Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Best athlete ever?

By CosmicConservative
So, Drax suggested that nobody compares to Babe Ruth in comparison to their athletic contemporaries. I've actually always felt that Ruth was a bit overrated frankly, so I will take that challenge and put up a series of athletes who so dominated their sports during their careers that Ruth's "domination" pales in comparison. I'll start with baseball. Ty Cobb. OK, he was a jerk, probably a racist and was accused of being a violent man. But when Ty Cobb retired he held every major league offensive record he cared to own. Hits. Doubles. Triples. RBIs. Stolen Bases. Batting Average. On Base Percentage. Just about the only records he didn't own were the home run and walks, which, coincidentally, are the two that Ruth and Bonds are so famous for. Cobb hated to walk, he felt it was an insult. Ty Cobb got fed up with the Ruth Legend and in one series told a reporter that he was going to "swing for the fences." He hit five home runs in the next two days, hit safely in nine straight at bats and set a new AL record for home runs and RBIs in a series. He just didn't like strolling around the bases, he wanted to terrorize them. Edwin Moses in track and field. This guy won every meet he ran in for over a decade. He set the world record in the 400 meter hurdles four consecutive times (meaning he beat his OWN record three times consecutively). No other runner has dominated a track and field sport for more than a few years. He did it for over a decade. Jack Nicklaus/Tiger Woods. These guys were so dominant in their sport that they redefined the sport entirely. Until Tiger tops Jack's 18 majors, I'm giving the edge to Jack in this. He not only won 18 majors, he came in second more than he won. Roger Federer. He has won one out of every three tennis majors he has entered. He has held the number one ranking for more consecutive weeks than any other tennis player. He has won 11 tennis Grand Slam titles. He is 26 years old. He shows no signs of slowing down. Martina Navratilova. She won 18 Grand Slam singles titles, 31 doubles titles and 10 mixed doubles titles. Nobody is even in the same universe with her. Then there was this guy named Wayne Gretzky who was so good that his scoring record was more than twice the second place scoring record when he retired. I could go on. Babe Ruth was a phenomenon. Most of my respect for Babe Ruth comes from the fact that he was an all-star and World Series record holder as a PITCHER before he became a slugger. That's really amazing. But as amazing as he was, I wouldn't even call him the best baseball player ever. Ty Cobb wins that title hands down. And in sports overall? Who is the most dominant figure in my lifetime in their sport? Hard to top Michael Jordan. All time? Hmm.. names like Wilt Chamberlain or Mark Spitz come to mind...

Comments (27)

Drax
Heh. When Babe Ruth broke the home run record the first year that he was an everyday player, he hit 29. That was 19 more than the old record. The next year, when he hit 54, that was more than any other AL TEAM. When he retired with 714, that was almost two and a half TIMES the number of home runs of anyone else. Ty Cobb, on the other hand, in comparison to his contemporaries, ended his 24 year career with 4189 hits in comparison to Honus Wagner who ended his 21 year career with 3415 hits (Cobb hit around 360 hits in his last three years). Cobb had a lifetime BA of .366 versus Wagner's of .327. Sure, Cobb has more hits and a better batting average, but IN COMPARISON to Wagner? Heck, in comparison to RUTH... In SEVENTEEN full seasons as an every day player and five as a pitcher, he had 2873 hits (had he played full time the other five years, that number might be closer to 3300 hits). He had a .342 BA, even higher than that of Wagner who won SEVEN batting titles. The "lumbering fatso" had 136 TRIPLES (still 71st all time). Cobb was a great player, and next to Williams, probably the greatest hitter ever to play the game. He ain't no Ruth.
