Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Coming soon! Life created in the labratory...

By CosmicConservative
Artificial Life Likely in 3 to 10 Years WASHINGTON (AP) - Around the world, a handful of scientists are trying to create life from scratch and they're getting closer. Experts expect an announcement within three to 10 years from someone in the now little-known field of "wet artificial life." "It's going to be a big deal and everybody's going to know about it," said Mark Bedau, chief operating officer of ProtoLife of Venice, Italy, one of those in the race. "We're talking about a technology that could change our world in pretty fundamental ways—in fact, in ways that are impossible to predict."
So Darwin and God are having a debate. Darwin says: "I can create life without using divine powers in the lab." God says: "I created all the life there is." Darwin says: "All I need is some basic chemicals, and I can find them in common dirt." God says "Make your own dirt then." This is an old joke, and one that I don't particularly care for. But it's relevant to the discussion of human lab-created life. According to this article we're only a decade away, perhaps much sooner. As an admitted agnostic I don't really get all worked up about stories like this. But I do wonder which of the following might cause the most consternation to devoutly religious people. 1. Artificial intelligence created in a computer. 2. Self-replicating living organisms created in a lab from inorganic materials. Or are we at the point now that even the most committed fundamentalist would just shake their head and say "what a crazy world..." and just chalk it up to scientific progress?

Comments (4)

Andy
I consider myself a fundamentalist Christian, and I hope that I can express this the way I know it in my spirit. I don't understand the desire to create life, or artificial intelligence, but I do understand that others do. For whatever reason...quest for knowledge...quest for achievement, etc. And it does not bother me. Man will never equal God. I don't know a lot about artificial intelligence, but the sheer magnificence of God's creation tells me that man will never match His intelligence. Man may one day create some form of life, but that will not equal God. Creating life is God-like, but does not equal God. The difference is that God's most wonderful achievement is something that man can never match...redeeming life. Man can not redeem himself. Man may one day be able to duplicate himself, or create some new life form, but he will never be able to stand in the holiness of God on his own merit. That takes a redeemer. So, it wouldn't bother me. It will upset many fundamentalist Christians...the crowd that is always out there looking for something to be upset over. Don't know if I was clear...short version. Good question, and subject, though.
ams182764
A lot of older science fiction seems to be hung up on this issue as well. I've been watching some of the older TOS episodes recently. It appears that the writers are conflicted about the idea of artificial intelligence. "Well our machines can do X and Y, and may someday be able to do Z - there doesn't appear to be anything to stop them, BUT THEY'RE JUST INANIMATE OBJECTS!!!" It seems we almost use two different parts of our mind to deal with the active and animate - things that originate actions; and everything else - the nonresponsive background. And when they conflict or cross, we get all the agonizing over these issues. I'm not particularly bothered by it myself, provided we don't start doing malicious things with it (making viruses to kill people, ect). PS - did they say "inorganic"? By that, do they mean they've somehow come up with a replicator using non-carbon based compounds? Or are they simply referring to carbon-based compounds not previously part of a living organism?
CosmicConservative
It sounds like they are pursuing the same technique that has been discussed now for decades. Create a "membrane" using fatty acids of some sort, and use that to isolate a set of nucleotides (which are the basis of DNA) and then get the nucleotides to combine and form self-replicating strings. The main difference from earlier approaches seems to be the addition of eight new nucleotides. That's pretty interesting.
Kevin in WI
Many will talk about how this will validate the theory of evolution and be a threat to creationism. However, I see it the other way around. They WILL succeed in artificially creating a simple life form. But, they will do so in such a contrived laboratory setting that the reality of its applicability to the prehistoric earth will be nonexistent. Consequently, the scientific reality will be very different from the narrative that will be created around it. Nothing new with that of course.