Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Greatest record in (American) Sports

By CosmicConservative
ESPN.com has one of the most lame and poorly written (or researched) articles I've seen in a long time. It is so bad that it would be laughed off of most amateur blogs. The only reason it was written was to provide Gene Wojciechowski an opportunity to diss Barry Bonds one more time. The premise of the article was to examine a number of candidates and then choose which of them represents the greatest record in sports. To spare you the pain of reading the pathetic article, he concludes that Hank Aaron's home run "record" is the greatest record in Sports. Now this is wrong on so many levels that it's hardly worth debating. But it does make me want to give CC's readers the chance to set the "record" straight, so to speak. First of all let's define our terms since ESPN seemed to have no guidelines or consistency whatsoever in their article. So here they are: 1. This is the greatest record in American sports, by which I mean that it is either a record held by anyone of any nationality in a recognized American sport (no rugby, cricket, soccer or lacrosse...) OR it is a record held by an American in any sport. 2. It has to be an actual record. This concept itself seems to have been beyond the ESPN writers reckoning. To be the "greatest record" let's say it has to actually BE a record. 3. It has to be a good record, achieved through efforts recognized as positively impacting the individual who holds it. So that puts Reggie Jackson's strikeout record out of the running. 4. It has to be statistically verifiable, not based on anecdote or legend. 5. It has to be legitimately a record that may never be broken. OK, so here is my first shot at a list of candidates:
  1. Ty Cobb's lifetime batting average (.367)
  2. Secretariat's 31 length victory at the Belmont en route to winning the triple crown.
  3. Wilt Chamberlain's 100 pt. game
  4. Bill Russell's 11 NBA titles (as player and player/coach)
  5. Wayne Gretzky's scoring title (or maybe Wayne Gretzky's 61 current Hockey records)
  6. Joe Dimaggio's 56 game hitting streak
  7. Jerry Rice's NFL touchdowns record
  8. Emmitt Smith's NFL rushing yardage record
  9. Cy Young's 511 wins
  10. Lance Armstrong's seven consecutive Tour de France victories
  11. John Stockton's career NBA assists record
  12. Byron Nelson's eleven consecutive PGA tournament victories
  13. Martina Navratilova's 59 Grand Slam titles (singles, doubles, mixed doubles)
Of these there are two that stand out to me as simply being so far beyond the reach of modern performance levels that beating them simply defies reason. Those are Wayne Gretzky's scoring and Ty Cobb's batting average scores. Of those I have to give the edge to the Great Gretzky, but it's very, very close.

Comments (42)

Andy
CC: Those are all great suggestions. The one that stands out to me is Byron Nelsons streak. I don't believe anyone will equal that. Love Aaron! But it's not the greatest record as you so ably pointed out.
Drax
I think that the home run record is the most glamorous record in American sports (lifetime). I also think that it is the hardest one to achieve. The level of excellence for such an extended period of time is simply insane. That being said, there are so many factors militating against this record being even marginally important in the American psyche that I don't think that it matters much to anyone anymore. Hank Aaron will forevermore be the "home run king," because, like the dollar, he did it when doing it meant something. But, taking a look at your list: 1. Ty Cobb’s lifetime batting average (.367) Really have a hard time thinking that this will be broken, unless, of course, baseball goes through rules changes or somesuch. He wasn't that far ahead of his contemporaries, however, so I don't put that one on too high a pedestal. 2. Secretariat’s 31 length victory at the Belmont en route to winning the triple crown. Sorry. He's a horse. Doesn't count. 3. Wilt Chamberlain’s 100 pt. game This will be broken. Kobie came close. 4. Bill Russell’s 11 NBA titles (as player and player/coach) Unless he won all those all by himself, doesn't count. 5. Wayne Gretzky’s scoring title (or maybe Wayne Gretzky’s 61 current Hockey records) Will be broken. Probably within the next 12 years or so. Gretzky was great, but the BULK of his "scoring record" is assisting the scoring of others. 6. Joe Dimaggio’s 56 game hitting streak Will be broken. It will take a while, but, it's just a matter of time. As it's not a "career record," I can't compare it to the "all time career home run record." 7. Jerry Rice’s NFL touchdowns record . Will be broken. Probably in the next 10 years. There are a couple who will break ALL his records, I think. But, again....team sport...doesn't count... 8. Emmitt Smith’s NFL rushing yardage record Will be broken. Sanders would have broken it had he not retired. (In fact in a conversation with Smith and Sanders...Smith agreed with Sanders when he said that he would have broken it but...so what...it'd just be broken later anyways....) Team sport. Doesn't count. 9. Cy Young’s 511 wins Team sport...defense counts. Unlike the BATTER, who has no help whatsoever, the pitcher has eight other guys backing him up. Won't be broken unless something changes in pitching rotations... "Lance Armstrong’s seven consecutive Tour de France victories " This is an astonishing record, steriod enhanced or not...but, it's seven years...not 20+ of excellence. Give the edge to Aaron. 10. John Stockton’s career NBA assists record. Team sport. Will be broken. 11. Byron Nelson’s eleven consecutive PGA tournament victories . Will be broken. Probably by Tiger. Snapshot of career, not career... 12. Martina Navratilova’s 59 Grand Slam titles (singles, doubles, mixed doubles) Don't know if this one will be broken. I think it will be, but I have no clue who might do it. If anyone cared about tennis, then this one might be a challenge to Aaron.
