Best athlete ever?
By CosmicConservativeSo, Drax suggested that nobody compares to Babe Ruth in comparison to their athletic contemporaries. I've actually always felt that Ruth was a bit overrated frankly, so I will take that challenge and put up a series of athletes who so dominated their sports during their careers that Ruth's "domination" pales in comparison.
I'll start with baseball.
Ty Cobb. OK, he was a jerk, probably a racist and was accused of being a violent man. But when Ty Cobb retired he held every major league offensive record he cared to own. Hits. Doubles. Triples. RBIs. Stolen Bases. Batting Average. On Base Percentage. Just about the only records he didn't own were the home run and walks, which, coincidentally, are the two that Ruth and Bonds are so famous for. Cobb hated to walk, he felt it was an insult. Ty Cobb got fed up with the Ruth Legend and in one series told a reporter that he was going to "swing for the fences." He hit five home runs in the next two days, hit safely in nine straight at bats and set a new AL record for home runs and RBIs in a series. He just didn't like strolling around the bases, he wanted to terrorize them.
Edwin Moses in track and field. This guy won every meet he ran in for over a decade. He set the world record in the 400 meter hurdles four consecutive times (meaning he beat his OWN record three times consecutively). No other runner has dominated a track and field sport for more than a few years. He did it for over a decade.
Jack Nicklaus/Tiger Woods. These guys were so dominant in their sport that they redefined the sport entirely. Until Tiger tops Jack's 18 majors, I'm giving the edge to Jack in this. He not only won 18 majors, he came in second more than he won.
Roger Federer. He has won one out of every three tennis majors he has entered. He has held the number one ranking for more consecutive weeks than any other tennis player. He has won 11 tennis Grand Slam titles. He is 26 years old. He shows no signs of slowing down.
Martina Navratilova. She won 18 Grand Slam singles titles, 31 doubles titles and 10 mixed doubles titles. Nobody is even in the same universe with her.
Then there was this guy named Wayne Gretzky who was so good that his scoring record was more than twice the second place scoring record when he retired.
I could go on. Babe Ruth was a phenomenon. Most of my respect for Babe Ruth comes from the fact that he was an all-star and World Series record holder as a PITCHER before he became a slugger. That's really amazing. But as amazing as he was, I wouldn't even call him the best baseball player ever. Ty Cobb wins that title hands down. And in sports overall? Who is the most dominant figure in my lifetime in their sport? Hard to top Michael Jordan. All time? Hmm.. names like Wilt Chamberlain or Mark Spitz come to mind...
Comments (27)