Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The big day is here

By CosmicConservative
Rockies - Diamondbacks. 6:30 MDT. Jeff Francis (who is on the cover of Sports Illustrated this week) vs. Brandon Webb (who is the reigning Cy Young winner in the National League). In games against the Rockies this year that Webb was the starting pitcher, the D-Backs have 3 wins and 3 losses. In games against the D-Backs this year that Francis was the starting pitcher, the Rockies have 3 wins and zero losses. I'm not sure if Webb and Francis went head-to-head, but presumably they did. Webb's E.R.A. against the Rockies is almost 6 runs per game. But in the past three weeks the Rockies have lost a single game, and that game was, of course, against Brandon Webb. When I look at the statistical comparison of the Rockies vs. the D-Backs, I have to give the Rockies the edge. The Rockies are the better hitting team and the better defensive team. The D-Backs have a slight edge in pitching, but much of that edge is in the person of Webb, their other pitchers are comparable to the Rockies pitchers. Examined purely by comparing statistics, I would say that the Rockies will either win in six games, or lose in seven. Of course the problem is that the game is not played on paper. My gut feeling is that the key to the series is Webb. If Webb pitches well and shuts down the Rockies in at least two games, (he could pitch three), then I think the D-backs win the series. If the Rockies get to Webb and take game 1, then I think the Rockies win the series. To put it another way, I would say that the D-Backs are depending on Webb more than the Rockies are depending on any single player. I don't envy Webb that situation, but if anyone can handle such pressure, you would think a Cy Young winner could. Bottom line, I believe this is a very even match up. If they played 100 games, I think they would end up pretty close to 50 - 50 when it was all over. It's all going to come down to individual performances, and whichever team has the most heroics will go to the Series. I wouldn't bet either way on the series, if I were a betting man.

Comments (5)

CosmicConservative
BTW, the official record for the regular season matchups of these two teams is 10 - 8 for the Rockies. However, the last two games of the season the D-backs sat out 4 or 5 of their regular starting lineup, so you could argue those 2 games don't count. Which would mean that they went 8 - 8 in meaningful games. As I said, I really do think these two teams are very even, and even resemble each other in very significant ways. The D-backs have Brandon Webb, the Rockies have Matt Holliday and Troy Tulowitzki. My hope is that since the Rockies edge is in every day players, that the Rockies will get more opportunities for their "heros" to make a difference. But then again, in the NLDS, it wasn't Matt and Troy who made the difference, it was Kaz Matsui and Jamey Carroll... That's the great thing about baseball, or the terrible thing... on any given day anyone can suddenly have a career high, or a career low... Gotta have hope though...
Andy
I took a nap this afternoon (haven't had a nap since kindergarten) so I could stay up to watch this showdown. I love Dadman and his D-backs, but I really think the Rockies have forgotten how to lose a ballgame. I predicted a week ago that the Rockies will win the Series, and I stand by it. The Rockies will win this series 4-1. The game that they lose will be on a "fluke" play, or a bad ump call of some type.
Dadman
Well, the snakes are underdogs and they rather like playing from that position. I like our chances tonight with Webb on the mound at home, but I'm going to wimp out and not make any series predictions. It's really too close to call. I think I'll just enjoy the ride. May the best team win...and then go on to get humiliated by the Red Sox.
CosmicConservative
I actually think that whoever wins the NL title will likely win the World Series. I said that before the playoffs started and I still believe it to be true. I just think the NL teams are more complete teams, and they are hotter. The Red Sox have their issues too. I am surprised if the Rockies are favorites today. I know they are favorites to win the series (Vegas is predicting a six game Rockies series victory I believe, and I think on paper that's not a bad prediction). But against Webb I don't see how anyone in the NL could be favored except perhaps San Diego with Peavey on the mound. The reason I think it will be a six game Rockies win or a seven game D-backs win is because of Webb. I figure he can pretty much be counted on to win 2 of 3 games. Other than Webb I think it's pretty close, so I'd expect the other games to go 2 and 2. That comes out to 4 and 3 for the D-backs. If the Rockies can take two from Webb, or go 3 - 1 in the other games, then I think it'll be a six game series. If it goes to game 7 and Webb pitches, I think the D-backs have to be the favorite. Oh this all counts on the Rockies winning either Game 1 or Game 4, if Webb wins both of those, there probably won't be a game 7, the D-backs will win in six. I'm hoping the Rockies can at least beat Webb in either game 1 or game 4. I just think it's tough for a pitcher to beat the Rockies back to back right now. But if anyone can do it, Webb can.
Andy
Dadman: I know that you are trying to fool the baseball gods. Even an old redneck can spot that. It is going to be fun to watch. I have sworn to myself that I will not visit Cosmic Conservative until this series is all finished...you guys are probably praying for a 7-gamer now. But...neither the Dbacks, nor the Rockies will be humiliated by the Sox. I read a great piece in my local sports section today, and it convinced me that the NL champ will confound conventional wisdom, and wipe out the AL guys.