Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The truth about Haditha...

By Dadman
Please forgive me if I'm not totally up to speed on this story. The last I heard - from the lips of Jack Murtha and his allies in the media - was that American soldiers were guilty of wantonly slaughtering 'in cold blood' up to two dozen innocent Iraqi's in November 2005. I recall Murtha repeating the sordid tale on every news program that would give him time and on the floor of Congress. It was also repeated ad nauseum in the MSM; I became fairly convinced it had happened as described. Apparently, what happened in Haditha is not so black and white and - surprise - Murtha and the MSM are in no hurry to clarify their previous statements about the incident. From today's Wall Street Journal:
OPINIONJOURNAL.COM - What Happened at Haditha: The massacre that wasn't, and its political exploitation The incident at Haditha--or the massacre, as it is often called--is due for a wholesale rethinking. The allegations are that in 2005 U.S. Marines went on a killing spree and deliberately executed 24 Iraqi civilians. The casualties have drawn an extraordinary amount of political attention, becoming an emblem for everything critics say is wrong with the Iraq war--in the common telling, another My Lai. Thus Congressman Jack Murtha, a decorated combat veteran, made accusations of war crimes and said the Marines had killed "in cold blood." These are serious charges; and military justice continues to deal with them seriously, though thankfully at a slower pace than politics. Now the prosecutions have mostly unraveled. It seems Haditha, though tragic, was exploited politically, and the allegations were exaggerated, if not unfounded.
This was a surprise to me given the veracity with which this story was reported by virtually everyone in the media. The article concludes:
Innocents were killed at Haditha, as they inevitably are in all wars--though that does not excuse or justify wrongdoing. Yet neither was Haditha the atrocity or "massacre" that many assumed--though errors in judgment may well have been committed. And while some violent crimes have been visited on civilians in Iraq and Afghanistan, overall the highly disciplined U.S. military has conducted itself in an exemplary fashion. When there have been aberrations, the services have typically held themselves accountable. The same cannot be said of the political and media classes. Many, including Members of Congress, were looking for another moral bonfire to discredit the cause in Iraq, and they found a pretext in Haditha. The critics rushed to judgment; facts and evidence were discarded to fit the antiwar template. Most despicably, they created and stoked a political atmosphere that exposes American soldiers in the line of duty, risking and often losing their lives, to criminal liability for the chaos of war. This is the deepest shame of Haditha, and the one for which apologies ought to be made.
Perhaps I am a good test case of how false impressions are created by the media and political demagogues that are then left to linger in the minds of an inattentive public. Now, I think I am more attentive than most people, yet I was unaware that the criminal cases against many of those involved in the Haditha incident were falling apart or that the truth of Haditha is really much more complicated than what Murtha, the Democrats, and their buddies in the MSM would like us all to believe. And I think they know precisely what they are doing. It's insidious. Regrettably, it will be a cold day in hell before Murtha makes the rounds on the news shows to retract his previous statements, and even a colder day before the MSM clearly sets the story straight.

Comments (2)

Andy
Dadman: Hey, last I heard this Frank Wuterich guy's lawsuit against Murtha hasn't been dismissed yet. I know that at least one Federal Judge allowed it to go forward. I don't know the status of it now, but the big jackass Murtha has refused to apologize to these men that he defamed (which was all that they really wanted)...what a jerk! There are a million articles about the suit, but floppingaces has a pretty good one: http://www.floppingaces.net/2006/08/01/haditha-marine-suing-murtha/
Andy
Dadman: Oh yea, I heard this Wuterich guy being interviewed (I think by Hannity). I think he was the one...anyway... One of these soldiers lives in Murtha's congressional district, and he is being encouraged pretty strongly to run against Murtha in 2008. I'm not a big one to give to campaigns, but I'd send him a few bucks...Jack Murtha is a true Jackass (note the capital "J") of the highest order.