CosmicConservative
I will grant you that the home run record is probably the most glamorous American record. But it is also very breakable, as we see with Bonds breaking Aaron's and A-Rod coming up fast on Bonds. One of the standards for it to be the "greatest record" is that it be arguably unbreakable. The home run record simply doesn't qualify. Cobb's lifetime .367 ain't gonna be broken unless they change the game so much that it is no longer baseball. Who is the current active leader in lifetime batting average? Todd Helton, at .333. I actually sort of agree with Andy here, Byron Nelson's eleven tournaments in a row is hard to fathom even Tiger breaking. His best effort so far was, I think, seven. There's nothing to say that the "greatest record" has to reflect a career's worth of effort. If that were the case, then Edwin Moses decade-long domination of the 400 meter hurdles is probably going to be the top.
Drax
Ah. I saw your list of how YOU defined what qualified. I simply don't agree with your qualifications. I don't compare singluar spurts of excellence to sustained excellence. I don't compare team effort to individual effort. I don't compare individual effort in which no one can affect the outcome to individual effort in which there is direct opposition. (Hurdles to batting, for example). Baseball hitting, for me, is surpassingly the highest form of competition. The long season in which, to achieve any degree of excellence requires that one plays 120 or more games per year plays a part. The fact that, to hit, one has another professional player doing everything he can to prevent you from being successful plays a large part. The fact that hitting is one person against a whole team plays another part. The sheer number of years a person must sustain excellence to be "one of the greats" plays yet another part. There really isn't anything which compares to hitting a baseball for me when it comes to what records are "important." That being said... It's REALLY hard to put anyone ahead of Moses for sustained excellence. If he had someone kicking his hurdles while he was doing so, I would say that this is the greatest record in the history of records. No one has dominated an individual sport as completely as he did for so long. But, some others of note: Cal Ripkin's unbroken streak of 2632 games played. This is second to Bret Favre's record of 16 seasons without sitting out a game. Jim Brown's more than 100 yards per game average. Nolan Ryan's 5714 Strikeouts. Nolan Ryan's seven no-hitters. Walter Johnson's 110 Shut outs. (Not a typo, heh...) I don't see any of those being beaten in my lifetime.
