Game Review: "Oblivion: Elder Scrolls IV"
By CosmicConservativeOK, I don't have time for a full review, I'll try to do one tonight. I got this game for Father's day after reading about how it had revolutionized gameplay and was to the modern gaming fan what "Wizardry" was to the gamers of a generation (or two) ago.
I am underwhelmed by the gameplay.
I love the graphics, they are stunning, although even my somewhat powerful system cannot really run it on full ultra-high quality mode on my 22" monitor. So I have to shrink it down a bit, but it still is incredible. It gives a credible illusion of individual leaves and grass stalks swaying in the wind, which is quite visually stunning.
But the game play is very similar to all role-playing games. Make a character, pick a class, find stuff, sell stuff, buy stuff, go do things people ask you to do...
I made a custom class instead of picking one of the standard ones. I liked that I could do that.
I don't like the combination mouse and keyboard approach to movement. I don't like that moving your character while walking or running is completely different than when riding a horse. (Although I love that you can ride a horse). I don't like the chaotic nature of melee combat, although I suppose that is a fair representation of real melee. For example, in Oblivion when engaged in melee with friends and foes, it is not uncommon for me to hit a friend accidentally. You are clicking the mouse in a finger-aching frenzy and suddenly an ally rushes across in front of you and the click you already clicked ends up with the sword or spell whacking your buddy, who says something like "Hey! I'm on your side" or some such.
I don't like that the guards and storekeepers are omniscient. If you try to pick a pocket or steal something, if you get caught (and at my level you are certain to get caught) every guard and storekeeper in the ENTIRE FRIGGIN WORLD knows you are guilty immediately. If you somehow manage to steal something, shopkeepers will not buy it because it is somehow tainted as "stolen" for all to see. You have to sell stolen goods to fences from the thieves guild (or so far that's all I can do). That is just plain stupid.
The plot moves you more than you move the plot. I was pretty much forced (okay, coerced might be a better word) to go to the plane of Oblivion to try to shut down a gate when I was level 2, and as such I was very ill-equipped to handle some of the very powerful evil ones I encountered. Also the whole "plane of oblivion" was so reminiscent of the "Doom" and "Quake" demon-infested worlds, complete with mutilated human corpses everywhere you look. I don't mind gore so much, but this whole "demons mutilating, decapitating, eating and bathing in the blood of innocents" thing is so "been there, done that" for me. I'd rather do some good old dungeon crawling, frankly.
More later.
Comments (2)