I like this cartoon. I sometimes feel like real life should have an 'Undo' option...and it would be nice if we could Photoshop things in the 3-D world. Of course, I think that's what Botox is for...
Dadman
I do need to say that the 'artwork', and I use that term very loosely, is utterly irrelevant in this 'toon. I don't like it at all. I like cartoon art that in someway adds to the humor and visual interest of the strip - like a funny facial expression, exaggerated postures, movement and body shapes, great caricatures of well-know people, etc.
This is really just a thought/word gag. The stick figures add very little...or nothing.
CosmicConservative
I think that's the whole point of the stick figures. It's a sort of ironic approach to cartoon art, the stick figures are part of the message.
You should check out "Order of the Stick" then.
Drax
Heh. Again, love "Order..."
I don't know if the same thing could be conveyed without something which resembles artwork, and, of course, this does resemble artwork...
Dadman
If you guys find something praiseworthy in this 'artwork' then there is no hope. It's pathetic.
Dadman
Explain to me the aesthetic qualities of the stick figures in this strip. I can't wait to hear it. I think I'll don some hip waders before actually reading your response, though, cuz I think it's going to get real deep...
Andy
Dadman: This is like a cartoon I could draw. I told you before that I would submit my last game of "Hangman" for critique. By the way, I won.
My feelings are hurt (whimper, whimper, sob).
Drax
There is nothing good about the artwork whatsoever except that without it, such as it is, I think that the "joke" would be less effective.
It would be MORE effective (but only marginally so) with some decent artwork.
CosmicConservative
The use of stick figures and no background in this strip is a deliberate artistic choice. It's a geek strip. It's anti-aesthetic on purpose. That's part of the point of the strip. Partly it's to show how far you can go with a cartoon with nothing but stick figures.
The "joke" in all that is that geeks don't appreciate aesthetics, so why waste time on it when the jokes are geek jokes anyway? And having the art drawn by DaVinci wouldn't improve the jokes because the jokes are geek jokes anyway. If you get the joke, then the objective is achieved with the minimum of cost, time and effort. It's good engineering. Darn near perfect engineering.
You gotta love it. ;)
Dadman
Like I said...deep. It's crap and you know it. It makes a mockery of good cartoon art. It's not anti-aesthetic, it's anti-talent. The guy who draws this 'toon is a lazy turd.
If you can close your eyes and have someone read the text and still get the joke then it's not a cartoon, it's stand-up comedy.
If you really believe this 'toon is 'perfect engineering' (and I bet you don't), you might want to revisit some of your earlier criticisms of the cartoons I posted and rethink them.
I do like the joke though, like I said before...
Dadman
I guess we've discovered how to assuage Cosmic's cartoon preferences: stick figures that could be drawn by my dog... :)
Comments (12)