Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Darn, the Clinton's house might be safe after all...

By CosmicConservative
Aw man, just when I was getting excited about Global Warming....
.: U.S. Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works :: Minority Page :. Following the U.S. Senate's vote today on a global warming measure (see today's AP article: Senate Defeats Climate Change Measure,) it is an opportune time to examine the recent and quite remarkable momentum shift taking place in climate science. Many former believers in catastrophic man-made global warming have recently reversed themselves and are now climate skeptics. The names included below are just a sampling of the prominent scientists who have spoken out recently to oppose former Vice President Al Gore, the United Nations, and the media driven “consensus” on man-made global warming. The list below is just the tip of the iceberg. A more detailed and comprehensive sampling of scientists who have only recently spoken out against climate hysteria will be forthcoming in a soon to be released U.S. Senate report. Please stay tuned to this website, as this new government report is set to redefine the current climate debate.

Comments (4)

pace
Meanwhile, NewScientist just published this article: http://environment.newscientist.com/channel/earth/dn11462
CosmicConservative
Pace: I am just as skeptical of this "authoritarian" presentation of Global Warming as "proven fact" as I always have been. The idea that the temperature variations of the last 1,000 years are understood well enough to say, with certainty, that the last decade of the 20th century was definitively the warmest simply flies in the face of historical records of the Vikings in Greenland, and other historical records of heat waves in England and across the continent of Europe. These are historical facts and can't simply be brushed aside in the manner that this article attempts to do so. Similarly the dismissal of the cooling of the atmosphere after WWII with the, again, authoritarian statement that it was due to particulate matter in the atmosphere is simply disingenuous and would cause any true scientist to say "well, that's the theory, but of course we can't PROVE it." This article is presented as fact, but much of what I read is, in my opinion, dogma presented as fact. Indeed, it is also my opinion that this sort of condescending, disingenuous misrepresentation of science is precisely why there is now such a significant backlash among scientists on the subject of global warming. This sort of dogmatic, condescending, one-sided argument makes a real scientist extremely uncomfortable.
ams1491625
Well, I agree somewhat about the dogma. However, I don't want to base our side of the argument on how many people convert to or away from the "consensus". "Our consensus is bigger than your consensus" isn't a scientific argument at all. I like the way junkscience.com argued against (catastrophic) global warming, and the green's position that mankind has to be curtailed to avert doom. They mention that the waveband that CO2 absorbs is already absorbed to a great degree by water vapor, which is normally thousands of times more concentrated in the atmosphere - essentially a variation in the air humidity is going to have a tremendous effect on the greenhouse properties of a column of air - more so than any concievable CO2 increase. (I actually want to do the math sometime and doublecheck them on this. If it's true, you can pretty much throw CO2 in the garbage bin as the primary driver of climate change). In any case, this is a scientific argument, it has nothing to do with how many people believe what and are in what camp.
pace
There are some seemingly unwitting contradictions in the NewScientist article. For example, their noting that historical data beyond 150 years or whatever is notoriously inaccurate and therefore cannot be used to reliably discredit global warming when it indicates that the Earth has experienced warmer periods that it is currently. Yet at other times they point to historical trends when it reinforces the catastrophic human-induced climate change position. And if in fact we cannot trust any data beyond that collected last century, then relying on recent trends to model long-term climate change would seem to be a fundamentally flawed proposition given the age of the planet. I was a little disappointed that NewScientist would adopt such a dogmatic position, but truth be told I haven't read the magazine since I was a teen so this may be consistent with how they operate.