Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Court dismisses suit challenging domestic spying

By CosmicConservative
OK, first let me point out the absolute bald-faced lie in this headline. It is not agreed by all sides that the NSA program being challenged here is "domestic" spying, but CNN believes that it is, and since they believe that it is, they report it as fact. In the headline. This is the worst sort of press bias imaginable. The reason there is dispute about the "domestic" part of this is that the program in question monitors calls originating from OUTSIDE the country to phones within the country. But the Left has already decided that they have won this debate, and CNN reports it as if that debate is over.
Court dismisses suit challenging domestic spying - CNN.com WASHINGTON (CNN) -- A federal appeals court Friday ordered the dismissal of an ACLU lawsuit challenging President Bush's domestic surveillance program.
Luckily there are still some judges with some sense of legal guidelines in this country. Of course this lawsuit does not settle the constitutional questions that the Left insists on bringing up on this issue, but perhaps the appeal will take that angle. We'll see. For now the program continues to be legal.

Comments (9)

Ed
Some judges with some sense of legal guidelines in this country? The ACLU can take their case to the Supreme Court? To be shot down by the very same people that rule against Free Speech? It really is a shame that it took 200 years for all peoples to get rights in this country (note how they took anti-slavery out of Thomas Jefferson's draft). This issue and others like it eat away at the very core of what America _should_ stand for. But hey, I bet people would rather hear about Paris Hilton than keep "our" government in check. But laws and checks and balances, that's a bunch of hogwash right. We haven't been attacked since 9/11 so it must all be worth it right? Well I'd rather _die_ in a terrorist attack than watch the very core of America rot away. I could die in a car wreck, some drunk could kill me anywhere, on an airplane, from a meteor falling from the sky; yet I still go out. I am more concerned with drunk drivers than of terrorists; as everyone should be. Make alcohol illegal. If death from terrorists is your justification; make all lethal things illegal. Would the NSA be able to stop some disgruntled person from carrying out a recent London styled attack? No. Any disgruntled John Q could fill their car with gas and nails and there is nothing that would be able to stop them. People run around and kill people with guns, see what happened in Las Vegas last night.. see the crime statistics involving guns. But that's different right. We have a right to carry firearms; just not a right to Freedom of Speech and or expect the Constitution to be upheld by. I mean that was written so long ago, and we are dealing with a completely different world than the Founding Fathers; so how can you expect government to really act by those out-dated ideals. Well I do; because those ideals is what makes people proud to be an American in the first place. No one keeps this government in check, and how can they when they just say "oh no, sorry, that's a state secret"; and the fact that people want to just ignore this and bury their heads in the sand and blindly support their political party instead of the actual issues will be the very downfall into something distinctively not American. If only the next president would repeal all of Bush's damage to this great country.
CosmicConservative
Ed: I'm not sure what you are railing against, except for your last sentence where you talk about all of "Bush's damage" to this "great country." Would you please list some of "Bush's" damage, and explain how he was able to do it all by himself? Last I checked the Iraq War was approved (more like demanded) by Congress, the NSA data mining (it is not "wiretapping" and every reporter who uses that word just reaveals how incredibly ignorant they are about what the NSA is really doing) has been specifically approved by Congress, and has been so far upheld by the courts, the Gitmo detention has also been approved by Congress and held up by the courts, etc. etc. etc. The fact that you call it "Bush's damage" simply reveals that you have no real understanding of what is happening, how it is happening or why it is happening, you just want to blame someone and Bush is an easy target. It's sad, really, how people use Bush as a scapegoat for everything they don't like that is happening, no matter how many Republicans, Democrats and Federal judges agreed with it when it mattered.
Drax
Ed....There are a lot of ramblings here, so, I'll just take it one by one... "Some judges with some sense of legal guidelines in this country?" As usual, when the lefties get the judges on their side, it's a victory for freedom. When the judges dsagree with them, it's one step closer to facism. "The ACLU can take their case to the Supreme Court? To be shot down by the very same people that rule against Free Speech?" Um...I seem to have missed that ruling. Should I look it up so that I can use it against people like you and shut people like you up? Or the protesters against the war? Or Al Gore even? Again. I seem to have missed where the Justices have taken away our right to Freedom of Speech. "This issue and others like it eat away at the very core of what America _should_ stand for." That's what the vote is for. You get to vote for people who think like you. You don't get to MAKE everyone think like you; you just get to vote for those who DO. "But hey, I bet people would rather hear about Paris Hilton than keep “our” government in check." This is true. Hell, everyone gets something right if they write enough stuff. "But laws and checks and balances, that’s a bunch of hogwash right." Um, laws are PART of the "checks and balances..." not the "checks and balances" in themselves.... You see, the part of the "checks and balances" you seem to be missing is the part where JUDGES get to look at the LAWS and decide whether they're in accordance with the constitution...whether Presidential action flies outside those boundaries. YOu know, the SUBJECT of what you're ranting about? "We haven’t been attacked since 9/11 so it must all be worth it right?" I'm still alive. My family is still alive. Some friends have had to go overseas to see to that. Other countrymen have had to do some dirty stuff to see to that. But, since I'm still alive and YOU'RE still able to rant freely about the state of things ANYWHERE YOU LIKE without fear of being imprisoned or killed, yah....pretty much. "Well I’d rather _die_ in a terrorist attack than watch the very core of America rot away." Thankfully, you neither get to decide for ME what the "core of America" IS, nor whether I'd die to defend YOUR definition of that America. From a