Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

CSU editorial says "F*** Bush"

By CosmicConservative
Who was it that said "Profanity is the weapon of the witless?" Or this one? “Profanity is the attempt of a lazy and feeble mind to express itself forcefully.” I'm guessing it wasn't the head of the journalism dept. at Colorado State University.
Profane Language Puts Student Editor's Job On Line - Education News Story - KMGH Denver FORT COLLINS, Colo. -- A four word editorial with a four letter word in it is sparking a spirited discussion on free speech at Colorado State University. The Rocky Mountain Collegian published an editorial on page 4 of the paper Friday which read "Taser this ... F*** Bush." The expletive was spelled out. The last two words were in bold type, larger than most headlines. A caption below said, "this column represents the views of the Collegian's Editorial Board."
I'm sure the journalism dept. staff are very proud. Seriously, I mean that. I'm sure they are. This is what they taught those kids no doubt. I wonder what their parents think?

Comments (6)

Briana
Actually, it is SO irresponsible for you to state that "this is what they taught those kids" (referencing the journalism dept). I attended CSU with a major in technical journalism. The school emphasizes ethics and every student is required to take media law and journalistic ethics courses. Saying something as ignorant as what you have posted is similar to saying Nicholas Confessore represents everyone in Washington. (http://www.washingtonmonthly.com/features/2001/0212.confessore.html) I'd encourage you to entertain some independent thoughts rather than whining about what their parents think...and read up on media issues.
CosmicConservative
Hmm... is my statement as "irresponsible" as the editorial staff at CSU? Since the entire staff took a vote on the subject, is it "irresponsible" of me to assume that SOMEONE took this to the journalism department administration, and they did not intervene? I do appreciate your comments, but this is my own personal blog, and I am allowed to speculate on people's behaviors and motivations, since I am not a "reporter" and am not publishing an official news or editorial statement reflecting the official editorial position of any body except my own. I'm afraid that I don't agree that my statements were "irresponsible" in any way precisely because I have no ethical or editorial "responsibility" to be fair and balanced, unlike the editorial staff of this college newspaper, or the administration and staff of their journalism department. Lacking such "responsibility" it is hard for me to fathom how I can be "irresponsible" in any way. How "responsible" is it for you to accuse me of lacking "independent thoughts?" Tell you what, when I see an official statement from the CSU journalism department that denounces this "editorial statement" and calls for the firing or suspension of those on the editorial board who voted to run this childish "editorial" I'll change my position on what I think of the CSU journalism department. Lacking that I'll continue to assume that most, if not all, of the staff of that department find nothing wrong with this sort of "journalism." How's that? Fair and open-minded enough for you?
Briana
If you had any knowledge of the way a student-run newspaper works, you would know that it is just that: STUDENT RUN. Thus, they do NOT take their editorial decisions to the journalism department staff. Also, again, since you seem to have such extensive knowledge about journalistic "balance," you should also realize the difference between an EDITORIAL (which is not necessarily unbiased--it is not written by a reporter; rather, it absolutely serves as a specific person's opinion...) and the regular paper which, yes, should be unbiased. I'm not defending the copy editor, which decided to make the headline larger, or the decision to print the word at all. I agree that the opinion could have been stated in a way that was much more respectful to the journalistic ideals and to their readers. However, there is no reason to blame the faculty of the journalism department. Do we go about blaming law schools for turning out sleazy lawyers? I don't believe so.
CosmicConservative
Briana: It is quite funny to sit here and listen to you assert that the journalism administration and staff of a public university have no influence or responsibility for how their students run a student newspaper. I wonder if you feel the same way about how college athletes act and whether that reflects on the coaching staff. I've seen three Colorado college football coaches lose their jobs in the past five years because of actions their "students" took off the field, away from the campus and on their own. Somehow it is acknowledged that a college athlete is expected to receive some sort of ethical guidance from the coaching staff, and if that guidance is lacking, the coaching staff is sacked. I see no reason that the journalism administration and staff aren't held to the same standards as athletic coaches. Now, just so you know, I do absolutely blame the administration and staff of colleges for turning out sleazy lawyers. In fact I have repeatedly stated that many of our law schools are run by a bunch of moral reprobates who teach their students that "right" and "wrong" are not relevant concepts for a legal case. Harvard college is well-known for teaching their students "when you have a solid case, pound the case, when your case is bad, pound the table." This is considered "wisdom" at Harvard. You can assert all you like that a college department has no responsibility whatsover for the type of product they turn out. I am sure you would not agree with that statement if the product in question were a car. It is my personal belief that students in particular and people in general react to the attitudes and biases of the people they perceive to be in authority over them. I have concluded, entirely subjectively I admit, that the journalism faculty at CSU includes a group of virulent, vocal anti-Bush bigots who have spread their Bush Derangement Syndrome to their students. You can disagree all you want. As I said, I'll believe otherwise when I see the journalism faculty at CSU rebuke these students and state their own belief that the actions taken were outside the bounds of common decency, much less outside the bounds of journalistic ethics. By the way, since you assert that these students have to pass ethics and standards exams, I am assuming that this behavior has essentially resulted in a failing grade for each of them. If not, I'd like to know why not.
CosmicConservative
Oh, one more thing. If you think this sort of story has no impact on the school, and should not reflect on the Journalism department itself, let me assure you that I am a parent and I would never send my child to a Journalism school which produced students who voted as a group to run this sort of editorial. As a parent my immediate assumption is that Journalism Department is poorly run at best, and viciously partisan at worst. And if you think I'm the only parent who would make that call, you are fooling yourself. In fact, if you think the Journalism faculty at CSU has not been called on the carpet for this, and had to answer some very pointed questions from the overall college administration, I have to question what sort of journalistic instincts your teachers have instilled in you.
Andy
Briana: You are going to lose this one. "Student run" is a term with a definition. "Student run" is any enterprise ALLOWED under the auspices of a University to let their students present to the public what the particular University has taught the students. Obviously, the CSU faculty has failed. Let us say that I sent my son to the grocery store with $100, and told him to bring back eggs, milk, bread, and cheese. When he walks through the door, he has a new video game, and $55 in change. I have just had a "student run" experience. I have to realize as a teacher, that my student has not learned the basics of grocery shopping, or the discipline involved in management of a task. Obviously, these J-school profs have not instructed their students in common decency. The F-word is never acceptable among intelligent people...not in conversation, and even more so in the printed media. Words that are spoken drift off into the air...words printed last forever. Sorry Briana...your arguments, and punctuation (check the usage of a semicolon) are really lame.