CosmicConservative
Cal Ripken is, to me, the most overrated baseball player in the history of the game. Yeah, he showed up every day, but otherwise he was a career .276 hitter who batted over .300 a grand total of four times in his career. He averaged about 20 home runs though, which is pretty awesome for a shortstop. But he showed up and played every day. Big woop. To me that is more of a stunt than an accomplishment. Yeah he had to be physically able to drag his butt out there, but how many times did he play when he really should have sat down and let someone else in better shape play? I would guess hundreds of times over his career. I didn't think much of Lou Gehrig's "iron man" record either, but Gehrig's other numbers were more than enough to get in the Hall of Fame. The only reason Ripken is in the HOF is because he played when he should have sat down and given someone else a chance to play. To me that record is pretty much a monument to selfishness. I don't have quite the same disdain for Favre's record of NFL games because he plays once a week and I would bet there were very few times he played that he wasn't the best quarterback the Packers could have fielded that day. But still, it's not a record I consider to be a "great" record for many of the same reasons. Jim Brown's yards per game average, on the other hand, is pure power performance and is definitely in the running. The rest of these are also candidates. If, as you say, baseball hitting is the highest form of competition, I don't see why you always discount Cobb's .367 batting average. (Yes, I know MLB stole two hits from Cobb and it now is "officially" .366, but to me it will always be .367.) You keep saying that Cobb wasn't that far ahead of "his peers." In my mind Cobb had a single peer, and that was Rogers Hornsby, who had a lifetime BA of .359 in 23 years, compared to Cobb's .367 in 24 years. The others who were close to Cobb had careers of ten or twelve years, and that's not nearly as impressive as doing it for 24 years. Tris Speaker is the next on the list with 20+ years and his BA was .345. Next was Babe Ruth, at .342. Interestingly, only Hornsby on that list batted right-handed. All the rest batted left-handed. That just makes Hornsby that much closer to Cobb, in my opinion. Hornsby also hit 301 home runs, many of those in the dead ball era. While we are on that subject, Hornsby holds the record for the highest single-season batting average at .424, four points higher than Cobb's highest which was .420. THAT is a record I don't think we'll see broken either. I think Rogers Hornsby is probably the best baseball player that nobody remembers. He was almost a cross between Cobb and Ruth. He hit for average and power. He played for 23 years. He won his share of batting titles in the NL. He was always overshadowed by Cobb and Ruth, but as a righty, he may have actually been the better hitter. In his prime he batted .404 over a FOUR YEAR PERIOD. Cobb's best 4 year stretch, he batted .402. That's inhuman. Those two guys were simply in a different league.
pace
As a side note; I found it interesting that Michael Schumacher was mentioned. I'm guessing Mr. Wojciechowski never heard of this guy: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ricky_Carmichael Did Schumacher win every single professional championship in his discipline? Nope. But Ricky Carmichael has won every single professional outdoor motocross championship since he turned pro in 1997. And Carmichael arguably had a much deeper talent pool to overcome in his branch of motorsports than did Schumacher. Should the fact that he is not a household name lessen the greatness of his achievement?
Drax
I don't know why you think I "discount" Cobb's accomplishments. I don't. I think you inflate them. Perspective, I suppose. It's hard for me to discount someone who was such a complete player, a person who arguably was the best baseball player ever to play the game. We just disagree as to his standing in the "top ten best baseball players of all time," not whether he deserves to be in that group... I just don't give as much weight to batting averages as you do in those days. .400, while not common, surely was not rare. Batting in the high .300's was frequent. Cobb was the best at doing that, no question, but I can't compare what he did to what Gwynn did or Williams did. They were different eras.
CosmicConservative
Drax: How long have we had this argument? Fergie Jenkins or Gaylord Perry? (OK, you were right about that one). You think I inflate batting average, I think you inflate home runs. I think getting a hit is the key to baseball success, not smacking one over the fence. I do have more respect for the player who can get the hit just about every game over the player who can knock one out of the park every third game, but strikes out in the other two games. I know this puts me in the minority, but I'm OK with that. I don't think I inflate the importance of Ty Cobb's accomplishments, and I repeat what I have said before, when Babe Ruth and Ty Cobb were on the same Hall of Fame Ballot voted on by the same baseball experts, Ty Cobb got more votes. I think that's because he deserved more votes. And I think that is in large part a recognition of the incredible hitting machine that he was, which is best demonstrated by his lifetime batting average. But I guess you could say that I am "discounting" home run records using the same analysis I am using, and I would argue with that since I think I do appreciate what Ruth, Aaron and Bonds (well, I also think Bonds is tainted) have done. I will just accept that you also appreciate what Cobb has done and that you and I are just on slightly different pages on which is the more important accomplishment.