Drax
And, these other guys... When Spitz wins 2.5 times more medals than any other person, we might be talking. Gretzky is close. He single handedly changed Hockey. However, Howe had only 93 less goals than Gretzky (894 to 801) and 1049 to 1963 Assists. (It is in assists where Gretzky outshines everyone else by far...not "scoring goals.") At no point did Gretzky score more goals than any other TEAM. When he retired, he didn't have more than 2.5 times as many GOALS (the "home run" of hockey, I suppose) as anyone else. Jordan? I'm sorry, but Jordan didn't even score as many goals as other players. His points per game just over 1 more than Chamberlain. We really don't need to look at any of his other stats because in EVERY ONE of them, he doesn't hold any records (in many cases, not even on the leader board...SHAQ
Drax
Sorry, dang it...hit enter.... To continue... SHAQ has a better field goal percentage than he does...
Andy
I don't really know if anyone that plays a team sport can be considered the best athlete ever. So much of their performance depends on what their mates set them up to accomplish. Ruth...unbelievable! If he had the DH rule he may have hit 900 home runs. Gretzky...fabulous! His phenomenal skill introduced hockey to masses that never cared before. I think that he is the reason that hockey is popular nationwide now...even here in my town in the south where there is not even an ice rink. But I think it almost has to be an individual sport guy (or gal). Their success or failure just belongs to them alone. If you define the best athlete by how they dominate their sport, Edwin Moses would have to be in the top two or three. Nicklaus and Woods are great, but they lost/lose far more than they win. The tall Texan Lance Armstrong is right in there, even though his sport fudges as an individual/team sport. Just sheer physical prowess...in his day Carl Lewis was probably the greatest physical specimen to compete in anything, anytime, anywhere. And there are countless, little known triathletes that defy reality by what they can do, and the short time that they can do it in (both male and female). How do you determine the "best" anything? My wife makes the "best" eggplant parmesan in the world. The "Best" anything is a matter of personal taste I guess.
ams1491625
Speaking of baseball, I once commeneted that it should be broken down cronologically into BS and AS (before steroids and after steroids)
CosmicConservative
Ruth did not hit more home runs than any other team because nobody else COULD do it... he hit more home runs than any other team because nobody else WANTED to do it, as Cobb proved. I will give you this, Ruth changed the game of baseball. Cobb played it according to the expectations of his time, and that was to run the bases. Home runs were not the "fun" part of the game. So yes, when Ruth started his assault on the home run record he blew away the rest of the league. Within three years he didn't even win the home run title. By then 40 home runs per year became common. So I consider Ruth's "Ruthian" numbers to be a historical anomaly that lasted only until other players in the league said "gee, chicks dig the long ball." Once that happened Ruth was winning home run titles by two or three home runs when he won them. His lifetime home run totals were impressive, but no more than Gretzky's lifetime scoring totals, just to use one example. As I said, people make way too much of the fact that Babe Ruth was the first player to reach the 40 home run plateau. OK, he did that. But it was not long before he was just one of many doing it, and that has been the case ever since.
CosmicConservative
It is fair also to note that the "House that Ruth built" had a right-field home run fence that was clearly built to help Ruth inflate his home run stats. As to Coors field. You don't see much in the way of inflated hitting or home run stats here anymore. Three years ago they installed a humidor to keep baseballs as moist as at sea level ballparks. This single act has reduced home runs so much that the Rockies are middle-of-the-pack home run hitters. Coors field will never shed it's "hitters paradise" reputation because people simply can't get over things, but statistically in the past three years Coors field has become a pitchers ballpark. There were many studies done on the "thin air" theory of Coors Field and all of them came up short of explaining the home run frequency. The ball simply does not fly that much further due to the lesser air resistance, that is made up for by the longer distance to the fences, something they did after mathematical analysis to offset the thinner air. What they did not account for is that a baseball is both lighter and more elastic when it is drier. Keeping the balls moist has taken care of that problem.
