Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Conservative vs. Liberal - the Gospel of Mark Helprin

By CosmicConservative
Unfortunately I don't subscribe to the National Review so I only get the lead-in to some National Review Online editorials, like this one from Mark Helprin. Now I can't read the whole thing, but I assume it follows this general line of reasoning:
Although some who use Conservatism as an implement may not think so, Conservatism broadly speaking stems from an impulse of far greater import than politics alone. And in this regard, perhaps the most fundamental division between conservatives and modern liberals is a belief or disbelief in an ordered universe, the splendor of which is an invitation to man to try for his justice and works to approximate the constancy and balance of natural laws, and for his reticence in the command and direction of others to be appropriate to his limited powers. To believe instead in accident and disorder is to refuse the evidence of a universe that hangs together rather well, in favor of the primacy of man, and therefore the legitimacy of pure power. The implications of this philosophical and temperamental difference — divine purpose for the conservative bent of mind and random disorder for the liberal — play themselves out in every conceivable situation.
Putting aside for a moment that I can only dream about writing as convincingly and beautifully as Mark Helprin, I do want to address his fundamental premise, which I take to be that conservatives believe that the universe is divinely ordered (to the benefit of man) while liberals believe that the universe is randomly disordered. I describe myself as a "rational conservative" for a reason, and one reason is because I try to avoid invoking divine authority in order to espouse conservative ideals. First, I don't think conservatism needs the blessings of the divine to be compelling, and second, if you don't believe in the divine, then you are unlikely to give much weight to such invocation in debate. There is also the notion that "random" is "disordered." In some ways, perhaps counter-intuitively, random distribution is the most ordered process man has ever discovered. It may be nearly impossible to predict the behavior of one atom, but when you have untold bazillions of them, their behavior is perhaps the most predictable thing we know of. But even beyond this, there is the notion that liberals believe the universe is "randomly disordered." That is not even close to an accurate representation of the belief of modern cosmologists, astronomers, biologists, geologists, etc. The universe is demonstrably an ordered system. The fundamental forces that govern the universe are constant and, as far as we can determine by observation, universal. Add to that that there are actually very few forces and constants to deal with and the most amazing thing about the universe, as Einstein once said, is that it is understandable. If conservatives are going to try to demonstrate the superiority of their position over liberalism, it is best to present arguments that demonstrate an understanding of both sides. In this case, in spite of Helprin's brilliant prose, his fundamental assumptions are flawed.

Comments (0)

No comments on this post.