Drax
Oh, and Cal? He only completely revolutionized the position, proving that a big, tall, powerhitter could play shortstop. No Cal? No A-Rod. (Don't you remember the shortstops who played in the 70's and before....?) Beyond his record, he was voted to the All Star Team NINETEEN TIMES. He had over 3000 hits (one of the most select groups in baseball). He had over 400 Home Runs. He won the gold glove twice, MVP twice. Was named to the MLB "all century" team. He holds the AL record for most assists in a season. He shares the AL record for most seasons leading the league in assists. He holds the MLB record for most seasons leading the league in Double Plays for shortstops and the AL record for most in a career. He holds the MLB record for highest fielding percentage by a shortstop in a season. He shares the MLB record for most seasons leading the league in put outs. It's REALLY hard to say that he is the "most overrated baseball player in the history of the game" when there isn't much of a question that he wasn't one of the BEST shortstops to every play the game...if not THE best, overall (hitting included with his INCREDIBLE fielding ability). Cal would have made the hall JUST based on his 3000 hits. He would have made the hall on JUST his 400 homeruns (gotta consider POSITION in these decisions). He would have made the hall JUST on his fielding record. He HARDLY made the Hall just because he didn't miss a game in 16 years.
CosmicConservative
OK, I give you that Cal was the prototypical big shortstop and that nearly everyone (including the Rockies) now has a big guy at that position. Maybe I'm too hard on Cal, but I hate that record. I think it encourages people to play when they should sit down and let someone else play. I think the pursuit of it put the Orioles in the position many times of choosing between Cal's pursuit of that record and fielding the best team they could field that day. He would have achieved all of those other things without the "iron man" record imho, yet when you mentioned Cal in the "greatest records" category, that's the one you mentioned. I will back off the "most overrated player" comment, but I still think that his biggest, most recognized "accomplishment" was purely a monument to selfishness. Nothing else.
Drax
As to the Ruth/Cobb debate, if Ruth didn't have a higher on base percentage, more RBI's (in less seasons), all those home runs....all the while maintaining his batting average to within approximately .024 of Cobb's, then I would agree with you.... But, he did.
Drax
Even hurt, Cal was the best shortstop on the team and never had a fielding % lower than .970 during the run. Let's take a look at "the streak," though. In the first few years of that streak, are we going to say that Cal was totally unhurt? Of course he got hurt, but he continued to play. Are we going to say that the manager(s), knowing that Cal was hurt, let him play anyway (when there was NO concern for any record) to the detriment of the team? Of course not. What about the first eight years (half way to the record)? No one was seriously considering that Cal, playing shortstop, one of the most demanding (non-catcher) positions in the game, was really a threat to the record at that time. Did he play hurt? Of course he did. Did he and his manager make the decision, each time that he was hurt--not considering "the record" at that time-- that Cal playing shortstop gave them the best opportunity to win? Of course they did. And, the fielding numbers ... the offensive numbers ... bear out that, if these weren't "good decisions," they certainly weren't "bad" ones. Now, why did Cal do what he did when he didn't have his eyes on "the record?" Because that's the way he was raised. Get up. Go to work. Play hurt so long as it doesn't hurt the team. What makes you think that Cal's decision making process was any different for the last eight years of "the streak" than it was for the first eight? Certainly, as he got closer to "the record," that had to weigh somewhat in his mind, but, he had been playing as he had been playing for a DECADE and more without that consideration just as he did when "the record" was within reach. His numbers remained good. His fielding percentage didn't suffer. He, hurt or no, REMAINED the best person at that position for that team. (And, apparently in the minds of the fans...long before he was in reach of "the record" as he was selected for the all star team every year...) Cal just got up and went to work. Every day. For sixteen years. Hurt or no, he was the best person at that position on that team....and many times...the best person at that position in all baseball. I can't call that selfish. I call that a good work ethic, one which was established for at least A DECADE prior to his "chasing the record....."
