Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Movie Review: Pirates of the Caribbean - At Wit's End

By Dadman
...or at least that how I felt at the conclusion of this marathon and, at times, difficult to endure film. And that seemed to be the general consensus of all those who attended the movie with me: wife, kids, father, sister, niece, boyfriends, fiances, etc. Ten of us left the theater with numb butts and a clear case of cinematic disappointment. If only one of us knew what the heck was going on. If only one of us could decipher all the competing motivations. If only one of us could understand a word Barbosa, Davy Jones or Calypso was saying it might have been a different story. But we couldn't so it turned out to be just a very long, loud story with great special effects... I hate to dump on this film. I really do. We were all so excited to see this movie. My 22 year old daughter was especially excited, but was the first to say as the credits rolled... 'that's so disappointing...' We didn't expect it to be. We loved the first two Pirates installments and expected to love this one too. It was not to be... Where did it go wrong? That's an easy question to answer. This project should have been identified as a mess when it was just a script. The storyline is all over the place. The main characters are all being pulled in different directions, moved by different, competing motivations, to such an extent it is virtually impossible to go with them too deep or too far. As a result the audience just doesn't enjoy the company and antics of these characters as much as we have in the past. It was confusing and not very much fun. It's a surprisingly talky film as well... I'm surprised a seasoned studio like Disney and a veteran director like Verbinski didn't catch the glaring deficiencies of the third Pirate's script long before principal shootiing began. On the upside, the film looks great and the characters are cleverly designed and performed. Clearly huge sums of cash were spent on the special effects and action sequences. The final cannon battle sequence is quite impressive... and the monkey was funny...

Comments (3)

ams1491625
It's the wrath of the sequel. It almost always hits. Star Wars managed to hold out until the modern trio came out (though I am loath to consider them part of the series).
siblog
I completely agree with you, there was way too much going on in the movie. I also cannot stand Keira Knightley, she is a horrible actress and I can't even handle her wannabe William Wallace speeches! bleh I have not been impressed with any of the blockbuster sequels so far this summer.
CosmicConservative
Hmm... no doubt the Cosmic daughter is going to read this and think it was my review... PLEASE READ THE BYLINE FOLKS! Still, I agree. We saw it on Saturday and I thought it was "a mess." I didn't like Pirates II nearly as much as I did the first Pirates and I think this movie also suffered a surfeit of Johnny Depp (both literally and metaphorically). I also suffer from inability to understand people when they try to speak with bizarre accents and there is a lot of other chatter going on. I would guess I missed about a quarter of the dialog of the movie between the mumbling of the actors and the ever-present musical score or background noise. Overall though I didn't hate the movie. It had its moments, although there were fewer of them than I would have liked. I find Keira Knightley to be pleasant to look at, and her accent is charming, but I have not yet thought that she has done a credible acting job in any of the movies. And now she's a swordfighter able to hold her own against Davy Jones' salty minions? I mean, really. I did not like the ending. I thought it was contrived and I suspect that most movie-goers also found it to be unsettling and unfulfilling. The Cosmic wife came away from the movie thinking that Barbosa was much the better pirate than Jack Sparrow anyway. My laugh-out-loud moment in the movie came when Sparrow's dad (I assume that was his dad) brought forth the "Pirate Codex" and slapped it down on the table. The whole concept of a "pirate's code" is so laughable that only Hollywood could come up with such a thing, but for it to be written down in some weighty tome and be followed as if it were law, by a group of cutthroats who live by ignoring law altogether, that is a funny thing. Not intentionally funny, but funny. But I did not begrudge the matinee fees for the movie. I enjoyed the special effects anyway.