Drax
Ruth began his career in the "dead ball" era. "Small ball" was the order of the day. When you hit .340, have 170+ hits per season, you're still playing "small ball." It's just that Ruth hit 40 or so of his hits over the fence. Cobb could not do this. Not would not. Could not. Cobb was INSCENSED by Ruth's popularity. Until Ruth, Cobb was the most highly paid and most "popular" baseball player. Ruth's ability to hit home runs made both of these things no longer true. Had Cobb the ABILITY to hit home runs and TAKE from Ruth these things, he WOULD HAVE DONE SO. He could not. NO ONE COULD. Ruth was simply in a league of his own in comparison to his contemporaries. And that's what began this conversation in the other threads...how an athlete compared to his contemporaries. Ruth was so far and beyond what his contemporaries did that the phrase "there isn't a close second" might have been COINED to describe just how much he dominated the game. Gretzky is the only one who comes close to being that..."not even a close second."
CosmicConservative
So, how do you explain Cobb telling a reporter he was going to "swing for the fences" in one series and then hitting five home runs in two games? A fluke? There were very few flukes in Cobb's career. Now, if Cobb had made it his goal to hit home runs for an entire season, would he have kept up with Ruth? I don't know, but he'd probably have been in the ballpark. I take him at his word, he enjoyed running the bases. Ruth hit more home runs, but who scored more runs? Cobb felt that his style of baseball was winning games, and Ruth's was just show-off. I'm not saying who was right, I sure like watching home runs myself, I'm just saying that Cobb's stats are far more impressive to me than Ruth's are. Ty Cobb held something like 90 major league records when he retired. How many did Ruth hold? Has any player in any sport ever come close to anything like that? That is AT LEAST as impressive as Ruth's home runs. And just as statistically overwhelming.
CosmicConservative
By the way, when both were elected to the Hall of Fame, the same year, by the same voters, Ty Cobb got more votes than Babe Ruth. Did you know there is a book about their rivalry? Ty and the Babe
CosmicConservative
So Drax, you realize that Ty Cobb held the baseball bat with his hands apart so that he could "spray" the ball wherever he wanted, right? That was why he didn't hit home runs, that way of holding the bat simply didn't translate into powerful bat speed. When he decided to "swing for the fences" he held the bat in a conventional way, and that's why he put it over the fence. But he just didn't like that, and preferred the "small ball" game. And as a "small ball" player he set more offensive records than any other player in history, perhaps the only ones he didn't own when he retired were walks and home runs, neither of which he cared about. This debate has raged for 80 years, and neither of us are going to solve it. Your assertion that Ruth was somehow superhuman beyond any comparable athlete is what I disagree with. He was a home run hitter who could hit for average, which is definitely a rare thing. Cobb was an offensive genius who terrorized the other team when he was on the bases. Ty Cobb more than once singled, stole second, third and home. If you want to use Ruth's statistically anomalous home run totals up to show Ruth's singular stature, I'll use Cobb's incredible collection of separate records to do the same thing. Which is more impressive? Well, I guess that's a matter of taste. But to say that Ruth was that superior to Cobb, in my opinion, puts way too much emphasis on a singular statistic, one that Ruth really only dominated for a few years before other players began challenging him for even that title. I put the two of them in the same category frankly. Cobb was the better athlete and the more versatile player. Ruth was the phenom who transformed the game. I'll just leave one final thing on the table here, and then I'll move on to other subjects. Of the two, which do you think currently holds more active major league offensive records?
Andy
Sorry for wasting everyone's time with my comment! I thought that this was about the best athlete ever...did not know that it was a contemporary comparison thing. Edwin Moses, or Lance Armstrong.
Andy
Also...don't forget Joe Louis. I know that he didn't win them all, but the longevity and success would be hard to top by any athlete.