CosmicConservative
Drax: Re: Ruth/Cobb - RBIs are as much a measure of how good your teammates are at getting on base as how good you are, and the Yankees clearly had better hitters in front of Ruth than the Tigers had in front of Cobb. I'm sure that had Cobb had the Yankees #1 and #2 hitters in front of him, he'd have had more runs batted in than Ruth. As it was Cobb DID have more "Teammates batted in" than Ruth did. Also Cobb did not have Lou Gehrig behind him to force pitchers to pitch to him. You have made the point that some records are as much about who you play with as what you do yourself, and I would argue that RBIs are very much in this category. You can't knock 'em in if they ain't on base. However, I will give you this. Ruth was much better at Cobb's game (hitting in general) than Cobb was at Ruth's game (home runs). Plus I keep pointing out that Ruth was one of the best pitchers in the game while he played that position. In that sense I would say that the two of them are about equal in terms of being "overall rounded players." Still I think that the home run title will change hands at least three or four more times in my lifetime, and Cobb's .367 (or even .366) will still be the top batting average mark. To me that means hitting for average is harder than hitting home runs. When Cobb retired he was the Wayne Gretzky of major league baseball. He quite literally held every single record of importance except the home run. (He retired as the RBI leader too, Ruth overtook him after he retired.) Ruth held home runs, walks and RBIs (and strike outs) when he retired. Cobb STILL held hits, doubles, triples, stolen bases, runs, batting average and a slew of other records when Ruth retired. I don't like Ty Cobb. I used to, when I was a kid. In part because we share a birthday. Back then they didn't talk about his personal life, and I was just looking at his on-field performance. It wasn't until I was an adult that I learned Ty Cobb could be a violent man and was undoubtedly a racist. I no longer like him, but I still can't overlook his on field legacy. Ruth was very, very good, and so was Aaron. Both Ruth and Aaron could hit for average and for power. Ruth in particular was an enormously capable athlete, in spite of his ungainly appearance in later years. I absolutely acknowledge Ruth's greatness and even if he had not hit 714 home runs, he would have been a first ballot hall of fame inductee on his hits alone. I just don't think his home run "record" is comparable to Ty Cobb's BA record precisely because it has been topped twice already. NOBODY is going to top Cobb's record. Nobody.
CosmicConservative
I can see the argument about Cal being an example of a "work ethic." I just don't buy it. I will agree that Cal had to perform for the first 8 years or so and was not handed anything to get to that point. However, the body ages, and it is simply inconceivable to me that at one point when Ripken was in sight of Gehrig's record, but had not yet set it, the Orioles Manager was presented with the decision of playing Cal or not, and the internal dialog I am certain went something like this: "OK, so Cal's really not up to it tonight, but he's always willing to go. He's been slumping at the plate, and he's banged up from that double play collision. I know he'll play, but we've got another SS who is healthy, hungry and needs to get a chance to show his stuff sometime. Still, if I take Cal out, I'm going to have to deal with the incredible second-guessing of my decision. The fans will be terribly disappointed. The GM will give me all kinds of grief about how the "streak" is pulling fans to the park every day, and now that's all over so revenue will drop... I guess Cal plays today too. Sigh..." You can tell me that I'm just making all this up, but I am dead certain in my own mind that exactly that sort of internal dialog took place, not just once, but many times, and as Cal got older and the streak got more important to the fans and to baseball in general, the decision to play Cal became more of a PR decision than a baseball decision. Maybe even to the point on some days that Cal himself was unwilling to sit down, not from selfishness, but from an awareness of the magnitude of the importance of the streak itself. So maybe I'm being too hard on his "selfishness" but whether it was his selfishness, or all the pressure from the many different directions, the end result was that on some (and I think "many") occasions, the Baltimore Orioles played someone other than the best person they could field at that position, and some young player with dreams of glory in the big leagues went another day without that dream coming true. I still don't like the record.
Drax
Sure, the body ages. But, point to the STATS that show that playing Ripken hurt...hurt the team. Point to a player who would have been BETTER at that position than one who brought Cal's bat and Cal's insane fielding percentage to the table. Sure, maybe the MANAGER made a decision about Cal in the end which he might not have made in the beginning, but that was the MANAGER'S decision, not Cal's. Again. Point to a GAME where Cal "hurt the team" because he, and not some other person, played the position. We can point to Aaron's record in comparison. At the end of his career, how many games would have turned out differently had a young player played his position rather than Aaron? But, it was Aaron, and he was chasing the record. You CHOOSE to believe that Cal was a selfish player. I choose to believe that, a person who played hurt (but Hall of Fame well) for over a decade just continued doing what he had always done. And, unless you're able to support that "feeling" with some facts, I'm giving him the benefit of the doubt.
