Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

A question of liability

By CosmicConservative
So Friday afternoon in Phoenix a man stole a truck and led the police on a dangerous high-speed chase. In the course of the chase he stole another truck, and then invaded a private residence where he was finally captured. As a direct result of his actions in the high speed chase, two helicopters from rival TV stations in Phoenix sent their news helicopters to film the chase. The helicopters collided at about the time the suspect in the chase abandoned one truck and stole another. Four people on the helicopters died. Who should be at fault for their deaths? Should it be the suspect, for initiating the entire situation? There are laws on the books about deaths in the commission of a felony, and there have been many convictions of murder, most upheld by the appeals courts, because the actions of the criminal led to the death of another person. In one case a woman was convicted of murder because her accomplice was killed by a store clerk who was protecting himself from them. But what about the helicopter pilots who did not adequately survey the situation and apparently were more intent on following the action on the ground instead of the traffic in the air? And what about the news stations who send their news copters into situations like this, knowing there will be multiple helicopters involved? Who should be held at fault? You can bet there will be lawsuits. Should there be a criminal indictment of anyone?

Comments (4)

Brian
I'm not a lawyer of course, just a guy. To me it feels like the people to blame are the pilots who flew into each other. I have a feeling, however, that the guy who initiated the chase is going to get a metric ton of the blame with lawsuits and criminal filings held over his head.
CosmicConservative
The NTSB will come back with a ruling on pilot error. But should the management of the respective TV stations be held accountable because they put their staff in harms way in order to get a "money shot" which is why they were following the chase anyway.
Drax
Hmmm...you have to ask the first question that any lawyer would ask: "Where is the deep pocket?" Is any lawyer going to spend a ton of time and money attempting to prove that the CRIMINAL is "liable?" Why would he do that? The criminal ain't got no cash. So, now whoever is suing will have to attempt to find the "deep pocket." I'm not sure who owned the helicoptors, who employed the pilots, or who gave the order to chase, but, I AM sure that someone is asking those questions right now. Further, now the question of "what is foreseeable?" arises. The police department is well aware of the potential of disaster on the road when they engage in high speed pursuit. It is entirely foreseeable that a car wreck or two might result of a high speed chase. When that happens, there is a balancing of the needs of the state to catch criminals, to catch THAT criminal RIGHT THEN, the crime for which he is sought...against the potential of a car crash. But, is it foreseeable that two helicopters would crash due to a car chase? That is the question which would first have to be answered in order to hold the police liable.
CosmicConservative
Drax: Heh, you are getting close to the point I was driving at. I'm pretty sure you are exactly right, and the questions are very much around "who has the cash?" as much as "who made the error?"