Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Dying tongues...

By Dadman
Is your tongue dead or dying? To find out, connect your tongue to a car battery with some jumper cables. Feel anything? If so, you're tongue is not dead... Okay...seriously...many of the world's most ancient tongues (languages) appear to be dying off at an alarming rate.
FOXNEWS.COM - Scientists: Many World Languages Are Dying While there are an estimated 7,000 languages spoken around the world today, one of them dies out about every two weeks, according to linguistic experts struggling to save at least some of them. Five hotspots where languages are most endangered were listed Tuesday in a briefing by the Living Tongues Institute for Endangered Languages and the National Geographic Society. In addition to northern Australia, eastern Siberia and Oklahoma and the U.S. Southwest, many native languages are endangered in South America — Ecuador, Colombia, Peru, Brazil and Bolivia — as well as the area including British Columbia, and the states of Washington and Oregon. Losing languages means losing knowledge, says K. David Harrison, an assistant professor of linguistics at Swarthmore College. "When we lose a language, we lose centuries of human thinking about time, seasons, sea creatures, reindeer, edible flowers, mathematics, landscapes, myths, music, the unknown and the everyday."
The evolution of language is a fascinating thing. It is disconcerting that so many languages are endangered, but I have to wonder how many we have already lost over time without any adverse impact. Change is inevitable. I wonder how long it will be before the loss of these languages is blamed on global warming and/or George W. Bush?

Comments (12)

CosmicConservative
It's already being blamed on Microsoft and McDonalds. This is part of the globalization of human culture. Liberals hate it while being the ones most vigorously promoting it. They are the ones demanding global courts, global governments, global police, etc. all the while screaming in bloody rage over global corporations and global cultural movements. It's typical of the cognitive dissonance of the left. They actually think you can have global governments without losing cultural identities. I am one of those who feels a bit wistful about the loss of cultural diversity, but I simply don't see what to do about it. Cultural diversity is a result of population discontinuity. Any fool can see this. As cultures merge and blend, cultural diversity is what you lose. People use languages to communicate and provide a life for themselves and their families. As long as they can maintain an existing language and do that, the language will survive. As soon as it becomes untenable to operate in a language, that language starts to die. Eventually there will be a few living languages left. It is as inevitable as the sun's eventual demise. Sure we can lament it, but we aren't going to change it. Although you can bet we'll see some sort of legislative attempt to do so...
Boyd
Endangered languages, endangered species, they're all the same, quite honestly. This is the natural way of things. The old and weak pass, the young and strong thrive. I predict that at some point in the future, maybe within the lifespan of my grandchildren (but certainly of any great-grandchildren), there will be one primary language around the world, and that language will be English. Some would call that hubris. I call it "following the trend."
Andy
Boyd: I tend to agree with you. I don't know if English will be the only language one day, but I can see within 50 years or so that everyone will know English. Everyone except Mexicans, of course. I swear, I was in Tijuana a few years ago, in a nice hotel about 2 miles from the US, and no one spoke English. One guy at the front desk did, but none of the employees. The restaurants and shops around the hotel had no English speakers at work. It was hard to believe...the language of success, and of most of their tourists...unbelievable.
CosmicConservative
English is, I believe, the fourth most commonly spoken language behind Chinese, Hindi and Spanish. If all the projections are to be believed we are more likely to be speaking Chinese than English in 100 years. In general I agree with the statements Boyd and Andy make, but I do want to address one thing, and that's the "old and weak" comment. It is generally believed by most people that the selection of species through natural selection (commonly called "evolution") is a process that weeds out the old and weak. That is not true. Charles Darwin himself commented on that interpretation of evolution and his rebuttal was that "evolution does not reward the strong, nor the intelligent, but only the species most adaptable to change." And the same is true here. If English becomes the dominant language of the world, it won't be because it is stronger or younger than the other languages, it will be because it is the most adaptable. Right now it has a huge advantage over Chinese, Hindi and Spanish simply because it is easier to use in an electronic world of trade. English is ideally suited to the Internet when compared to other dominant languages. Couple that with the cultural dominance of "Pax Britannica" in the 19th century and "Pax Americana" in the 20th, and English has a huge edge on other languages. But, technology is rapidly removing the difficulties other languages face in a computer-driven economy, so that edge could fade fast.
Andy
CC: Exactly! English is the language of success, and of the future, because so much technology has sprung from English-speaking countries...our capitalism urges us to provide products that will be profitable. You know what I am saying... I doubt that Mandarin characters will ever be on a keyboard, or that a keyboard will ever display typing from left to right as some languages proscribe (I could be wrong...it may be available now). Things do change, and the "hostess with the mostest" normally has the biggest party.
pace
Wikipedia has English in the third spot in terms of native language speakers. However, I read even several years ago that it is the most prolific when considering multi-lingual speakers who may use it as their second, third, language. In fact, Wikipedia lists the total English speakers at 1.8 billion, the total Mandarin speakers at 'over 1 billion', and the total French and Spanish speakers at 500 million each (upper estimate). So I think it is fair to assert that 'more people can speak English than any other language'.
CosmicConservative
I was referring to primary language usage, and I will stand by fourth. In terms of multi-lingual usage, I am certain English is first in total people who can get by compared to other languages.
pace
I blame Global Warming. Bush is too stupid to have orchestrated this. ;)
Andy
Pace: Don't misunderestimate the evil President GW Bush...he is capable of more than we know.................one day everyone in the world may speak Texican...time will tell.
Boyd
BTW, it kinda depends on your definition of "weak," CC. That lack of adaptability is what I really consider weak, and I took a kind of a shorthand approach to that. Also, my prediction was that English would become the "primary language," not the "only language." And I didn't even mean it would become the primary language for everyone. I just expect English to become the de facto language for any business beyond a certain size. And y'all cain't be expected ta larn to speak Texican. It's jyust tew complicayded fer somebody who hadn't herd it theyr whole lahf.
CosmicConservative
The secret to "Texican" and other "deep south" dialects is the dipthong. No, that's not a thong that dips down, although those are certainly worth discussing too, a dipthong is a multiple vowel sound in a single syllable. So for example if you want to really sound "Texican" you have to say it "Tye-axe-ee-ah-can" But done so that the vowel sounds just roll together smoothly. To say "I am" you would say "Aye-uh aye-um". This is why northerners have so much trouble mastering "y'all." They think it's a simple contraction of "you all" and they pronounce it "yall". A true Texican knows that the "oo" sound from the original "you" is still there, it's just rolled into the "ah" sound of the "all" so that it comes out "yuall". When someone says "yall" it sounds like a screen door slamming in your face, it's curt and abrupt, instead of the warm and inviting sound of the true "yuall". Using these techniques it is easy to translate "You can't do that" into the Texican "Yuall caihn't do thayet!" But it has to be said with a smile... ;)