Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Ann Rice endorses Hillary

By CosmicConservative
Welcome to AnneRice.Com! PERSONAL ENDORSEMENT OF HILLARY CLINTON FOR PRESIDENT: August 10, 2007
Let me summarize her lengthy self-justification: "I'm pro-life, but it's OK with me if you want to kill your babies."

Comments (22)

Andy
I read the Anne Rice statement. I will be back later...I have an appointment with the toilet to fill it with vomit right now.
CosmicConservative
Basically she is saying "I like Hillary and will overlook my fundamental Christian values in order to support her. If that means a few more million babies are murdered, then so be it. I like her that much." I hope I never like anyone that much. I mean that's some real adoration, right there.
Drax
I'm a bit torn on her missive. She's a Democrat. There will be only two viable candidates for President in 2008, one of whom is likely to be Hillary. As I have said in the past, "I'd vote for a shaved monkey, if he had an (R) after his name." This is because I believe that Republicans are more likely to reflect my views generally, not that any particular Republican will (that is what Primaries are for...), and, when it comes down to it, in most cases the (R) or the (D) have meaning in political power. I also understand, somewhat, her view that as a student of history "giving up the right to abortion" is something which will cause a great upheaval, but, unlike her, I'm cool with that. We, as a nation, will get over it. Frankly, technology will likely make the issue moot anyway in the near future in Western Countries. What shocked me the most was that Anne Rice became a transformed Christian. Did not know that.
Andy
Okay...I am back...feeling somewhat better now. Mrs. Andy has spent most of her adult life volunteering in Crisis Pregnancy Centers (she is a relentless, loving, adoptee that could have been terminated...long story). This is a subject that hits us between the eyes. History (and God) will judge us by our respect for life. This chick (Anne Rice) seems to miss that. I know better. I have held my ear to Mrs. Andy's tummy through four pregnancies...hearing the swish...feeling the kicks...and seeing the result (not always so pleasant...just a joke). I don't really know who this Anne Rice is...visited her website, and saw the report on Drudge...but not familiar with her work. But I feel badly for her. Anyone that professes Christ as Savior that could wish for Hillary Clinton to lead the nation that leads the free world needs sympathy, and some spiritual (and psychological) help.
Drax
Heh, what happens if the choice is Gulliani or Hillary? Both are pro-abortion. Do we just not vote?
CosmicConservative
Drax: I don't consider that sort of question to be academic. And I do know more than one fundamentalist Christian who has said that they will not vote in that circumstance. I think that is foolish. Here are my thoughts: 1. There is usually a difference between the degree of "pro-choiceness" of candidates, both of whom claim to be pro choice. For example, one may support partial-birth abortion while the other may not. Go for the one that is less extreme. It's a lesser of two evils, but lesser is better when that's the only choice. 2. There may be a difference in the type of judges one would nominate to the SCOTUS. In the case of Guiliani or Hillary, I think Guiliani would nominate less extreme justices. 3. If no difference can be determined between the two, then vote based on different principles. Such as free-market vs. socialism.
Andy
Drax, I have heard one or two folks say that they will sit out if it is Rudy vs. Hillary. I agree that it is foolish. No Rudy fan here...but I would make a gamble on his judicial nominees. Hillary is at a disadvantage, because we know exactly the type judges she would enthrone. It is a gamble with Rudy, but at least there is a chance. My hope is that we will have a better option come Nov. 08.
Drax
CC, Andy: That is the point of Rice's message. There will only be two choices. She will vote, because, as you both note, it's foolish not to. She's pro-life, but, believes that the Democrats more closely represent her views (else why be Democrat?) I don't see it as being any different from a pro-lifer voting for (and backing) Rudy. (And, if we classify the choice as the "lesser" of evils, we yet are voting for an "evil.") Single issue voters are, at best, "foolish."
CosmicConservative
I think the point is that if you are going to call yourself a born-again Christian, then if you vote for a pro-choice candidate when a pro-life candidate is available, you have pretty much said that some other issue is more important than the life of a child. And that's a pretty hard case for most people to make. "Oh, I am pro-life, but I'd rather protect my social security than insure that innocent babies are not murdered." I think that's why Ann is being criticized.
