Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Intel's racist ad...

By Dadman
Intel is in a lot of trouble over a print ad that was recently released into the world. Mea culpas are flying all over the place here at Intel (I work at Intel), including a mea culpa from the big man himself, Paul Otellini. Here's what he had to say:
Many of you have written to me over the past two days regarding the "sprinter" ad. Your notes have expressed shock and concern, and you demanded to know how a company as great as ours could have run this ad. First of all, I want you to know that, as CEO, I take personal responsibility for the offensive ad that appeared in Intel’s name—the sprinter ad advertising the Core 2 Duo. I believe that the ad is insensitive, insulting and of course should never have seen the light of day. On behalf of the company I apologize for it appearing. We have canceled the ad buy, and are in the process of taking it down wherever it appears.
Here's the ad: What do you think? Intel is being excoriated all over the blogosphere for this. Do they deserve it or is it an overreaction? I just hope my buddies in marketing had nothing to do with this ad. The PC hounds smell blood on this one and it could get ugly...

Comments (18)

Andy
Dadman: I don't know. If I just saw the ad without knowing that it had been branded "racist," I would not have thought anything about it. Since I know that it is controversial, I look at it differently. Yea, the sprinters are black, and the other guy (whatever he is supposed to be) is white. So, is the outcry because white guys can't sprint, or because black guys can't stand there looking like they have a selection of pocket protectors? I really don't get it.
Dadman
The most common complaint I've heard is that it appears the sprinters are bowing down before the evil, white overlord. And all the sprinters look a like, evidently reinforcing an old racial stereotype.
Drax
This is just insane. I could understand it if blacks got upset because all the sprinters were black. After all, blacks don't run faster sprints than whites...all the track and field results clearly indicate this. But, no. They apparently aren't offended by the stereotype that blacks run faster than (everyone else) since, at least at this point in history, that is a fact.... They're offended because the "sprinters" are in a classic sprinter's pose just before the gun sounds, deciding to think that, instead of the picture depicting EXACTLY what it was intended to depict (i.e., sprinters just about to burst out of the blocks...showing the new "maximized" performance of the employees...) the ad "really" is about a "white overlord." God. Shoulda had it all backwards. Put a black woman in charge and have all the sprinters be white.
Andy
Dadman: Thanks for the clarification. Having never worked in the corporate world I just didn't get it. So the white guy is the supervisor, and the black sprinters are the underlings...got it! The controversy is really stupid. I don't know...if I was a black guy with a chip on my shoulder, I might be offended. Not being a black guy with a chip on my shoulder I can not say for sure. I tend to agree with Drax. The ad is probably less racially offensive than it is just plain wrong. Drax wrote: "Shoulda had it all backwards. Put a black woman in charge and have all the sprinters be white." I understand from friends (and from family) that things (more often than not) pan out that way in corporate America. The thing that interests me most about the whole controversy is Intel's CEO's statement. He takes personal responsibility (an admirable move), and then bows down to obvious PC pressure (not so admirable). I know that he has a lot of plates to spin as a CEO of a major corporation...responsibility to the shareholders...to the employees, etc. It would just be nice to once hear a CEO tell the PC Police to "take a flying leap."
Andy
I am watching the WGC Bridgestone Invitational this afternoon. Obviously white guys can't sprint, and black guys can't golf.
CosmicConservative
Hmm... So are we now forced to acknowledge that it is a racist act for a group of black sprinters to crouch down at a race if the starting gun is fired by a white man? That's what it means, isn't it? This is just a way to get white people out of the business of firing starting guns, a practice that has probably outraged the sensibilities of black sprinters for decades now. So, let's get on that, OK?
Andy
Black sprinters...white guy with a gun? You are dangerously close to the edge with that one CC. You guys are a trip...thanks!
Kevin in WI
This is a bunch of PC hogwash. That's not racist at all - even if some aggrieved individuals or hyperactive PC police say it is.
CosmicConservative
Andy, but that's what it's all ABOUT! If there's ever going to be any progress.... (p.s., if anyone gets that reference, I will bow in homage..)
Dadman
Um...that would be from Monty Python and the Holy Grail...the mud stacking scene and the obnoxious peasant... Bow now in homage please...
CosmicConservative
Hmm.. can't seem to create a passable bowing emoticon.... I bow in your general direction...
Andy
Hmm...you guys lost me...again...I know a guy named Monty, and I know that a Python is a big old snake...and I have been called obnoxious...and I have shot a pheasant...but I can't put those things together... I have to go...the nice lady in the white coat is bringing me my pills.
Darrick
