Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Divine morality

By CosmicConservative
So, I get into discussions with religious folks all the time. One of the most frequent issues that comes up in these discussions is my refusal to "worship" God and put His desires foremost in my own life. Assuming "He" exists, of course, which I do not concede. But if "He" did, I would still argue that the demand that his creations worship him is beneath any God worthy of worship in the first place. The answer I always get is "You are putting yourself above God, how dare you challenge his will, he CREATED you, so he is entitled to your worship, and you are obligated to give it." So here's a thought experiment. Let's say that human beings continue to advance in knowledge and power. Let's say that human beings learn to manipulate DNA directly. Let's say that human beings learn how to design creatures and produce them tailored for special purposes. Like, say, engineering gills onto a human being so they can breathe underwater. Now let's say that human beings create, from scratch, using nothing but a molecular manipulator to create DNA strands, an entirely new species. Let's say that species is intelligent and self aware. Does this argument now mean that human beings have the right to demand that these new creatures worship them? And that the new creatures have an obligation to do so? I have two comments. 1. No. 2. Human beings would not demand such worship, instead they would welcome the new creatures as equals. (Well, some would, some would not at first, but over time it would happen). So, from this analysis I would say that human beings would be more worthy of my worship than a God who demands worship. And human beings are obviously not worthy of worship. So a God who demands worship is even less worthy of worship than human beings that we know are not worthy of worship. QED

Comments (3)

pace
I find the notion of 'God', as I think most people would define it, to be one of the most conceited ideas to have so persistently encumbered modern Humans. I ponder these types of philosophical questions with some regularity - usually while trying to get to sleep at night. It is the paradoxes that invariably arise when considering the implications of an omnipotent supernatural entity, that make the entire thing (divinity) wholly irrational and implausible to me. In the unlikely event that I were ever to conclude the existence of some type of creator, it would certainly not be consistent with the God of men described in the Bible (nor presumably in the Quran). Exactly for the type of reason demonstrated by your thought experiment: No such perfect, loving being would need nor even desire our worship in the manners that we are instructed.
CosmicConservative
I don't believe that all religions, or all believers, follow the notion that God demands our worship. And as an agnostic, I do believe it is possible that a God exists out there somewhere, and it is conceivable that such a God is as kind and loving as some have proposed. I guess it is specifically a certain brand of fundamentalist beliefs that I am mostly referring to. It is frequently the case that this discussion arises out of a discussion of Heaven, how to get there, and what you do once you are there. I find myself saying "well, Hell certainly sounds like a place I don't want to go, but Heaven certainly doesn't appeal to me either. What's the third option?
ams182764
In my cynical opinion, throughout history it has been the priests who have demanded worship and obedience. God was the proxy by which they demanded it, and whose works they took credit for. If God was as obsessed with orthodoxy as his "servants" (God needs servants?) are, you would expect there to be an obvious and universal religion, rather than the thousands of culturally local ones throughout history, moving and growing by means of human interaction. IMO, worshipping God should be prompted by honest appreciation of the universe, not by fear of punishment. I have been somewhat far out of the range of what would be considered orthodox by my friends for some time now. Occassionally I still run into trouble with debates on things like evolution.