Drax
I understand why she's being hammered, I just don't agree with it. Christians who villify her for supporting Hillary when Hillary is Pro-abortion who, nonetheless, hold their nose and vote for Pro-abortion candidates rather than sit out the vote are just being hypocrites. As you know, I'm anti-abortion (except in cases of the life of the mother), but not for any faith based reason. But, if the choice is Hillary or Rudy? Not even close. Not the "lesser of two evils." The better of two candidates, the candidate who most closely resembles what I believe. If the choice were a pro-life Democrat (highly unlikely on the National or State level) or a pro-abortion Republican (again unlikely on the National or State level--as Romney proves, heh) what then? There are many other issues which are as important or more important. (For example, if the nation ceases to be, then whether or not we allow abortion kinda pales into insignificance, eh?) Single issue voters.... Meh.
Andy
Drax: An amen to you. I have never been a single-issue voter. I will vote for Rudy (maybe campaign for him) if he is the nominee vs. Hillary. I don't like the guy personally, but he probably would not like me either. I have held my nose many times behind the curtain in the voting booth...never felt bad about it. You are right...if the nation ceases to be, then there is no hope for a right turn.
The Blue Site » Blog Archive » Ann Rice: Confused Christian, "Pro-Life", Pro-Abortion, Hillary Supporter
[...] CosmicConservative sums it up nicely: “I’m pro-life, but it’s OK with me if you want to kill your [...]
Andy
Maybe I should add that I differ with Drax just a bit on the abortion issue. I believe that abortion is murder, regardless of rape, incest, or the life of the mother. Drax only mentioned "life of the mother," but the "big three" are often cited, so I threw the other two in. I know...I am a real creep. My conviction is that a little baby in the womb is alive, regardless of it's stage of development, or the circumstances by which it was conceived. I have listened to the "viability" argument my whole adult life, and it always falls dead on these old deaf ears. A full-term baby is not viable. As I understand viability, it begs the question "Can the fetus survive on it's own outside the womb?" The answer to that is that no baby...even a full-term, perfectly healthy baby can not survive outside the womb on it's own. Human offspring need years and years of feeding, nurturing, help, training, etc. to ever be able to survive outside the womb. A perfectly healthy baby will die within a few days if not tended to, fed, etc. The viability argument is just plain bunk. I have to once again give Drax an amen. He asks: If the choice were a pro-life Democrat (highly unlikely on the National or State level) or a pro-abortion Republican (again unlikely on the National or State level–as Romney proves, heh) what then? Excellent question, and as much as I despise abortion, he gives an excellent answer. There are bigger issues...if we conservatives lose the hearts and minds of the public at large over one issue, we will never be able to regain lost ground. Roe vs. Wade is a national disgrace. It is so misunderstood by the public that it could make you cry. When Roe v. Wade is overturned, abortion will not cease in the US. As I understand the ruling, the court would throw abortion issues back to the various States...will be illegal in S. Dakota, Lousiana, and Mississippi at this point...and finally regulated in many others (Pennsylvania comes to mind...and others. The only way that abortion will ever cease is for hearts to be changed... Well...sorry for using so much comment space.
Drax
I understand that there is an argument that killing an unborn human child is "murder," but, is it ALWAYS "murder?" In the law, there are times when it is legally justifiable to kill a person....and one of those times is to prevent one person from killing another, i.e., "self-defense." In the case of "the life of the mother," we are presented with the proverbial choice, two innocents...one of which must die. If the child is born, it kills the mother; if the child dies, the mother lives. Both are "innocent." Of the two, only one presents a threat to the other, i.e., the mother presents no threat to the unborn child while the unborn child presents a threat to the mother. So, if ALL abortion is outlawed, then the law FORCES a mother to give up her life for her unborn child when she has done nothing (other than attempting to give birth) to deserve her death WITHOUT giving her the (horrible) choice: "Do I live for my OTHER kids, or do I die for THIS one?" That is why I draw the distinction between "the life of the mother" and the other "big two." In the case of incest or rape, there is an innocent unborn human child who presents no threat to the life of another. Killing the child under those circumstances would fit the definition of "murder," so long as we accept that the unborn human child fits our definition of a "human being."
