Existential ruminations
By CosmicConservativeSo one of the most commonly asked questions in casual philosophy is "Why are we here."
To many people this becomes a religious issue. "Because God made Us."
To others this becomes a science issue. "The Big Bang."
Some are comfortable believing both.
But the truth is that neither of those answer the question, nor does combining the two.
Because neither explains a first cause. If "God made us" then what made God? Why is God here? If the Big Bang happened, what caused it?
This is one reason I remain agnostic to this day. No matter how hard I try, I can't come up with any plausible reason for anything to exist.
It is not possible that there was ever a time when there was "nothing" because by definion "nothing" means that there can be no cause and effect, because there is nothing to cause an effect. So "nothing" is forever.
But this implies that "something" has always existed, and that violates every concept of time and causality we have been able to conceive of.
So either "something" can erupt out of "nothing" or time and causality are concepts we have not begun to comprehend. Or both.
To say "God has always existed" just puts a name to the "something" that has always existed, it does nothing to explain how or why God came to exist.
This sort of thing keeps me awake nights.
Comments (7)