Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Comments (13)

CosmicConservative
Well, I'd say you nailed me on this one. I really don't find it very funny. And you probably would have predicted that I don't care for the art style either, and you would have been right there too. Here's an example of why I don't care for what I've seen (I only looked at about a dozen). quigmanstoon.jpg OK, so there's a burger at the top of the pyramid. That's not enough to make the joke work. There's too much good, healthy food in the pyramid. You have to work to notice the burger. The fruits and vegetables should have been twinkies and ding dongs.
CosmicConservative
Of course this one: quigmans3.jpg Could have been replaced with "imagine any stereotypical, poorly drawn, condescending, elitist 'toon here and save me the trouble" and it would actually have been funnier.
CosmicConservative
But then this one sort of cracked me up. So there's definitely some funny ones. quigmans4.jpg I dunno, maybe he grows on you. I wasn't a huge fan of Gary Larson at first, but I became a big fan over time.
Dadman
One has to wonder if any cartoon or cartoonist would meet your approval. I think some of your issues with cartoons has to do with your inability to recognize aesthetics or style, or your inability to appreciate them. I my opinion, Hickerson's cartoons have a very unique, albeit quirky, aesthetic or style. It's different, no doubt, but I think it works. I also like his off-beat humor. It doesn't work everytime, but when it does it can be quite good. Hickerson's humor, in fact, resonates very strongly with me. When I was drawing a single panel 'toon a few years back I called it The Weerd Zone and my approach to humor at that time was very much like The Quigmans. Anyway, your hyper-cartoon-criticality makes it a forgone conclusion I won't be posting any more of my own cartoons. The audience here is just too hostile. ;)
Drax
Heh. I'm with CC on this one. I think the "style" is non-existent and the jokes, at best, lame. Art is to taste. Dadman, your art was EXCELLENT -- on a par with just about anything I've seen in political cartooning. I would have to read your text more to see if I liked your taste in that regard, though. This stuff is just bad. It's like the comic books I sell. I don't have ANY idea why some of the artists can get a job on some of the major titles, but they do. Some of the "best" over time have styles (and they DO have styles ... not just an inability to draw) leave me utterly cold. (Giffen, Infantino, a few other "greats") Some (like Giffen, Synkevich (sp?), Miller, and a few others) developed a "style" of their own after they had been published for years and developed a following that hurts my eyes. Others love them. Gotta love art. It's ALL in the eye of the beholder.
Dadman
True, Drax. It is in the eye of the beholder. I know Hickerson has been doing The Quigmans for years and years. So, it's obvious his 'style' resonates with someone, somewhere (other than me of course). Hickerson's artwork is, admittedly, not the greatest. But I think it's been successful due to the fact that it is quirky and unique...and consistent. There's a lot to be said be being consistently quirky and unique. If you can pull that off you've essentially created a recognizable style that's all your own. A whole lot of people like quirky, particularly when it comes to cartoon art. His humor is off-beat, much like The Far Side(although not as good) or Bizarro or Close to Home, and, again, that resonates loudly with some people. I'll never forget a Quigman cartoon that featured a speaker at a podium with a banner hung behind him that read 'Skeptics Convention'. The speaker said, 'Good afternoon ladies and gentlemen' to which the audience responded, 'liar!', 'no way!, 'prove it!' and the like. It cracked me up. Sometimes Hickerson can be brilliant and other times quite lame...like all of us I suppose.
CosmicConservative
See, Dadman, I think I've delivered some hilarious comments on these 'toons. Seriously powerful zingers, and you haven't noticed or said a word about them. I'm beginning to wonder about YOUR ability to spot humor. ;) I particularly liked my comment: "JC and AG look like holiday matriarchs on a cheap Christmas card". That just cracked me up. Too bad it whizzed right by your radar... Seriously though... I wasn't whacking on these toons, I picked two I liked and two I didn't, so I figure I gave this the 50/50 treatment, and sure enough, you only see the negative again. I'm not sure it's all about me Dadman.
CosmicConservative
As far as cartoons or comics that meet my approval... I dunno about "approval" but the cartoons that I find to be worth the time to read them are indeed rare. In my entire life it's a pretty short list. I'll post my own comment on that so it doesn't get lost in the comments.
Dadman
I have no sense or humor. I've completely misinterpreted everything you've said about all the cartoons I've posted. It's all about me...
CosmicConservative
Well, good, at least you see it now. ;) Took you long enough.
CosmicConservative
By the way, I only critiqued this strip because of your "Bet Cosmic won't" like it comment. I took that as an invitation to post my thoughts. Otherwise I would have continued to follow my critique supression rules...
Drax
Single panel cartoons just HAVE to be the hardest kind. It's set-up, story, and pay-off in a single panel... That's why I find VERY few of them even mildly humorous. They seem better suited for political commentary than the "gut shaking" belly laughs of a Calvin & Hobbs, I think.