Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The Frodo Franchise

By Dadman
If I have any bona fide geek credentials, I earn them through my obsession with The Lord of the Rings, and specifically my fascination with the films recently produced and directed by Peter Jackson. Peter Jackson is my hero. I followed every step of the production for years via theonering.net breathlessly waiting for the next spy report. I am a charter member of The Lord of the Rings fan club. I own expensive Sideshow Weta polystone action figures (Sauron, Frodo, a Moria Orc Archer, a Numenorean Infantryman, a couple Gollums, a High Elven Infantryman, Pippin, etc.) trading cards, limited production calendars provided only to cast and crew, magazines, etc. I even have sediment from the river used in the Flight to the Ford scene given to me by a friend who visited New Zealand and did The Lord of the Rings movie tour. If you check the credits of the extended version DVDs of all three films you will find my name. Jackson promised all charter fan club members that their names would be included in the credits...and he came through. Like I said, my hero... A book has recently been published called The Frodo Franchise that provides a behind-the-scenes view of what transpired to ensure Jackson could make his trilogy and the marketing and selling of all things Tolkien. As a lifelong fan of The Lord of the Rings trilogy (as literature) I have mixed feelings about the crass commercialization of these classic novels. Of course, I would be a bit of a hypocrite if I protested too loudly...

Comments (6)