CosmicConservative
OK, okay, I've already backed off the "selfish" accusation somewhat (but not entirely). But I can't say that Cal was any more selfish than, say, Ty Cobb when he was playing at the age of 44 and trying to push his hits record and other records into the unattainable range. All players are selfish, so I should get off Cal's back. (Although Ty Cobb's last year as a doddering old man he hit an impressive .323 and Cal Ripken hit a fairly pathetic .239. I'm betting the Orioles had a backup shorstop who could have topped .239. I doubt the Tigers had another outfielder who could top .323, and if so, not by much.) Back to the Ruth/Cobb comparison: Here are some stats, and all-time placement: Batting Average: Cobb #1, Ruth #9 Hits: Cobb #2, Ruth #38 Games: Cobb #5, Ruth #45 At Bats: Cobb #5, Ruth #94 Doubles: Cobb #4, Ruth #39 Triples: Cobb #2, Ruth #71 Home Runs: Cobb too low to measure, Ruth #3 RBIs: Cobb #6, Ruth #2 Walks: Cobb #44, Ruth #3 Stolen Bases: Cobb #4, Ruth too low to measure So, in 8 out of 10 of the top offensive categories (all but Walks and Home Runs) Cobb is STILL in the top ten, and in the top five in 7. Ruth is in the top ten in 4 categories, and in the top five in 3. For whatever that's worth.
Drax
Unless you take into consideration 17 full seasons versus 24, not much. Add another 5 full seasons to Ruth...in his youth...and you get a clearer picture of where they stood relatively. As to Ripken's last year... His last year was 2001. He broke the record in 1995. He sat down for the first time in 1998. What he did after 1995 is not pertinent to this debate.
CosmicConservative
Aw crud! I just looked at the all-time RBI numbers and Barry Bonds is actually now #6 in RBI, not Ty Cobb. Sheesh... Now that Bonds has passed Cobb in a stat, I'm prepared to nail him as the stoked up cheater that he is! Scrape the record books free of the name Barry Bonds! He cannot supplant Ty Cobb in any category! NEVER!!! ;)
CosmicConservative
Drax: OK, I'll say what he did after 1998 is not pertinent to the debate. As long as he was still advancing the record, it's still debatable whether he should have played... In 1998 he hit .271. That probably wasn't close to the lowest BA for a shortstop. OK OK Drax, you win. Cal is the man.
CosmicConservative
By the way, based on our Cal Ripken debate, I thought you considered longevity to be valuable in its own right, so it should be pertinent that Cobb played more years than Ruth. In fact, that should be more to Cobb's favor, not to his detriment. ESPECIALLY since those additional years, taken OFF Cobb's record, would have pushed his Batting average much higher than .367.
CosmicConservative
BTW, I think you overestimate the hitting in Cobb's era. Hitting in the high .300s was not common, in spite of the fact that Cobb was doing it. In that stretch (say 1900 - 1920) the winner of the batting title in the AL or NL had the following batting averages: 1904 NL Honus Wagner - .349 1905 AL Elmer Flick - .308 1906 NL Honus Wagner - .339 1907 AL Ty Cobb - .350 1907 NL Honus Wagner - .350 1908 AL Ty Cobb - .324 1909 NL Honus Wagner - .339 1910 NL Sherry Magee - .331 1911 NL Honus Wagner - .334 1912 NL Heinie Zimmerman - .372 1913 NL Jake Daubert - .350 1914 NL Jake Daubert - .329 1915 NL Larry Doyle - .320 1916 NL Hal Chase - .339 1917 NL Ed Roush - .321 1918 NL Zack Wheat - .335 1919 NL Ed Roush - .321 1920 NL Rogers Hornsby - .387 Frankly that looks a whole lot like exactly what we see today, INCLUDING 1912 and 1920. (Todd Helton won the title in 2000 with a .372 average and Barry Bonds won it in 2002 with a .370 average) The reason the AL figures for 1909 and onward are not included is that is when Ty Cobb was destroying pitching in the AL at a rate that was 50 to 70 points ABOVE the NL leading batter. In fact it was in the 1920s, when Cobb was in a slow decline and Ruth was playing, that the winning batting average in both leagues started hovering in the high .300s. When Cobb was in his prime there was only one player hitting in the high .300s on a yearly basis, and that man's name was Ty Cobb. When Ruth was hitting in the mid .300s a decade later, both leagues were seeing a lot of batters in the high .300s. You can draw your own conclusions about that. But when Cobb was playing and winning batting titles regularly, he was outpacing his NL peer by fifty points or more every single year. To me that is every bit as impressive as Ruth's home run dominance.
