Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Comments (9)

Kevin in WI
Man, I don't know where to start on this one. But, several things come to mind: 1. This story is laced with ridiculous, over-the-top rhetoric (terrible journalism). 2. It all depends on the thermal efficiency of the electricity - sound - heat conversion. It could be game changing, or just something neat for science teachers to demonstrate. 3. If it is game changing, just think of the conspiracy theories that will be proffered. i.e. "Big oil (you can sub "govt" here also) had this all along, and just staged is "amazing discovery". Wow, I'm really in a cynical mood today...
CosmicConservative
So, either this is breaking all the laws of thermodynamics, or else what is happening is that he is essentially converting radio waves to heat, but reducing the efficiency of that process by going through water electrolysis on the way. This would take about a day for a serious scientist to investigate and come back with a "dude, something's going on here that we should check out" or a "Nothing new here folks, except for a new and less efficient means of using electricity to liberate hydrogen and oxygen from water." Sure, I HOPE there is "something new going on" but I strongly suspect it's just a new way of doing electrolysis and the end result is that you use more energy to separate the hydrogen and oxygen than you gain from it.
Andy
I am in a cynical mood today, also. But, I am going to check this out with a retired radio guy friend that once told me that there are interlocks in the control rooms at radio towers to prevent someone from being "fried" if they happen to be in there when all power is up. My memory is sketchy on what he told me, but his will not be. It is very interesting, and I suspect as does CC that it will be another "more is less" discovery. But it is worth looking into...we will see.
Andy
Oh, by the way...a Miss Teen South Carolina wannabe commented on this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dT-h0Zh2JCo&mode=related&search=
ams182764
Dude, why do people fall for these things? xJ + 2*H2O --> 2*H2 + O2 --> H2O + yJ x = ? y = ? anyone? .... Bueler?
ams182764
BTW, I wouldn't reccommend microwaving yourself after injecting yourself with metal particles either. Could get a bit warm.
Andy
ams: Thanks for the advice...I was just about to inject myself with metal particles and hop into the Panasonic. Instead, I think I will just inject myself with dinner, and hop into the Whirlpool.
CosmicConservative
Heh. My favorite part of the video was where the reporter was saying "it's just salt water, and it's burning!" Yeah, just salt water and an indeterminate amount of electromagnetic radiation in the form of concentrated radio waves. I guess if you can't see it, it isn't really there.
Andy
CC: "I guess if you can’t see it, it isn’t really there." Kind of like...I don't know...God? Interesting topic...again!