CosmicConservative
I find it interesting to compare my LOTR interest to yours Dadman. I remember having a Hildebrandt calendar on our dorm room, but I don't remember whose calendar it was. I remember my first ever attempt at sculpture being a figure of Gandalf I made out of white sticky-tacky stuff we used to hang stuff on the wall since we were forbidden to put tacks in the wall. As has been noted before on this blog, I used to read LOTR at the end of each quarter while waiting for grades to be posted. I still manage to read it at least once per year or so. My conservative estimate is that I've read those books at least 30 times, perhaps as many as 40 times. It was LOTR that got me interested in role playing games like Dungeons and Dragons. I may not have LOTR collectibles, but I have a suite of characters that I have role-played so much that they are personalities I can adopt as easily as pulling on a bathrobe. That includes wizards, rangers, druids, clerics and thieves of many sorts. I am looking right now at a dragon calendar the Cosmic Daughter bought me for my birthday that was undoubtedly inspired by Tolkien. Yet I do not have a single LOTR collectible item of any sort. The Cosmic Daughter has an Arwen necklace, but that's the only LOTR paraphernalia (outside of the books, of course) that you could find in our house. Which is sort of weird because I would greatly enjoy having a collection of the sort you have put together, and no doubt it's a pretty marketable long-term investment as well. But all of my miniatures and sculpted items are either things I made myself, or were purchased specifically as game pieces. I even make origami creatures that can be used as game pieces. I guess my own LOTR passion evolved into wanting to participate in that sort of world as much as possible. And to that end I've devoted countless hours of time and effort into creating alternate magical worlds of my own, or creating the characters that meander around worlds created by other people. And again there is irony because I find the Middle Earth versions of such games (those based rigidly on Tolkien's world) to be among the least fun to play. They are too constrained and the magic is too tame for my taste. I don't want to sneak up on a dragon and steal its loot while some bowman gets a lucky miracle shot that downs it, no I want to walk up to the dragon and beat it fair and square, using whatever strength or power that exists in "my" own hands or wits. But while you end up with valuable marketable merchandise, I will end up with nothing really but a pile of interesting old papers that detail years of effort, but have no value beyond my own enjoyment. Weird...
Dadman
Hmmmm... I think one way of characterizing the difference is you seem to have a broader appreciation of the fantasy genre and I am very LOTR focused. I don't much like fantasy books or films outside of what Tolkien created. All else I find derivative. Your appreciation of Tolkien and broader fantasy realms seems to manifest itself via these role playing games, as if you want to become the characters in the novels. As you know, I've never gone that far with it. I'm content to be thoroughly engrossed and entertained by Tolkien's story as I'm reading it (and I've only read the trilogy about 5 times) and then appreciate its artistic magnficence between readings. But I think a better distinction is the one between literature and film. I didn't become a big LOTR collector until the films went into production. Most of the items I have are directly related to the movies. None of it existed prior to the films being produced. As you know I am a huge film fan and when I learned these films were being made it was like my own personal nirvana. Since the day I started reading Tolkien, starting with The Hobbit, I literally fantasized about these films being made the right way - 3 live action films with high production values, produced by people passionate about Tolkien's world. Jackson was the guy born to do it. I am fascinated by the creative challenge making good movies presents - and LOTR was the Holy Grail of creative film making. All that came out of that process - set design, character design, music, imagery, sound, performance, choreography, cinematography, etc. has been endlessly fascinating to me. I was always eager to see if Jackson's vision matched the one in my own mind. He rarely disappointed. So I've been eager to own some of the creative fruits of Jackson's work, whether it be the imagery/ photography of key characters captured for a cast calendar, or fan club magazines that provided updates on the production's progress, or high quality statues/figures that possess great detail and artistry. I just love the stuff... I love the books too, but I don't feel compelled to enter the book and be one of the characters...
CosmicConservative
Dadman: That's an interesting perspective. I am not nearly as visual as you are, I liked the movies, but find the books to be far more enjoyable, even on the fortieth reading. I appreciate the efforts you describe and can examine them critically, and I agree with your conclusions about Jackson and the whole LOTR movie team. They did it right and created what will become one of the most enduring classics in movie history. But I think you are misunderstanding my motivation behind role playing games. I actually have absolutely no desire to "be one of the characters" in the book. And I don't feel "compelled" to do it any more than I feel "compelled" to go fishing. It's something I find entertaining and challenging. The characters I create to role play are unique characters with their own life histories, motivations and skills. Most of the enjoyment of playing the game is actually in the interaction with other players as we try to solve unique and challenging problems. Unlike many games, role playing games have an inherent risk associated with them that your character could actually be destroyed and not be playable any longer. This greatly increases the attention to detail that you have in playing the game. Or it should anyway. There are always good and bad role players. The reason I play D&D, and especially the reason I run campaigns myself, is that I am fascinated with the creative efforts involved. In some ways it's a miniature version of the creative process you are describing, with the additional challenge of creating something open-ended so that the "story" has a chance to evolve as the characters interact with the world and with each other. I love games of all sorts. I consider myself something of a game aficionado. I play card games, board games, puzzle games, computer games, etc. I've invented several games of my own. I think the reason I became so fascinated with role playing games is not that I want to "become a character" in a book, it is more that role playing is the most challenging and engaging game experience I have encountered. When done well it is an incredibly enjoyable experience. When done badly it sucks. It's sort of a combination of story writing, acting, set creation, problem solving, competitive impulses, and abject fear of failure that would end up with losing something actually valuable to you.
Dadman
Well, your original comment was basically...'this is how I appreciate Tolkien (i.e. playing role playing games, creating miniatures, etc.) and this is how you seem to appreciate it (collecting LOTR memorabillia) and isn't that interesting. And then you said: 'I guess my own LOTR passion evolved into wanting to participate in that sort of world as much as possible. And to that end I’ve devoted countless hours of time and effort into creating alternate magical worlds of my own, or creating the characters that meander around worlds created by other people.' So, I don't think I misunderstood as much as I may have been misled...;>) There's no need to debate the merits of role playing games. I know they are fun, engaging, challenging and all the rest. On the rare occassions I have taken time to play them I've had a lot of fun. I should probably play them more often, but no one ever asks me to. So play away, Cosmic, and enjoy...
CosmicConservative
True... I do enjoy fantasy fiction and enjoy the concept of magic and fantastic creatures. And I do think it was Tolkien that first got me started in contemplating such worlds. In my first response I guess I neglected to focus on the amount of influence my interest in games had on the desire to play role playing games. Perhaps it is more accurate to say that I would likely be playing role-playing games of some sort (perhaps straitht sci-fi, which I have done on occasion) but LOTR gave me more of an appreciation for the fantasy versions of those games, and LOTR is more properly identified as the reason I play D&D vs. say, Star Wars roleplaying games. I agree that my first post made it seem more like LOTR led me directly to role playing games. I will amend that now and say that LOTR really directed my interest in role playing games towards the fantasy genre than the sci-fi one. Which is also ironic because I read probably five sci-fi books for every fantasy book I read. So there is something compelling about the fantasy milieu that I find more fun to play than straight sci-fi. I have never really tried to examine why that might be so.
CosmicConservative » The zombie threat
[...] Dadman, I just had to post this one. Last one tonight, I promise. I did get “Frodo Franchise” back on the front [...]