Drax
Heh. I think we have hammered a stake into the Ruth/Cobb debate. As to the longevity issue. It's important as to sustained excellence. Ruth had 5 years (in his youth) in which he only played part time. Both Ruth and Cobb had "declining years" at the end. We can't ignore the games not played by Ruth in the beginning if a fair comparison is to be made (especially in games played and at bats?) It's hard to compare some things. Ted Williams lost almost two full seasons to injuries and five seasons to the military....all in the full flower of his power. Ah, what might have been....
CosmicConservative
I absolutely agree with you about Williams. He put patriotism and duty above his own personal self-interest and I respect him all the more for that. He wasn't the only one either. And on the sustained excellence point, the whole debate here centered around Ty Cobb's LIFETIME batting average, not his single season record. If that isn't "sustained excellence" I don't know what is. Even in his declining years, he was hitting in the mid .300s. If you want to compare the best four years of Cobb's overall batting statistics to Ruth's best four years of batting statistics to settle this debate once and for all, you are on. You are soooo on. ;) By the way, you keep saying that Babe Ruth lost five years of his early career. I don't see that. I see that he came up late in 1914 and pitched a few games. It is not likely that he would have played significantly more games as a position player, coming up that late in the year it is likely that he was brought on as a roster expansion to help with a pennant race. He would not have been a starter. In 1915 he MAY have played a full year as a position player, but I find that unlikely, most players, even players like Ty Cobb, took a year or so to get settled into a position, so my guess is that he would have played much less than a full year in 1915. I'll give you 1916 and 1917. In 1918 he played half of the season as a regular player, then became a regular for the rest of his career, until his dotage. I think he lost, maybe, somewhere between 2.5 and 3 years from his early career. Not five.
Drax
Hmmm....but, we'd have to compare all the stats... And, yes. As I've acknowledged, Cobb is certainly in the top 10 best baseball players in the history of the game, based on his body of work....which is the only test of significance to me.
CosmicConservative
OK, here is the comparison: I took Ruth's best four years of his specialty (home runs) and Cobb's best four years of his specialty (hits). That meant I took the following years for Ruth: 1920, 1921, 1927, 1928 And the following years for Cobb: 1909, 1911, 1912, 1917 Here is the comparison:
StatCobbRuth%diff (C to R)
Games594599-00.8%
At Bats23052074+11.1%
Runs490656-33.9%
Hits915741+23.5%
Doubles154138+11.6%
Triples8141+97.6%
Home Runs30227-656.7%
RBIs419614-46.5%
Walks219569-159.8%
Strikeouts109337+209.2%
St. Base27542+554.8%
Bat. Avg..397.357+11.1%
This is actually pretty interesting. I will have to concede that Ruth was a run and an RBI machine, even when compared to Cobb, who was no slouch in either category. Cobb kills Ruth in the speed categories and almost never strikes out compared to Ruth. (I had to fudge Cobb's strike out numbers because apparently they did not keep them his first few years in the league, so I took an average from his later years and plugged those in). But I can't get over the runs and RBIs. Man, that's awesome...
Drax
Heh. Plug in the stats for OBP. I think its .491 to .631.... Lead off to clean up.... Meh. They were both awesome
CosmicConservative
You keep saying Cobb was leadoff. He hit third, just as Ruth did.
Drax
I never knew that! From his stats (looking at them froma modern day perspective) I just assumed he was lead off! Wow. Thanks. Never woulda thunk...
CosmicConservative
Actually I am seeing stuff online that says both that he batted third, and that he batted leadoff. Now I'm not sure. I assumed he batted third because he was the best hitter on the team. That's where I would have batted him. And I had seen references to that online before. Now I'm not sure. I'm digging.
