Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The buzz about the bees

By CosmicConservative
Scientists find clue in mystery of the vanishing bees - CNN.com (CNN) -- A virus found in healthy Australian honey bees may be playing a role in the collapse of honey bee colonies across the United States, researchers reported Thursday. Colony collapse disorder has killed millions of bees -- up to 90 percent of colonies in some U.S. beekeeping operations -- imperiling the crops largely dependent upon bees for pollination, such as oranges, blueberries, apples and almonds. The U.S. Department of Agriculture says honey bees are responsible for pollinating $15 billion worth of crops each year in the United States. More than 90 fruits and vegetables worldwide depend on them for pollination. Signs of colony collapse disorder were first reported in the United States in 2004, the same year American beekeepers started importing bees from Australia.
Actually I'm sure it's more like "billions of bees". But when this story was first reported, of course all of the "scientists" quoted blamed it on, you guessed it, global warming. Just like Kilimanjaro, whose vanishing glaciers have now been more or less proven to be the result of extensive deforestation on the slopes of the mountain. Funny how the story doesn't mention the original Global Warming angle, eh?

Comments (6)

Daniel G. Pesante
What strikes from the communiqué is that no evidence is provided that a virus IS the cause of CCD. The fact that a new technology was used to examine honey bee hemolymph and that virus were found, in no way points to virus being the culprits; although, it does not exclude the possibility. Daniel Pesante, Ph.D. Apiculture
ams182764
Must be an evil Australian plot: I guess now we'll have to import even more immune Australian bees to make up our losses. Just in time for the price to go up. Dang Australians.
gjh
It depends which story you read. I read one this morning that discussed all of the above, but was not willing to blame the Aussie bees. The Canadians have been importing the A bees for many years longer than the Americans and have had no sign of the virus. This is a very complex problem where knee jerk reactions and quick fixes will not solve it. It may be a "perfect storm" of a variety causes.
Andy
I know a tiny bit about this...not much, but a little. I know a lot of beekeepers here, and there is not a great panic among them. But, it could just be a local calm. This has happened before, according to my beekeeper friends, and righted itself eventually. There have been colony viruses here in LA occasionally forever. One man tells me that he is missing some bees, and another tells me that he sees no change at all. They think bees are where they haven't been in the past, and not where they are normally expected. It bears watching, but I don't buy in on the "no crops" panic. I would have to see data. Everything I hear on the ag news reports bumper crops of wheat, corn, etc. We don't get fruit crop news, so that sector may have been hit.
CosmicConservative
There seems actually to be a sort of bee population crash cycle. I think there was one around WWII, and another at the turn of the last century. I don't recall the dates, but losing huge portions of the bee population is not unheard of in this country, and probably not worldwide either.
Andy
CC: Yes, that is about right. I know that there was a bee crash in the late 50's throughout the midwest (if memory serves). Like I said...not buying the "crisis" just yet.