Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

September Dawn released...

By Dadman
...to dismal reviews. It's gratifying to see this film about an incident known in Mormon history as the Mountain Meadow Massacre get called out for the propaganda it is. Nick Schager, film critic for Slant magazine, has this to say:
Forget Grindhouse. September Dawn is the year's first honest-to-goodness exploitation flick, utilizing its "inspired by true events" yarn about the 1857 Mountain Meadows massacre for tear-jerking, righteous indignation-stoking melodrama. Christopher Cain's portrait of the Utah region's Mormons as insane-in-the-membrane zealots, as well as its depiction of their successful plot to kill (with the help of local Native Americans) 120 immigrants passing through to California, is reportedly based on the official 27-page confession of convicted Mormon John D. Lee. Yet the clunky, heavily skewed means by which this tale is presented is nothing short of egregious, with its Mormon characters demonized with such laughable gusto, and its Christian victims cast in such a holy, noble light, that the project quickly feels less like an attempt at historical truth-telling than like shameless anti-Mormon propaganda.
I couldn't have said it better myself...

Comments (8)

CosmicConservative
Even the lead in text on the poster implies that they "have the goods on" Brigham Young, which is exactly what they intended to imply I think. A truly despicable effort, and I am ashamed of John Voigt for being caught up in it. In general Voigt is a voice of political reason in Hollywood. But this is one he miscalculated on, I think.
Andy
Dadman: Thanks for the heads up on the movie. I won't go see it...of course I wouldn't anyway.
ams182764
Nevertheless, the event happened. Whatever the agenda of the movie, the massacre did occur.
Dadman
ams: Yes, the event did occur, but the story can and should be told without demonizing an entire group of people, the vast majority of which had absolutely nothing to do with what happened. The film is not intellectually honest and fails to provide a full context of the times in which the event happened. It seems more invested in making Mormons out to be wild-eyed, bloodthirsty monsters than telling an objectively honest story. It truly is propaganda... The film also clearly implicates Brigham Young in the massacre. In the film he orders the murders when in fact his involvement continues to be unclear. Books have been written on both sides of the argument and a new one is in the works. I'd recommend a read of The Mountain Meadow Massacre by Juanita Brooks if you want a more objective treatment of what happened back then. This film is an anti-Mormon, anti-religion agenda film - pure and simple. It's interesting that so many critics without a vested interest either in Mormonism specifically or religion generally have recognized it for what it is...
Andy
ams: Let me preface this by saying that I am not a Mormon, or a Mormon apologist. I am just a Christian, not affiliated with any particular church. I have heard of this Massacre, but never looked deeply into it. The post aroused some long-forgotten curiosity and I did do a little bit of research. In your comment you say rightly that regardless of the motivation, it did happen. Yes it did. My first thought is...well, the Crusades happened...slavery in the US happened...lynchings of blacks happened (not only in the south by the way). Just because those things happened does not mean that the current Roman Catholic, Baptist, Methodist, Lutheran, etc. population whose predecessors participated in those things are proud of it, or would they condone it. My thought is that looking into a terrible chapter in any religion's history that their explanation, or justification for the sin involved can be "skewed." That goes for any situation. I read a pretty concise article that seems to be officially condoned by the LDS. In looking at any such thing (from any church) we always have to have the filters up, and I found this article to have "the ring of truth." You might find it interesting. The link is: http://www.lds.org/portal/site/LDSOrg/menuitem.b12f9d18fae655bb69095bd3e44916a0/?vgnextoid=2354fccf2b7db010VgnVCM1000004d82620aRCRD&locale=0&sourceId=1c234dc029133110VgnVCM100000176f620a____&locale=0 One thing that I do know is that the sins of the father, whether real or contrived belong to the father...not the children. And no Protestant, Catholic, Pentecostal, or Mormon need live under the cloud of their religion's past.
Dadman
Good link, Andy. Thanks for posting. This issue is a very polarizing one and it's true you have to have your filters up when reading about this incident. Both camps have their own prejudices and objectivity is often difficult to find. But I do think the synopsis in the account you shared is a fair one. Again, thanks for sharing. You're a good man...
Andy
Dadman: You wrote: "You're a good man..." Man have I got you snowed.
Kevin in WI
If this wasn't the 150th anniversary of the event, I would be tempted to think the movie's timing too much a coincidence with the development of a serious Mormon Republican presidential contender.