Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Aaron's record about to fall

By CosmicConservative
Barry Bonds is just about to make history... maybe even by the time I post this.
ESPN - Bonds hits No. 754 in first inning against Marlins - MLB SAN FRANCISCO -- Barry Bonds hit his 754th career home run Friday night, moving within one of tying Hank Aaron's record. Bonds sent a 2-1 pitch from Rick Vanden Hurk over the wall in left-center in the first inning against the Florida Marlins, giving the Giants a 2-1 lead on his 20th homer of the season. The 43-year-old Bonds connected off his 444th pitcher -- the first hailing from the Netherlands. He has homered off pitchers from 17 different countries, including the United States.
I remember when I was a kid and my big brother told me that Hank Aaron was going to break Babe Ruth's home run record. I thought he was nuts. But Hammerin' Hank just kept hammerin' 'em, year after year, like clockwork. And then he did it. Then I remember that same brother saying how unlikely it was that anyone else would break Hank's record. That was when 45 home runs in a year was a lot. I have mixed feelings about Barry Bonds and the record. First of all, I just don't care much for Barry Bonds. Forget all the steroid allegations, they guy is just plain rude and arrogant. Hank was unfailingly polite and humble. I admit that I sort of like polite and humble when compared to rude and arrogant. Secondly, I don't think Barry is likely to hold the record for the 30+ years that Hank did. In fact I'd guess he'll hold it for less than a decade. So I can't work up a lot of indignation about his being the home run king. It won't last long.

Comments (9)

Drax
At the time, I couldn't conceive of anyone being as good for as long as Hank was. He still has (I think) the record for most extra base hits, RBI's, and total bases. If you took all his home runs away, he'd STILL have 3000 hits (he's 3rd all time). I'm convinced that when the Grand Jury finally concludes (in September, I think) that Bonds will be indicted. There is NO WAY he didn't know that he was taking performance enhancing drugs and NOT "flax seed oil" as he testified. (There's something about income tax evasion as well, I think.) Further, I think that Henry Aaron will be considered the "real" home run king for the rest of time (whether anyone else breaks Bonds' record or not) much like Ruth was considered to be the single season record holder even when his record was broken by Maris (but in more games).
CosmicConservative
"Rest of time?" What happens when A-Rod breaks Bonds' record? He's pretty good too...
Drax
If Rodriguez breaks Bonds' record (or Pujos or any of the new crop of monsters out there) their achievements will be under the haze of the "steroid era." I mean, have you SEEN what A-Rod looked like when he came up? He and Sosa...two peas in a pod...
CosmicConservative
Well, waitaminute... Didn't those steroid laced sluggers hit home runs off of steroid laced pitchers like Roger Clemens? Doesn't that even it out?
Drax
Heh. The "steriod era" will color how we look at most records. However, there aren't many career pitching records likely to fall. 511 wins? Safe until they change the pitching rotations to 4 days (or less). 5714 Strikeouts? I think that's safe for many, many, many decades (no one on the horizon is even CLOSE...(Clemens is nearly 1700 (6 seasons of 300 or so....) away)
CosmicConservative
There is a growing feeling that even reaching 300 wins may become a thing of the past. There are only a few with a shot currently pitching, and it's getting harder all the time to win even 20 games in a season. It's really not fair to compare records pre-1930 and post-1930 (or so).
Drax
I agree that the different eras shouldn't be compared too much. They call this era the "long ball era," for many, many reasons beyond the steroid issue (new bats, new batting techniques, strength conditioning, pitchers not throwing inside (and being thrown out for doing so too often unless you're Clemens, Martinez, or Johnson...) favorable parks, etc. I think that the most appropriate comparisons are "like to like." How much better of a home run hitter is Bonds to his contemporaries? How does that compare to others from other eras? When this comparison is done, I don't think that ANYONE in ANY sport compares to Ruth.
Andy
I'm not a big baseball expert, but I think Aaron will always be the home run king if for no other reason than that he played most of his career batting against the "tall mound" pitchers. And those guys would rather hit you than give you anything to jerk out. Drax gives other good reasons. I'm not a great baseball historian, but I know Aaron didn't play several games a year at Coors Field, or Reliant Park either. My vote goes to "Homering" Hank.
CosmicConservative
I commented on the "Coors Field mystique" in the other thread, there is no longer any statistically significant advantage to hitting at Coors field, as you can check by looking at ballpark hitting stats. It is far more likely that in fifty years Babe Ruth will be considered the better home run hitter than Hank Aaron because he was the first to do it well, and by then Aaron will be fifth or sixth on the list and people simply won't remember him. When Aaron was playing people made excuses for his numbers usually citing the lower quality of pitchers Hank faced compared to Ruth because of the league expansions since Ruth played. Of course they also brought up the longer season as well, so there is always a way to make some sort of excuse to account for an athlete who is setting new records. Personally I think hitting a home run is just as hard today as it was when Hank did it or Ruth did it. Or so close to just as hard to be statistically insignificant. I would say that any advantage today's hitters have in equipment or physical training is offset by the more modern theory to walk dangerous hitters instead of facing them. So I tend not to get into the apples vs. oranges comparisons. If Barry Bonds sets the record, he's the king. Maybe he did it through artificial drug use, but I do think he faced a lot of pitchers whose abilities were similarly inflated by the same drugs.