Andy
Drax: The "life of the mother argument" is a difficult one. But this is not 1907, or 1807. Regardless of whether society accepts my definition of the unborn child as a human being, the life of the mother is rarely in danger. I have studied this issue, and have come to conclude that "life of the mother" is a catch-all used by some abortion-prone OB's to justify it. I am a creep...but, what makes the Mother more valuable than her child? I would love for someone to give me an argument that would convince me that in this age of astounding technology...advanced medical care...and "911" that any woman is going to die while giving birth. There may be a few examples out there...and I am up for correction on this. I personally believe that the argument is a by-gone argument for a by-gone day. Tell me if I am wrong... As Ross Perot would say, "I'm all ears."
Drax
I understand that the excuse, "the life of the mother" can be overused when not appropriate, however, that isn't the issue. The issue is WHEN that choice presents (as a real choice) is it the law's place to choose for us "which life is more important" or is it OUR place? We accept, generally, that there are times when it is appropriate to kill human beings. I hope that this isn't even a question for you. We kill innocents in war. We kill murderers and rapists. Police kill to protect others. Etc. So, the only question is whether the CHOICE should be taken from US when we are presented with the choice of killing the mother (through inaction) or killing the child (through action). It should be an INDIVIDUAL choice who dies in this circumstance, the FAMILY deciding "who is more important." After all, the mother is no less innocent than the child in this case, right?
Drax
Andy: Taken from a Pro-life web page: "There are virtually no conditions that threaten the mother's life in which abortion is a medically recognized treatment. In some conditions (e.g., an ectopic pregnancy or a cancerous uterus) a treatment may be required which indirectly kills the preborn. But in such cases, the treatment does not legally or morally qualify as an abortion. When removing a cancerous uterus, the intent is to save the mother; every effort to save the child should still be made. Thus even if the child dies, the treatment is still fully justified. The death of the child was never INTENDED. In contrast, for an abortion the intent is always the same: to kill the preborn child. " Here, the argument is one of "intent," not of result. It parses words to the extreme. When the known result is "killing the child" while "saving the mother," I don't see that there is any distinction between that and intentionally killing the child, since, indeed, that is what is occurring. Now, I agree with the premise that, in such cases, all effort must be made to save both patients. However, when the effort to save the child INCREASES the danger to the mother, then the mother should have the right to make that choice. (Three possible results: 1) Both live, 2) One lives, 3) Both die.) To the extent that medical procedure AFFECTS the probability of these outcomes, the mother should have the ability to choose her level of risk.
Andy
Drax: I have read this before. It is extremely rare, and the argument has been used (once again) by abortion-prone OB's to justify the act. Look, we are all faced with tough choices in life. We all make good, and bad calls. I am a creep...but I do not believe that anyone should decide, as you wrote: (Three possible results: 1) Both live, 2) One lives, 3) Both die.) Now...neither I, nor Mrs. Andy have stood in those shoes. It is easy to pontificate in theory, but much more difficult to make the call in a real life situation. I have said a thousand times..."I would like to think that I would..." But you never really know. Good food for thought Drax...later.
Drax
I understand that it is very rare these days (and getting more rare every day). It would be a tough choice. I just want it to remain just that....a choice rather than a governmental mandate.
CosmicConservative
It absolutely makes sense to say that if a mother's life can be saved only by killing her unborn child, it is at least as "right" for the mother to live and the child to die, as for the child to die and the mother to live. Especially if the only result of not intervening is the death of BOTH the mother and child. I am OK with this being resolved in favor of the mother. I have no moral qualms whatsoever in that regard. However, the problem with the argument from a practical (and legal) perspective is that as soon as you make such a law, suddenly there are going to be a lot of pregnancies that somehow "threaten the life of the mother". And there will be all the doctor's signatures you want proving it. So it's a de-facto legalization of abortion, which is what the pro-life people are saying. I don't know how, or IF you can solve that problem. But I understand the arguments on both sides.
Drax
CC: I agree with your analysis. It's even worse when the test is the "health of the mother," rather than the "life of the mother."
Andy
CC & Drax: WOW...the moral questions we have raised with medical advances! I am still grateful for the advances...improves the length, and quality of life...and makes a Christian actually study and pray.