Drax
Of course, Ricky Henderson broke Cobb's record for runs scored, and Ruth still holds the record for runs scored by a left hander for a single season. Aaron has the record for most consecutive seasons with 100+ runs scored. Ruth, of course, has the record for most seasons leading the league in scoring runs (8--Three others share 2nd place with 5--none of whom are Cobb). Don't forget, Ruth had SEVENTEEN SEASONS as an everyday player....Cobb had twenty-four. And, Ruth STILL led the league in runs scored in EIGHT of them (almost 50%). Ruth's on base percentage was .474 while Cobb's was .433 -- (Of course, Williams has the highest lifetime on base percentage -- .481, a bit better than Ruth...a lot better than Cobb...) Let's see: -- Career at bat/RBI record....Ruth is #1. Cobb? Not in top 100. -- Career walks? Ruth is #3. Cobb? #44. -- Career BA? Cobb is #1. Ruth? #10. -- Career hits? Cobb is #2. Ruth? #38 with 5 seasons in which he played as a pitcher. Add in a reasonable 350 for those years and he's in the top 5. -- On Base percentage? Ruth is #2. Cobb is #8. Cobb was lead off....Ruth clean up... -- RBI? Ruth is #2. Cobb is #5. -- Runs scored? Cobb is #2. Ruth is #4. (Remember...5 seasons as a pitcher....Cobb played 3 more seasons....and only 72 runs scored separate them) These are the stats which compare favorably, for the most part, for Cobb, and Ruth either beats him, or when he doesn't beat him, he comes close (and probably would have beat him if he had played 5 seasons full time in most categories.) When Ruth came to bat, Ruth was more likely to get on base, was more likely to knock in a run, and, once on base, was more likely to score a run (figuring that in 5 seasons (still 3 less years than Cobb) Ruth could have scored 73 more times...). Then, there's the home runs.... Old argument. I don't know WHY it's an old argument, but it is....
CosmicConservative
I concede that the two are comparable in many ways. Your assertion was that Ruth was in an entirely different category. I think he was only in home runs, and Cobb was equally as impressive in other categories, so I call it a wash. Back to the subject of "most dominant athlete against his peers", I still think it's tough to beat Edwin Moses.
CosmicConservative
Andy, you certainly aren't wasting anyone's time. This is an OLD argument between me and Drax. Drax is my older brother, in case you couldn't recognize the dynamic... As far as it goes, I think you are right, it's really a matter of taste in many ways. Lance Armstrong was pretty dominant. So is Michael Phelps. There are actually a lot of athletes who have been head and shoulders above their peers in their sports. Babe Didrickson comes to mind. Or if this goes on long enough, I'm going to bring in Secretariat.
Drax
Yah, Moses is tough to beat. (What...10 years in which he was IMPOSSIBLE to beat? By anyone in the world?) Tough to beat that in terms of "dominance." I'm still sticking by Ruth, however. My initial assertion wasn't about "dominance" in general, but by the DEGREE of dominance. Moses beat his competitors by fractions of seconds. Ruth beat his by MILES. Moses did only one thing. Hurdles. Moses wasn't competing against others, he competed against himself (no one could have ANY effect on his performance...). Ruth did it all. He had a better on base percentage than any LEAD OFF hitter in the history of baseball, yet hit for power. My argument wasn't about "dominance," so much as it was about the "gap" between contemporaries. There was little that Ruth did which wasn't at least in line with his contemporaries (and has survived 70 years of challenge in great part) while doing what has been termed the "hardest thing to do in sports,", i.e. hit a round ball with a round bat just so with enough power that it goes out of the park not only better than anyone else in his time, but SO MUCH BETTER that it changed the face of the game. Let's face it. Who would you rather have at bat with the game on the line? Ruth would get on base more often, would knock in a run more often, and would score a run more often if he got on base. And, when you're down runs, would you rather hope for a single from Cobb or a home run from Ruth? (I'll take the run versus the possible run, thanks....) But, we haven't addressed Bill Russell yet. THERE was dominance in a team sport. He, too, changed the game. I'd take him over Jordan....EVERY TIME without hesitation. Jordan still has room on his fingers for more rings....Russell doesn't, but could loan Jordan his extra....since he has the room....
