. I was aware that we had attained all of our deductible thresholds, and our out of pocket expenses for the surgery should have been nil. Apparently this fee was for a technician present in the O.R. during surgery. The technician was supposedly 'out of network', albeit selected by our 'in-network' surgeon to perform surgery in our 'in-network' hospital. And don't you just love how the amount billed by the provider to the insurer is always a fraction of what you have to pay if you're determined to be responsible for the charges yourself. My experiences with socialized medicine in the UK were far from positive, but clearly some parity needs to be achieved in our system. It's a freakin' racket right now. And France has seemingly made socialized health care function at more than adequate levels, based at least on anecdotal evidence of my family members who live there.
Andy
Pace: Man, I am sorry to hear about your wife, and her diagnosis. I know that when you hear "cancer," it must be very frightening. I don't know you or your wife, but you all will be in my prayers. All I have is anecdotal, but relevant. I already wrote the story about the urologist and my youngest son (cheap bill for the uninsured). My second son (24 yrs. old now) had a troublesome boil on his neck a few months back. He went to a dermatologist and had it treated (the details are pretty gross). When he went to pay the office personnel, the doctor just happened to walk into the office. She looked at the paperwork and said "You don't have insurance?" He told her that he did not. The bill went from about $200 to $100. Then she went into the back and came out with two weeks worth of antibiotics (no telling how much that would have cost at the pharmacy) and gave them to him...no charge. When Mrs. Andy was pregnant with #4 son, we told Dr. Vanderslice that we had no insurance. He charged us $1500 total (prenatal visits, a C-section pregnancy as all the others were, and a tube-tie...thank God!). The hospital charged us about $1000 for a 3 day stay and operating rooms, nurse care, etc. Doctors know that they are playing a financial game. Almost all of them really want to give good care at an affordable price. They do care about their patients (there are some jerks out there, of course that don't). But none of them want to use their intelligence and skills to make $80-150k a year working in a social health care system. It is a freakin' racket right now. My contention is that health insurance has caused the problem. When people don't have to pay for something, they will use it without thought. Now...don't get mad at me...I am not talking about serious illness like your wife is going through. But in my experience I have seen many folks that immediately get sick after obtaining health insurance. There are many stories that I could relate, but I look to my own family for this one: This is personal, and close to home...My oldest son married in January of this year. For some reason he married a girl with "health problems." She had always been covered under her parents health care plan until she got married. It was just amazing to watch how she didn't go to the doctor, or hospital, or emergency room for 5 months. Within a week after her new health insurance kicked in with my son's job...man...she was a doctor's dream (new Porsche on the way for everybody). Once again, my belief is that health insurance is a huge part of the problem. I don't want to return to the days when you paid the doctor with chickens and eggs. But, I believe that if people didn't demand health insurance on the job (or presume it to be a constitutional right), and adopted the "pay as you go" strategy, that the great bulk of the population would have much more money in their pocket, doctors would feel better about what they are doing, and we could come to some sane level of exchange in the health care industry. Socialized medicine ain't the answer (that would be worse). Cut out the multi-billion dollar industry of insurance, and the market will figure out what is.
Andy
Dadman: No, that was not Tim...I know him too. I remember his name because those are the only two Vanderslices that I have known (and both are doctors...go figure). We were living on the Res in Southwestern Colorado at the time that Paul was born. He was a Doctor in Farmington, New Mexico (the closest hospital, and he was a heckuvaguy). I never will forget when we were in the operating room...he had done the C-section delivering son #4, and was working on the tubal ligation...He said to me "now you know, this is only 99 per cent effective." I told him "If Pam gets pregnant again, I will find you, and I will kill you!" This terrible look of fear came across his eyes...then it broke...and he said with a gleeful look in his eyes "oh, you are kidding me, aren't you." Ya gotta love those doctors...
ams182764
I don't understand why more insurance companies wouldn't want to develop a reputation for paying out claims leniently and generously, and just adjusting their premiums to a point where they can handle the claims. That way, you don't have to play this barter game every time you need to make one, and customers would trust them a whole heck of a lot more than their competition. It would be more expensive, but it would also be much easier to trust than a company that tries to operate on the hairline between red and black by denying any claim they don't want to hear.