Imagine that,a blog full of conservative white guys not getting why black people are offended. The truth is that if this were 1807 and not 2007 you guys would not be offended by a white man with a whip standing over black slaves with the same wording. Know why? Because you are the ones would have been cracking that whip just as you are today's corporate masters. Then you wonder why us black folks never vote Republican. You guys are terribly insensitive. The whole conservative outlook on race relations goes like this; "We gave you your freedom and your right to vote, now act like us. Everything's cool now right?" No, everything is not cool Republicans. Look at your candidates for President...and the winner is....a white guy in a suit. You guys would be funny if you weren't so dangerous.
Darrick
P.S. I happen to work for Intel and good luck finding 6 black men working in any IT department.
CosmicConservative
Darrick: I hope you manage your anger and resentment in public life better than you do from your keyboard. I could not care less about your opinion of whether I or my friends are racist. I know my own opinions and biases quite well, and after 20 years in management at large companies, including a major Fortune 100 company, I have worked with a lot of minorities. So far none of them have indicated any problem with my attitudes. I work in the IT area and I agree with you that there are few African Americans working in IT. In fact the last two black people I had on my team were from Kenya and Niger. Both were excellent programmers. Both came from areas suffering severe economic distress, yet they somehow managed to develop the skills needed to become programmers, and they have no trouble whatsoever finding employment in the field. I was happy to hire them, and they beat out more than one white programmer who interviewed for the same position. The current situation I have with programmers is that the majority of the ones I work with are from India or Israel. I don't think I could find six white, male programmers in my area these days. So I suppose I could be as bitter and resentful about that as you are, but I choose not to be. I am pretty sure that all of us "white guys" here on this blog are very well aware of why this ad could be offensive to certain black people. We just think that the offense taken is more an indication of their attitudes than it is an indication of any intent or bias on the part of Intel or the PR company who put this together. To put it bluntly the racism that is being exhibited in this issue is not coming from the white guys. So go ahead and be as offended as you want to be. That's your issue, not mine. BTW, last time I checked, every Democratic President so far has been a "white guy in a suit." Hillary would be the first "White woman in a suit." I'd vote for any number of black candidates before I'd vote for her, including Condoleeza Rice or Justice Clarence Thomas. Would that appease you?
Drax
Darrick: You are a prime example why this country is unlikely to have anything resembling a racial meeting of the minds anywhere in the near future. You CHOOSE to see something offensive in an ad which, if taken at face value (and not LOOKING FOR and CHOOSING TO FIND "code words" or whatnot) is innocent in the extreme. First, let's examine the motivations of those who CREATED the ad. Are you saying that the admen/women PURPOSELY set out to offend blacks when they created this ad? I suppose that some people think that is a likely circumstance, i.e., the ad men/women sitting around trying to figure out how to craft an ad which INTENTIONALLY is designed to anger a huge percentage of potential buyers. That is a SURE WAY to get re-hired by ANYONE in the future, right? Second, let's examine the motivations of those who PLACED the ad, i.e., Intel. Again, I suppose that there are some people who think that the people who run Intel PURPOSELY set out to offend a huge part of their potential market by placing an offensive ad. Again, that's probably a good recipe for attracting business in the future... Now, let's examine the ad itself: 1. I'm going to assume (probably incorrectly) that you find nothing offensive about the TEXT of the ad. I looked, but couldn't find any "code words." I'm sure that some people can "find" something offensive in those words if they look hard enough. 2. The setting? Is the setting offensive? It looks like a typical cubicle office set up. I guess someone could find that racially insensitive somehow... 3. The sprinters? Are you offended by the fact that the sprinters are black? Should they be Asian? We all know how successful Asians have been over the past 50 years in sprint competitions, right? Should they have been white? Again. Whites have proven over the past two decades or so that they are vastly superior to all other races in running sprints, eh? So, are you offended by the fact that the sprinters are BLACK, a recognition that BLACKS are more likely to actually WIN a sprint? I guess there are some who could be offended by having their race depicted as SUPERIOR to all others in a given activity.... 4. Are you offended that the "boss" is white? What race should he have been? You have two other choices... Would you have been satisfied if he was black? That way, the ad would have been all black. That good enough for you? Is that the only way that this ad would have passed your muster...? Until people such as you get a clue, we are not going to EVER make any progress in race relations in the U.S. As long as you SEEK to find offense, you will find it. No matter how sanitized the ad (or whatever), no matter how carefully people attempt to assuage you, you will ALWAYS find offense... Because you WANT to. Because it fits your world view.
Drax
Man...how can I edit my posts??? I said "inoffensive" when I meant "offensive." Sigh.
CosmicConservative
Drax: You don't appear to be registered on the site. Click on the "register" link and create a user and I'll give you edit privileges. I'll give you posting privileges too if you want.