Pajamas Media: The Gospel of John & Yoko: The Origins of Mad Morality Have you ever been asked whom you liked better, John or Paul? And have you ever answered “John†on a vague assumption that otherwise people might have less respect for your other views? Wonder why? The question was never about music - it was about your moral philosophy. To answer it correctly - assuming you wanted to fit into the crowd - you had to consider the moral philosophy of the crowd, thus voluntarily submitting your mind to thought policing. In most cases, answering “Paul†constituted a thought crime.I've been asked that before. And I've always said "Paul". Because I do like Paul better. Not to say that I didn't like John too, and George and Ringo as well. In fact in some ways I really like Ringo best of all. Of all of them Ringo seems to be the one I'd have liked to go over to his house and hang out. But the truth is that when I was asked this, I usually knew that "John" was the "right" answer for all the "right" reasons. But I always said "Paul" anyway, in part just to irritate the holier-than-thou type that asked that sort of question. Paul was definitely prone to a sort of pop sentimentality that comes through loud and clear in songs like "Your Mother Should Know" or "In My Life." But I liked that sentimentality. I still do. In general the songs I like best by the Beatles are Paul songs. For example, although "Strawberry Fields" and "Penny Lane" are both brilliant rock songs, to me the difference between them is that "Penny Lane" makes me smile while "Strawberry Fields" makes me think. And while there are definitely times I like to think, I always like to smile. Of course, as I got older (than about 14, for example) I started hearing the message in John's songs and started realizing that they sounded good, but they wouldn't work. The song "Give Peace A Chance" is probably the most glaring example. This is a song that I would hear sung at every Vietnam protest march in the 70s, and it still goes on today. And the theory of the song seems to be that you should always "Give Peace A Chance" instead of going to war. But the reality is that in virtually all cases, peace was given more than a chance before war began. And it seemed silly to talk about giving peace a chance when our enemies were quite happy to keep on shooting at us. I eventually realized that these philosophical platitudes have no purpose other than to make the folks singing or chanting them feel good. It's not that peace isn't given a chance in most cases, it's that peace has been given a chance and failed, and STILL the mindless robots are chanting it as if nobody ever tried peace in the first place. So, between Paul and John, put me down as a Paul fan. But I'd really rather have a beer with Ringo I think.
I always liked Paul
By CosmicConservative(Hat tip to the Insta-Pundit)
Comments (0)
No comments on this post.