Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Beware of litigious eskimos...

By Dadman
Apparently the people-formally-known-as-eskimos (now referred to as Inuit) are being threatened with extinction as a result of global warming and, naturally, it's America's fault. That's why they are suing us. Here's the story. This scenario comes to us right off the pages of Michael Crichton's latest thriller, State of Fear, which I recently consumed. In the novel, the U.S. is being sued by an island nation claiming the imminent rise of ocean levels caused by global warming would force them to evacuate their land and way of life. Mr. Crichton is one prescient guy, or perhaps the Inuit and their legal counsel like Crichton novels too and thought his idea was a good one. Crichton's story probably should have been titled 'When Environmentalists Run Amok' since it involves evil and corrupt environmentalists using murder and high technology to artificially (and secretly) generate environmental disasters to gain public and political support for their agenda. I did find this plotline to be a bit absurd and not particularly convincing, however, I thoroughly enjoyed the way Crichton presented an opposing viewpoint to the orthodoxy of human-induced global warming through the banter and conversations of the novel's main characters. Crichton studied the global-warming issue for three years before penning this story. I admire him for his willingness to stick a metaphorical finger in the metaphorical eye of the modern environmental movement and raving lunatics on the Left who are convinced global warming is going to kill us all. As a member of the Hollywood intelligensia, he clearly is not afraid to take on sacred cows and suffer the inevitable ostracism. I think his conclusions are instructive, reasonable and significantly more objective than the hysterical rhetoric we continually hear from environmentalist moonbats and, regrettably, from some climate experts who appear to be more loyal to a political agenda than pure science. Here are some of Crichton's more compelling conclusions:
We know astonishingly very little about every aspect of the environment, from its past history, to its present state, to how to conserve and protect it. In every debate, all sides overstate the extent of existing knowledge and its degree of certainty. Atmospheric carbon dioxide is increasing, and human activity is probably the cause. We are in the midst of a natural warming trend that began about 1850, as we emerged from a four-hundred year cold spell known as the 'Little Ice Age'. Nobody knows how much of the present warming trend might be a natural phenomenon. Nobody knows how much of the present warming trend might be man-made. Nobody knows how much warming will occur in the next century. We can't 'assess' the future, nor can we 'predict' it. These are euphemisms. We can only guess. An informed guess is still just a guess. Part of the observed surface warming will ultimately be attributable to human activity...the principle human effect will likely come from land use, and that the atmospheric component (e.g. increased level of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere) will be minor. Before making expensive policy decisions on the basis of climate models...it is reasonable to require that those models predict future temperatures accurately for a period of ten years. Twenty would be better. People in 2100 will be much richer than we are, consume more energy, have a smaller global population, and enjoy more wilderness than we have today... The current near-hysterical preoccupation with safety is at best a waste of resources and a crimp on the human spirit, and at worst an invitation to totalitarianism.
Crichton provides many additional points of view in the appendix of his book, but these are some of the more interesting ones. I must say I like what Crichton is doing. May he continue to be a rational iconoclast in a politically over-heated world.

Comments (1)

CosmicConservative
I haven't read Crichton's latest book, although I've heard about it and know that as a result of it he has been named public enemy number one by the elites in the environmental movement. Toppling GW Bush from his five year reign in that role is a feat worthy of recognition, if not approbation. I pretty much agree with Crichton's points you posted above, but I will take exception to the final two. Whether we have more or fewer human beings on the planet in 2100 is related directly to the question of whether humans will be richer. All the evidence that has ever been collected and analyzed on the subject of population growth and decline has demonstrated that there is an inverse relationship between birth rate and wealth. But the birth rate in the wealthiest parts of the world has already declined about as far is it can, it is the birth rates in the poorest parts of the world that are the problem. If wealth increases in those areas, then yes I believe population will decline. But unless the geopolitical realities of today change pretty drastically in the next fifty years, there is still a very strong possibility that the poorest parts of the world will continue to be poor, and will continue to pump out babies at a prodigious rate. I'm also not sure that even if wealth increases and populations decline that per capita energy consumption will continue to climb. I can think of several converging technologies that all tend to reduce energy consumption per capita, and assuming that trend continues we could well see that energy consumption per capita may be close to or even less than what it is today. And finally, the amount of wilderness available is also a geopolitical issue. Democratic cultures tend to protect the environment much better than totalitarian ones. So the likelihood of increased wilderness is also tied directly to geopolitical changes that also drive wealth and reduced population. I would call Crichton's conclusion the "optimistic" view. The pessimistic view would be the opposite. I tend to agree with Crichton and am also optimistic, but I'm not quite as confident as he seems to be. His final point about near-hysterical preoccupation with safety is accurate, but does not go far enough. The real danger is not the imposition of safety rules until the state is totalitarian, but the imposition of political correctness until the state is totalitarian. And it must be noted that the emergence of such a totalitarian geopolitical environment would work directly against the conclusions Crichton reached in the immediately preceding point.