CosmicConservative
Who would I rather have up to bat? Depends on the circumstances. Cobb actually had more teammates batted in (RBIs - home runs) than Ruth did, he still holds that record, btw. So if there was a runner on second or third? Cobb hands down. If there was no runner, or a runner on first? Ruth. Seems pretty comparable there. Ruth's OBP is vastly inflated by his walks, just as Bonds is today. I am not questioning Ruth's greatness, and I'm the one who brought up his pitching performance, which was every bit as good as his batting. That's an element that puts him in a different category than Cobb, imho. He could pitch AND hit. I just think that you are making too big of a deal about Ruth being the first guy to really take advantage of the live ball and start specifically going after home runs. That did change the game and I give him credit for that, but as soon as other people started playing Ruth's home run game, 40 home run seasons become the norm, not the anomaly. So for three years Ruth was the only guy doing it, but from then on he was no longer "miles ahead" of everyone else. So I consider that to be more about him breaking new ground than in being a dominant athlete. I also think that it's a bit unfair to compare his "dominance" in home runs against something like Cobb's batting average. Cobb led the league in batting average for nine consecutive seasons. Ruth never even led the league in home runs for nine consecutive seasons. You and I both know that hitting .400 is more impressive a feat than hitting 40 home runs. Or even 50 home runs. Cobb batted over .400 as many times as Ruth hit more than 50 home runs. How many times did Ruth bat over .400? To me comparing Ruth's home runs to previous or even contemporary hitters is like comparing forward passes before and after the rules were changed to favor the pass in football. It's a different game. Cobb dominated the dead ball era every bit as much as Ruth dominated the live ball one. As I said, when both were on the same ballot by the baseball experts of the day, many of whom played with, coached, or reported on the two, Cobb beat Ruth in the voting. I think that alone demonstrates that it is not reasonable to say that Ruth somehow dominated his sport in a unique manner. Certainly their peers did not agree with you.
Drax
Today, I agree that hitting .400 would be more impressive than hitting 50 home runs. Not then. But, old argument. Not going to settle here, heh.
CosmicConservative
See, but I think the fact that it is an old argument directly contradicts your contention that Babe Ruth was some sort of baseball god. The arguments are good on both sides. You said yourself that Babe was a regular hitter whose hits went over the fence more than his peers, that, I think, is about right. But, I do agree that Babe transformed the game, and that puts him in the category of "game-transforming athletes" and there are darn few of those, and Ty Cobb was not one of them. I just don't think that his game transforming activity was due to superior athletic skills, I think he just tried something new. Back then players were taught NOT to swing for the fences, and frankly a player who was thought to be doing so would be benched more often than not. It took Babe to show the baseball world that a good enough hitter swinging for the fences not only brought in more runs (and more strike outs, a stat I noticed you avoided) but more importantly, brought in MORE FANS, and the money those fans brought in allowed the team to buy BETTER PLAYERS, so Babe Ruth's home runs translated directly into World Series titles, not simply due to Babe's RBIs, but more importantly, due to the massive payroll the Yankees had and their ability to put a full team together based on that payroll. That's also why Cobb never won a World Series title, for all his baseball genius and skills, he did not fill up the seats in the ballpark, and that did not allow the Tigers to bring in the top talent, especially after paying Cobb's salary. So I agree with part of your assertion, the part that Babe is in a different category than all but a very few athletes in that he transformed the game. But as a pure baseball player, comparing stat for stat, I think he is one of the top five of all time, and so is Cobb, and perhaps the two of them are #1 and #2, but who is 1 and who is 2 would depend on who is doing the judging. But I don't want to discount someone like George Sisler or Honus Wagner either.... Or even Tris Speaker or Hank Aaron. Or .... well, the list goes on and on...
Andy
Dang you CC, I almost brought up Secretariat, or Man O' War. I assumed that this was about humans, so I held myself back. Obviously this is an argument that neither brother will win. Sometimes tests of wills end up a draw. Some you win, some you lose, and some get rained out. This is spooky...Babe Zaharias came to mind also as I was trying to compare one single athlete to their peers. Spooky...
CosmicConservative
In order to get this debate over with, here's something I think we can all agree on: transformers-megan-fox-070518-12.jpg
Drax
We're just gonna agree to disagree on this one.
Drax
But, not the picture. I think we all agree on that one... Wow...
CosmicConservative
heh, but it's certainly babe something..
Andy
Okay...you wore me down...we all agree! Later!