Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Bush in holy gaffe: World: News: News24

By CosmicConservative
Bush in holy gaffe: World: News: News24 Vatican City - US President George W Bush drew gasps at the Vatican on Saturday by referring to Pope Benedict XVI as "sir" instead of the expected "His Holiness", pool reporters said.
Good for Bush. Why should he call the Pope "Your Holiness" if he isn't a Catholic? I wouldn't.

Comments (6)

Drax
Yep. Me either. Ain't in no way "holy" to me, that's for sure.
CosmicConservative
I don't understand why anyone would expect a non-Catholic to call the Pope "Your Holiness." Similarly I would not call the Queen of England "Your Highness" or anything like that. And if people gasped I'd say "grow up, this is YOUR tradition, not mine. We fought a WAR to get away from this nonsense. We won."
gjh
This may explain why we are disliked more intensely every day by the rest of the world. Common courtesy goes a long, long way.
CosmicConservative
GJH: Pretending you subscribe to a worldview that you don't subscribe to goes beyond common courtesy and into the realm of dishonesty, or disingenuousness at best. I see no reason to cater to people's delusions of grandeur, and that includes referring to any religious leader as "your Holiness" or any king as "your Highness." Those are relics of exactly the sort of medieval nonsense this country was founded to get away from. I see nothing "courteous" about pretending that someone is a "highness" or is "holy" just to assuage their feelings of grandeur. You can call that rudeness or you can call it plain talk. I prefer plain talk. If "sir" is good enough for the President, it's good enough for the Pope. Period. Common courtesy is "yes sir" and "yes ma'am", not bowing and scraping before some inbred relic of a "royal family" or before some self-proclaimed "spokesman for God." Bush was exercising EXACTLY the common courtesy you chide him for not showing. What you are demanding is UNCOMMON courtesy. As I said, I wouldn't do it. You want to be called "your holiness" talk to your flock, a member of which I am not and refuse to pretend to be just so you can feel good about yourself.
Drax
Common courtsey is not sticking a microphone in the Pope's face, demanding answers about all the charges of child molestation amongst members of his clergy. Oh, wait. Nevermind. He doesn't answer questions, does he? It's really a matter of perspective, I suppose. I think that using the honorific serves to validate the person's belief that they are, indeed, that which they are called. Even the President, instead of being called "sir" by anyone, is called "Mr. President," further distancing him from those he is supposedly serving, rather than ruling over. "Sir" is about as far as I'd go, I think. However, until I am graced with an audience with the Queen (or the Pope) and am faced with the decision, I really can't say what I'd call them. Maybe I'd use the honorific then talk bad about them behind their back?
CosmicConservative
I'm 99% certain I'd use "sir" and if reporters had a complaint about it I'd tell them to try to find an actual story about something that matters somewhere in the world instead of running a gilded gossip rag.