brief review of your writings, I would suspect that our definitions of what constitutes the "core of America" and what is worthy of dying for are vastly divergent. "I could die in a car wreck, some drunk could kill me anywhere, on an airplane, from a meteor falling from the sky; yet I still go out." What this has to do with anything escapes me. Are you of the impression that organized attacks against the U.S., its interests, and its people is somehow equatable to getting hit by a drunk driver? If so, that would explain much about your ramblings. "I am more concerned with drunk drivers than of terrorists; as everyone should be." Umm. No? We have laws against those idiots. We do what we can WITHOUT infringing upon the rights of non-idiots to drive. Terrorists have as their aim the destruction of the U.S. Drunk drivers generally have as their aim to get home. You compare the two and give the comparison meaning. Huh. "Make alcohol illegal." It is the OVERDRINKING of alcohol while DRIVING that is of import. That is ALREADY illegal. "If death from terrorists is your justification; make all lethal things illegal." All intentional and unjustified killing is already illegal. You are really going a long way around the horn to attempt to make a point. I think you got lost somewhere along the way. "Would the NSA be able to stop some disgruntled person from carrying out a recent London styled attack? No. Any disgruntled John Q could fill their car with gas and nails and there is nothing that would be able to stop them." So we should just stop trying to keep them from doing so? Remember, you can VOTE people into office who think like you do, then we can stop attempting to defend ourselves as you would like. Oh, wait. We already did that. "People run around and kill people with guns, see what happened in Las Vegas last night.. see the crime statistics involving guns. But that’s different right." Um. Yah? Again, if you missed the news, killing people is illegal. We try to stop it when we can. If we can't stop it, we try to prosecute those who do it so that they can't do it again. If those people took up arms, gathered together in Wyoming, published that they are going to attempt to destroy the U.S. by force and begin killing people and blowing up things in order to effect their goals, then, your comparison might have some weight. But, since that isn't the case, I suppose you can park this "logic train" alongside of your others in a train station of bad thinking. "We have a right to carry firearms; just not a right to Freedom of Speech and or expect the Constitution to be upheld by." Until someone can exercise that right to carry firearms (and, it's "own," not "carry") and use it to kill idiots who spout nonsense on blogs without any reprisal, I would suspect that our right to "Freedom of Speech" is pretty well intact. Has someone come to your house lately telling you to shut up while waving a firearm? "I mean that was written so long ago, and we are dealing with a completely different world than the Founding Fathers; so how can you expect government to really act by those out-dated ideals." This is almost funny. This is almost EXACTLY the argument that the leftists use for many of the Supremes' rulings over the past decades, i.e., that the Constitution is a "living, breathing document" which must adapt to the times. Yet, when such thinking is used to justify a decision with which they disagree (and, I'm not saying that this one is...it ISN'T...read the dang decision) they rail against the very "living Constitution" that THEY CREATED. It's just sad. "Well I do; because those ideals is what makes people proud to be an American in the first place." I'm fairly certain that we disagree as to what it is to "be an American," and just what it is that I should be "proud" about. "No one keeps this government in check, and how can they when they just say “oh no, sorry, that’s a state secret”;" Just because the "checks and balances" didn't work out the way you want doesn't mean that there aren't "checks and balances." I'm pretty sure that Bush would disagree with your assessment of their being no "checks and balances," after he was upbraided by the Supremes recently. Guess you forgot that. Ah, nevermind. THAT decision went YOUR WAY; you didn't forget it; you were simply being intellectually dishonest. "and the fact that people want to just ignore this and bury their heads in the sand and blindly support their political party instead of the actual issues will be the very downfall into something distinctively not American." Yes. This is an ignored subject. It wasn't on the front pages of most major newspapers or in the video news. No one is writing about it. I'm not paying attention to it even now. "If only the next president would repeal all of Bush’s damage to this great country." Don't worry. If you have your way and vote people into office who agree with you, we won't have this problem for long. We will pull out of Iraq, ignore Iran and Afghanistan. We will stop trying to use intelligence to find out and stop terrorist plots, and, ultimately, just roll over and die.
gjh
The suit was dismissed because the Judge ruled the ACLU did not have standing. The Judge did in the rest of the ruling state the ACLU was right. It was dismissed on a technicality
CosmicConservative
gjh: Did you read this part of my post?
Of course this lawsuit does not settle the constitutional questions that the Left insists on bringing up on this issue, but perhaps the appeal will take that angle. We’ll see. For now the program continues to be legal.
Drax
gjh: The "technicality" is a fundament of law, i.e., in order to bring suit, you must be the injured party. This lack of "standing" is why the ACLU and lawyers properly had their suit dismissed.
gjh
They will appeal on the basis of the general good.
Drax
They will appeal, or more precisely, apply for Writs. I tend to doubt that that Writ will be granted, but wouldn't be surprised if it were.
CosmicConservative
gjh: I am assuming that the attorneys involved and the judge or judges involved, know the law better than you or I do. We'll see what they do, OK? For now the challenge has been rebuffed, for a third time, I think. Whether it is a technicality or not is immaterial, if the SCOTUS wants to make law on a case like this, they'll take the appeal and rule any way they want to based on any "technicality" or "constitutional" issue they desire to. The question is, how will they appeal be submitted (or "writ" or whatever) what the appellate court will rule, and how badly the SCOTUS wants to make law in this case. That's pretty much all that matters, and is no doubt why very knowledgeable attorneys filed the lawsuit in the first place. Not because they expected a lower level court to rule one way or the other, but to get past the first rung of the ladder which eventually leads to the SCOTUS.