Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Greenspan piles on

By CosmicConservative
Alan Greenspan claims Iraq war was really for oil - Times Online In his long-awaited memoir, to be published tomorrow, Greenspan, a Republican whose 18-year tenure as head of the US Federal Reserve was widely admired, will also deliver a stinging critique of President George W Bush’s economic policies. However, it is his view on the motive for the 2003 Iraq invasion that is likely to provoke the most controversy. “I am saddened that it is politically inconvenient to acknowledge what everyone knows: the Iraq war is largely about oil,” he says.
I'm guessing Greenspan is trying to sell books and he knows this is one way to do it. To examine the "largely about oil" statement rationally though, it is fair to note that there is something worth pursuing in the charge. The economy of the United States runs on oil. A serious threat to oil supplies, production or distribution is a national security threat to the United States. People who don't understand that simply aren't worth discussing anything with. A President who did NOT consider a threat to the flow of oil as something to deal with is a President who should never have been elected. Jimmy Carter comes to mind. I WANT my President to make sure that we continue to have access to what drives our economic engine, and I do not consider the desire to keep oil flowing to be some sort of corporate subsidy. There is a reason that we keep a "national security reserve" of oil in this country. It's because without oil, this country will fall apart. As will the economies of every other country in the world. When people say oil is the "life blood" of our culture, they are objectively accurate. That's what it is. A relatively minor restriction in the oil supply led to a major US recession in the 70s. I know, I was there. So put me in the category of those evil conservatives who want to keep oil flowing. But to say that was the only reason we went to war with Iraq is simply disingenuous. But even if it were, there is a powerful argument to say "well, that was enough of a reason on its own."

Comments (12)

