Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The Bonds "hitting machine"

By CosmicConservative
Barry Bonds' HR Record Tainted by Elbow 'Armor'? NEW YORK (Commentary) Beyond his alleged steroid use, Barry Bonds is guilty of the use of something that confers extraordinarily unfair mechanical advantage: the “armor” that he wears on his right elbow. Amid the press frenzy over Bonds’ unnatural bulk, the true role of the object on his right arm has simply gone unnoticed.
Read the whole thing. The writer goes on to describe seven "advantages" that the contraption Barry Bonds wears on his elbow confers to his swing and his power. I think there is something to this. But not nearly as much as the writer does. The writer thinks Bonds has added as much as 100 home runs to his total due to this mechanical device. I doubt that it has added that much. But it is possible it has added some. Probably the most reasonable of the seven arguments made is the one that the device helps Bonds lock his swing in a more consistent fashion due to the elbow hinge, which essentially restricts motion on the swing. Most of the rest of the arguments I don't find very compelling. In fact some seem to contradict each other. It is hard to see how the device both "glues" his arm to his side, allowing him to spin faster on an inside pitch, and simultaneously provides additional mass and leverage for a power stroke on an outside pitch. If it provides so mush mass and leverage, it seems it would be much harder for Bonds to keep his arm at his side while spinning rapidly, and if it causes the arm to stay by his side, it seems it would be difficult to extend it for the power stroke. What I would think could be done quite easily is to confiscate the device and do some actual empirical analysis by running some simple experiments on the thing. My guess is that none of the seven supposed advantages provides anything close to the most obvious advantage the armor affords, which is the ability to fearlessly stand in the batters box where he has complete coverage of the outside part of the plate.

Comments (5)

Drax
I'm with you. Of the advantages, the most important is the consistency of swing. As any hitter will tell you, with age comes some fluidity in the swing, and it is one of the reasons that, even though they are just as strong as they once were, they tend to "get under" the ball more than they once did. I have to give Bonds his props. Had he not taken a single steroid, put on a single piece of armor, he would have been a first ballot Hall of Famer....if he had retired TEN YEARS AGO. I HATE that the conversation around such an awesome talent has denegrated to "steriods" and whatnot. Sigh.
Andy
Drax: I have to agree. In golf, football, cycling, skiing, ice skating, bobsledding, the luge,...I could go on and on...the equipment that the competitors use has made them better. I don't blame Barry Bondsoid for using the elbow armor. If I had to stand up there against those guys I would probably put on a medieval suit of armor. Bonds was a great young baseball player. I do hate that he thought that he needed something more than his ability and fortitude. He should have quit 8 or 10 years ago. He would probably be in the HOF class this year (or before)...relaxing at home with his family...running several businesses...able to walk with his "head up" anywhere. Instead, he is the home run king with a cloud over his head for the rest of baseball history...a good lesson for us all I suppose.
Drax
Unfortunately, it appears that the lessons our kids are receiving are: Cheaters DO prosper. Nice guys DO finish last. Winning isn't the most important thing; it's the ONLY thing. If I've heard these quotes once, I've heard them a hundred times from the talking heads on Sports Center or calling a game: "That was a good foul." (The ref wasn't looking; the ref's view was blocked. Whatever) "If you're not cheating, you're not trying." "He really sold that." (The "catch" that wasn't a "catch." The "foul" which was really a "flop." Etc.) Argh.
Andy
Hey Drax: Don't forget Bear Bryant: "It doesn't matter whether you win or lose...until you lose." I love competition as much as the next guy, but losses are going to come our way in life. It is a shame that young people can be corrupted by the desire to win. Hey, I like to win...but I know the value of a loss. A big "amen" to you. Your children are blessed to have a father that knows these things.