Andy
CC & Drax: I like baseball as much as the next guy, and enjoy a friendly disagreement...but there is something really dangerous going on here. I hope you brothers don't live near each other, or visit the same bar on game night...someone would have a broken beer bottle in the neck at County General...and someone would be in County Lock-up (and the family would be destroyed). I am in awe. How do you guys know all this stuff about Ruth & Cobb & who batted in what order, and for how many years, and the game of baseball in general? It is kind of spooky...Write a book.
Drax
Heh. This is a decades old argument, revisited after decades.... In our youth, we both LOVED baseball with the kind of affection for its history and its heroes that is out of place any longer. (Part of what I do for a living is sell sports cards. It is distressing how little our kids are taught about the history of sports. If they knew the history of history, I wouldn't be so bothered, but, dang it, they should know something about SOMETHING....) We had baseball teams with figures from the past in our lineups, playing with cards from one of the Topps sets (can't remember the year...). It was astonishing how closely the members of our "fantasy" teams mirrored their real life performance. We had arguments over about everything, as could be expected of kids separated by only a year. History has proven me right on just about every issue.....except the Ruth/Cobb controversy. That one simply is a matter of taste...not fact.
CosmicConservative
Heh... I am forced to admit that Drax is right, he was right on just about everything, which is why he runs a sports collectible store now and I don't. We had famous arguments over who was better, Gaylord Perry or Fergie Jenkins (Drax had Fergie), whether Hank Aaron would break Ruth's record (Drax said he would) whether Ty Cobb or Babe Ruth was the "greatest ever" (I still say Cobb)... We both adored the sport of baseball, both played little league and both memorized the stats of many, many players. One of my favorite players back then was Roberto Clemente, who was killed in a plane crash after barely reaching 3,000 hits. I still think he would have made a serious run at a lot of all-time records had he lived. Believe it or not though, we didn't fight over baseball. We argued, debated and discussed, but we saved fisticuffs for more important things. Like who got to use the green or the red army men.
Drax
Heh. I gotta agree about Clemente. Best arm I've ever seen (although Vladamire Guerrero is dang close....)
CosmicConservative
Isn't OBP (On Base Percentage) calculated from (hits + walks + hit by pitch) / (at bats + walks + hit by pitch)? If so they are much closer, Cobb's .449 vs. Ruth's .495 (leaving out hit by pitch since those aren't recorded...)
CosmicConservative
Larry Walker had the best arm I've seen. I don't remember enough about watching Clemente to remember his arm. I know I've seen Larry Walker throw runners out at the plate with a perfect strike thrown from the warning track in right field at Coors field. More than once.
CosmicConservative
Oh, one aspect of the comparison that we haven't done is total bases, which is calculated as hits + doubles + 2* triples + 3 * home runs. That gives 1321 for Cobb and 1642 for Ruth. Which sounds bad until you realize that stolen bases are not included, but stolen bases are part of the contribution to base advancement so adding them in reflects how many bases the players actually reached on their own, in that case you get: Cobb: 1596 Ruth: 1684 Which is pretty dang close. BTW, Total Bases is yet another record where Cobb is ahead of Ruth, and in the top five while Ruth is in the top ten.... And, if you add total bases to stolen bases for a count of total base advancement, guess who still leads the major leagues for his career?
CosmicConservative
7,096 - Aaron Cobb has 6,746 for second place (from a quick calculation of the most obvious leaders....) Ruth is at 5,916 This is actually a statistic I think they should adopt and track. It's a great measure of power and speed. Call it total bases advanced, or TBA.
CosmicConservative
40 comments. This is insane. I guess I'll stop now.
Drax
Heh. Good debate... Checked calculation for OB%. You're correct, except that you divide by (AB + HBP + BB + SF (sacrifice hits))
CosmicConservative
Well, I'm not gonna find statistics on sacrifice hits from 1910, so I'll just call the OBP figures we've got "close enough." By the way, all time, Babe Ruth is #2 in OBP, Ty Cobb is #9 (Ted Williams is #1, Hank Aaron isn't even in the top 200, which is a huge surprise to me). Ruth = .474, Cobb = .433. Which is about the same spread as in their respective top 4 years, so I'm pretty confident that the top four year comparison is pretty good. Right behind Cobb is a guy named Todd Helton. Barry Bonds is #6 at .445.