Andy
CC: Yes, from the beginning of the build-up to the invasion of Iraq, any thinking person had to know that the free flow of oil was part of the reasoning. Sadly, many non-thinking people (I think we know the types I reference) will say "See...see..see." The reality is that we conservatives had already "seen" this as a factor in the Iraq invasion from the start. There will surely be a "firestorm" from the left to follow. Maybe the most interesting thing about this is that the right and left both knew that oil was germane to the reasoning for war. And while the left "shouted it from the mountain tops" as evidence that the invasion was wrong, few conservatives acknowledged it, or made the argument that it's a pretty darned good reason... Not to steal Iraq's oil of course (we could have already done that if we wanted to), but to keep the US economy stable (and the rest of the world, for that matter). If we ever fall into an energy crisis, you can kiss the war on terror goodbye...just what the Islamic nuts want.
gjh
This blog has screamed from the mountain tops that this war had nothing to do with oil!
CosmicConservative
No gjh, it hasn't. This blog has consistently said that there are a LOT of reasons we went to war with Iraq. Pretty much exactly the reasons that Bush gave when he was asking Congress for permission to do so. Permission which Congress granted. In the "National Security" concerns, the free flow of oil was clearly a national security issue. Hussein's violations of U.N. Security Council resolutions on how they manage their oil production and distribution were included in the reasons we went to war, in case you did not notice. You might remember the whole "oil for food" debacle as one of the U.N. programs that Iraq was violating. To acknowledge that the free flow of oil was part of the equation is nothing new, and should be nothing surprising to someone who understands economics and how economics relates to national security. That "someone" may not be you, but it CERTAINLY should include Alan Greenspan. And it does. As I said, he's just trying to sell books now and he knows people like you will suck up anything that bashes Bush. I'm sure his bigger problem with Bush is Bush's out of control spending, just as my bigger problem with Bush is Bush's out of control spending. But that doesn't sell books to liberals, and doesn't get reported as a news item by the New York Times staff since liberals more or less live off of that sort of spending. So the quote on oil being part of the reason for going to war is what gets press. No surprise there. In the overall equation I would say that "oil" was one of the lesser variables leading to the war in Iraq. But to pretend it wasn't one of them is either ignorant or idealistic to the point of courting national suicide. Either way, it is typical Democrat behavior.
Andy
gjh: Did you catch Greenspan in the Washington Post today? He explains the reality...read it if you really want to know the truth. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/09/16/AR2007091601287_pf.html
gjh
CC Pull your head out of your a**. We have been screaming about his out of control spending since the beginning. You love to put words into others mouths to attempt to make your point. Remember the "highest national debt in the history of the world". You poohooed it as being relative to todays dollar. Revisionist history is what I'm seeing now.
gjh
By the way Congress gave him permission to go to war as a last resort not a carte blanche. May he and his gang rot in Hell.
Andy
CC: "By the way Congress gave him permission to go to war as a last resort not a carte blanche. May he and his gang rot in Hell." I have figured this out (it took me a while): gjh is actually a pseudonym. This is a character that you have created in your overly active mind to illustrate the ultimate "lefty." Now I know that you actually write this stuff yourself to make us all laugh, and sign it with his identifier. You thought you could trick me...ha!
Drax
gjh: I'm fairly certain that going to war was the last resort as I don't recall there being any further negotiation (other than terms of surrender) after we started lobbing bombs Saddam's way. Maybe a refresher on the meaning of "last resort" is in order? Also...the debate on this blog about the "oil issue" wasn't whether it was "part" of the reason for going to way, it was whether it was the "only" reason for going to war. If it was the "only" reason, we picked not only the hardest target in the area, but one of the ones with the least amount of oil. Saudi Arabia would seem the better target.... And, if oil was "part" of the reason, the question as to whether it was "sufficient" reason arises. I don't think that it was. I doubt that anyone else in power thinks so either, else, again, we should have picked an easier and richer target. It was everything, not the least of which was Saddam's desire to conquer his neighbors and take THEIR oil...
CosmicConservative
gjh: I'm not going to go back and find my posts that have taken GW Bush to task since this blog began over his out of control spending. You obviously don't comprehend anything you read other than what satisfies your already solidified biases. If anything I have been a harsh critic of GW Bush since he began his Presidency, and the main things I have complained about have been his inability to control his own tendency to create entitlement programs (No Child Left Behind, Prescription Drug Program, Immigration "reform", etc.) and his inability to veto crazy spending bills stuffed to the gills with pork by Democrats and Republicans alike. Giving the OK to go to war is by definition a "carte blanche" gjh. Or have you not read the Constitution lately? Or ever? Greenspan's clarification of his comments match my own eplanation almost word for word gjh, it's not my fault you don't get it. I can explain things to you, and I have done so many times, but I am afraid it is beyond anyone's ability to comprehend things for you.
gjh
Do you know anything about no child left behind? If you did or if you have spoken to anyone in education you would know that the nuts and bolts of this legislation is such a mess because the Pres refuses to fund it. It is a funding issued. This act has done more damage to education than anything in the last 30 years. Did you know that it causes adminstrators to push kids out of the class room and force them into alternative ed programs or to private tutors?
CosmicConservative
If you think no money has been spent on NCLB, you simply aren't looking at actual budget figures. As with all entitlement programs, the Left is always going to say that it isn't funded adequately. That's because the only "adequate" funding for entitlement programs according to the Left is "infinite." Bush has spent plenty in my opinion. The failure of funneling money into education to "fix" problems has been clearly documented. In the past 50 years as we have doubled, redoubled and redoubled the amount of money we have poured into our public education system, that system has steadily decreased in effectiveness until it is now one of the least effective educational systems in the Western world. And of course your response is "well, throw MORE money at it then!" I think the problem has more to do with our schools having become altars to the agenda of the Left instead of places people actually learn facts, history and skills.
gjh
You have bought into propaganda. The conservative agenda has pretty well bankrupted the schools in the states that have elected repub governors. The Michigan situation is a prime example. Schools taxation was tied to property taxes. Some guy by the name of Hedley ran through an amendment that take the school taxes off the property taxes and to fund the schools through the lottery. Michigan schools as well as the State of Michigan are broke because of the actions of John Engler. Now a Democrat is supposed to fix it?