Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Quantum Mechanics and dice...

By CosmicConservative
So.. one of my weekly websites I visit is called "DM of the Rings" and it is a parody of the movies (and the book, but mostly the movies) from Peter Jackson, presented as if it were the result of a standard (well, mostly standard) D&D campaign. It's really quite funny. For a geek, I guess. Anyway, today's strip relates how one player is getting upset because another player "borrowed" their 20-sided dice and is "using up" all their critical hits (a roll of "20" on the die). So of course I had to drag quantum mechanics into it. But I'm more than half serious. I have wondered about dice rolling ever since I encountered the eerie phenomenon in quantum mechanics of observation of an event influencing the event itself. There are experiments going on right now that purport to create quantum-mechanical states in a real-world system. Quantum computing more or less depends on this. What I wonder is if dice rolling has been an example of quantum mechanical state transition that has existed since mankind first began to play games. And if so, whether the "observation affects the outcome" is manifested in dice rolling. Which is a fancy way of saying that dice are not purely random after all. They are only random when you set up an experiment to observe their randomness. Otherwise they are quantum-mechanical in nature and will resolve to a final state based not only on their own internal mechanics, but also based on the external world's awareness of them. Which would explain why I suck so much at dice games....

Comments (1)

Twenty Sided » What are the odds?
[...] More analysis here. [...]