Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Jon Voight sends mixed messages

By CosmicConservative
Interesting story and interview:
Features : Radar Online Few actors can deliver a menacing glare as convincingly as Jon Voight. And, as Radar learned, he strikes a pretty imposing figure off screen as well. The Oscar-winning star of Deliverance and Midnight Cowboy has appeared in over 70 films, but his most recent role, as a fundamentalist Mormon leader in September Dawn (in theaters this summer), seems to have held particular resonance for the actor. Based on the Mountain Meadows Massacre of September 11, 1857, in which Mormons mercilessly slaughtered 137 settlers traveling peacefully across Utah, the film, according to Voight, is rife with parallels to 9/11 and the current state of religious extremism.
I don't know quite what to make of this. When I first heard of Voight's role in this movie, I immediately assumed that it was a typical Hollywood hit job on Mit Romney. Why else would a movie about Mormon's attacking "peaceful" settlers be made in the current election cycle where a prominent Mormon is one of the Republicans leading the pack for the nomination? And I still suspect that's a big part of why this movie was made. But in reading the interview I came away with the feeling that Jon Voight is no Hollywood liberal. He seems to "get" a lot of the issues in the War on Terror. So now I'm all confused.

Comments (2)

Dadman
This film is clearly intended to be an editorial against religious 'extremism' drawing parallels between what happened at Mountain Meadow in 1857 and what happened on 9/11. The fact that both incidents occurred on 9/11 is a coincidence just too juicy for Hollywood to pass up on. And I think Jon Voight is quite alright taking on religious extremism in all it's forms. The problem, of course, is that religious extremism was not the primary motivator for what happened to the Baker-Fancher party at Mountain Meadow. The incident was more a function of paranoia, fear and the misguided desire for revenge. Consider the context. The Mormons had been violently driven from their homes in Ohio, Missouri and Illinois before finding some peace and security in the remote Utah territory. Many Mormons had been murdered (including their leader), their property stolen, their temple burned. At the time of the Mountain Meadow Massacre, President Buchanan had literally mobilized most of the U.S. Army to put down the so-called 'Mormon rebellion' (which, of course, was an incendiary exaggeration of what was going on in the Utah territory at the time). Complicating the situation was the fact the Mormon apostle, Parley P. Pratt, had been murdered in Arkansas (the state of origin of the Baker-Fancher party attacked by the Mormons and Piutes at Mountain Meadow) just a few months before the massacre and rumours were swirling that some of those in the Baker-Fancher party were involved in his death. Of course, none of these extenuating circumstances mitigates the guilt of those Mormons and Indians involved in the incident or diminish it's horror, but they certainly do make the story more than just a case of wild-eyed religious extremists gleefully doing God's bidding. It's also a story of a persecuted, even paranoid, people who perceived history repeating itself with Buchanan's army preparing to take their homes and property by force and unfriendly interlopers invading their land. Unfortunately, the movie will not likely capture the nuance and context of the times. And that may be bad news for Romney, who I personally like as a candidate.
Dadman
Some follow-on comments... Jon Voight seems oblivious to the fact that the LDS church has acknowledged its complicity in the Mountain Meadow massacre incident, has apologized and now maintains a monument in southern Utah honoring those who died. John D. Lee, the man Voight plays in this film, was tried and executed for his involvement. They do, as I understand it, still dispute that Brigham Young gave the order to commit mass murder. Movies like September Dawn are dangerous in my view because they give us caricatures and simplifications and call it truth. In this case the producers will portray an incident that occured 150 years ago, within a complex historical context, and no doubt leave the impression with many people that modern day Mormons are blood-thirsty, religious zealots...or at least so inclined under the right conditions. Given that animosity toward Mormons is already quite high in some quarters, this film will just fuel the fires. I can't wait...