Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

CNN.com - Review: 'King Kong' a giant pleasure - Dec 14, 2005

By CosmicConservative
CNN.com - Review: 'King Kong' a giant pleasure - Dec 14, 2005 So now I have two major movies I haven't seen yet, Narnia and Kong. It looks like it will be Lion vs. Ape this Holiday season. I'll be seeing Narnia this weekend and will post my opinion of the movie as soon as possible (by Sunday night at latest I hope). Every review of Kong that I've seen has been great, even glowing, this one included. What sort of bothers me is that now that "Lord of the Rings" is behind Peter Jackson, his talent is assumed and I've yet to see a Kong review that does not refer to the brilliant film-making Jackson did in LOTR. But when "Fellowship of the Ring" came out, I remember well that many of the reviews snickered at Peter Jackson, with most making snide references to some of Jackson's earlier "quirky" films such as "Meet the Feebles" and "The Frighteners." The consensus in Hollywood before FOTR was screened was that there was no way some New Zealand film company was going to compete with Hollywood, and Peter Jackson was a flaky director with no history to indicate that he could pull off a film that had long been considered to be unmakeable. Even after FOTR was released it was hardly considered genius, Hollywood grudgingly handed the film four Academy Awards, but none for the prestigious categories, FOTR won for makeup, score, cinematography and visual effects. The Two Towers did even worse, only winning two Oscars, one for visual effects and the other for sound editing. It wasn't until the final movie, Return of the King, was released that Peter Jackson received recognition for his accomplishment when ROTK won eleven Oscars including Best Picture and Best Director. Now he's a genius and Kong is getting rave reviews. It makes me wonder what would have happened if he had made Kong first, then LOTR.

Comments (5)

Dadman
You're wrong, Cosmic. FOTR was nearly universally praised. In fact, only 13 of 181 reviewers panned it. It was one of the best reviewed films of 2001 and was nominated for Best Picture, although it did not win. You can read all the reviews here: http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/lord_of_the_rings_the_fellowship_of_the_ring/ Prior to the premiere of FOTR in 2001 there was some doubt that Jackson was the right man for the enormous job of translating Tolkien's novels to the screen, but those doubts quickly evaporated (in the minds of most critics) half way through Galadriel's prologue. Given the success of ROTK (receipient of the most Academy awards in history - along with Titanic) it seems reasonable to assume the Academy was holding off on giving Jackson and his team the more 'prestigious' awards until the story was complete...rather than slighting FOTR or TT in any way. Jackson's genius, in my view, is embodied in the passion he brings to his craft. He's seems to truly care about doing the job right, attending to every little detail to ensure the illusion he is creating looks and feels authentic. His genius combined with his heart, make him, in my opinion, the best director working today. I can't wait to see Kong... By the way, I did see Narnia and found it to be quite flawed...
Dadman
I forgot to mention that TT was even more universally praised than FOTR. In 2002 when it was released 197 of 202 reviews were positive (approximately 98%). I think it may have been the best reviewed film of the year. You can read the TT reviews here: http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/lord_of_the_rings_the_two_towers/ TT was also nominated for Best Picture...
CosmicConservative
Regardless of how good some, or even most, of the reviews of FOTR and TT were, the fact remains that the movies garnered a total of six academy awards, and the only one that is even remotely connected with the vision and artistry of the movie was for cinematagraphy, I don't consider that to be remotely a ringing endorsement of the movie or the director by the Hollywood establishment. But you are correct, I questioned the reviews it received and it did receive good reviews once it actually was finished, but the pre-publication buzz was peppered with the snide comments I am referring to. Which is what I was trying to point out here, the pre-publication buzz on Kong is exactly the reverse, I don't recall a movie getting this kind of positive buzz even before it was ready for viewing. And my opinion is that is entirely because of LOTR, which despite the number of awards ROTK finally did win, I still feel was treated shabbily by the Academy. Not a single acting Oscar was handed out, for example. Yes, I consider it quite likely that the Academy was holding off until the final movie, but that is exactly what I am talking about. Had ROTK been a failure, then the brilliance of the first two movies would never have been recognized. It is my personal opinion that TT was by far the best of the three, although ROTK had its moments (mostly the Siege of Gondor). The Two Towers should have garnered several technical Oscars, Ian McKellan should certainly have won an Oscar, and you could make a strong case for Theoden actor Bernard Hill, whose performance in ROTK was even better than TT. This withholding of awards to wait and see if ROTK was worth it was petty and unfair. Positive reviews are one thing. Recognition of peers is another.
Dadman
I'm not really sure what your point is. You said that 'most' critics made 'snide' remarks about Jackson's 'quirky' filmography prior to the LOTR production. Many may have, but most didn't. Indeed, FOTR got rave reviews and was nominated for Best Picture - something fantasy epics rarely achieve. Ditto for TTT - uber-rave reviews and a nomination for Best Picture. Jackson was also nominated for Best Director for FOTR and ROTK receiving the Oscar for the latter. You may not subscribe to the notion that an Oscar nomination is recognition in and of itself, but I do. Only 5 out of hundreds of films are nominated for Best Picture and all three LOTR films received Best Picture noms. If you want to make the case that they or Jackson were somehow overlooked or dissed by the Academy I would just have to disagree. From where I'm sitting (often in a theater) LOTR received copious amounts of praise and recognition from both critcis and peers. Sure, I think FOTR and TTT deserved more golden statues, but I guess I'm not as upset about it as you are. I don't expect much from the Academy anyway. Are you ready for the Brokeback Mountain lovefest we are going to be forced to endure?
CosmicConservative
Heh, I will have to admit that you are the more knowledgeable movie-goer. I guess I don't really have a point, I would try to say that my point is that FOTR and Kong were both prejudged based on criteria that aren't even relevent to the actual movies, but that's what pundits do isn't it? Heck, as a blogger I do it myself, so what am I whining about? Perhaps the real issue is that I felt that LOTR still does not get the respect it deserves, in spite of the great reviews and record-tying Academy Awards. What Jackson did with LOTR was simply unbelievable, and he did it for three movies at once. And it took three years before he got even one-third the recognition he deserved. Now with Kong, even if Kong is a great movie, Jackson's situation is so much improved compared to when he embarked on LOTR that, to me, it is not entirely fair to compare his effort on Kong to LOTR. When he made LOTR, he was David, now he is Goliath. Kong ought to be great. And it is probably fair to say that I still am rankled by the lack of any acting Oscars for LOTR. It is very difficult to pull off the kind of acting done in LOTR, not just because of the omnipresent green screens and "OK, the ball on the end of the stick is the Nazgul, I'll wave my hand when it is attacking you" direction the actors have to respond to, but also because of the fantastic nature of the story. Gandalf is one of the great archetypal characters in all of literature, to pull him off as superbly as McKellan did deserves recognition. In ROTK the scenes Sean Astin did as Samwise were heart-rending, and again the difficulty of that sort of pathos and pain while dolled up as a diminutive fairy-tale creature makes it even more impressive to me. As far as Brokeback Mountain is concerned, I am afraid that you are entirely correct and it will be a love-fest indeed. No double entendre intended...