Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Movie Review: Bridge To Terabithia

By CosmicConservative
OK, so we saw the movie. Some of you may recall my review of the book a few months ago. I wasn't very kind. The movie was both better and worse than the book. Better because the movie did not depict the local townspeople as dirt-poor hicks who could live destitute, but couldn't spell it. The homes and school were realistically portrayed instead of the pathetic stereotypes that they were in the book. This made for a much more believable story than the book, where Leslie was like an angel descended into the depths of hell by comparison. However, this brings me to what was worse in the movie. The special effects were not merely over-the-top, they were distracting and actually interfered with the story, especially during some of the most dramatic scenes where the movie desperately needed humanity, not computer generated animation. I thought the boy who played Jesse, and the girl who played Leslie, were excellent. The actress who played the music teacher was good, but there was something just not right about her, but that may be because I've seen her in other things and can't quite get those roles out of my head. The father was too harsh on Jesse, also in a manner that strained credulity, but it was clear they were setting up for the big finish. I almost can't believe I am saying this, but this movie would have been an absolute tear-jerker and much better than anyone would have expected if they had just filmed it straight, without the CGI.

Comments (7)

Dadman
I disagree. I thought the CGI was very minimal, indeed the CGI you see in the previews is essentially all you get in the film. This was primarily a relationship story and I think it worked very well on that level...in spite of the CGI...
CosmicConservative
Dadman: I agree, it worked "in spite of" the CGI. And it is interesting that you think the CGI was minimal, and I think it was pervasive. Virtually every scene in "Terabithia" itself was nothing but CGI. The whole "dark lord" thing with the shape forming and unforming throughout the woods was never in the book. And the way they merged the "dark lord" with his dad at the end, was, I thought, grossly misrepresenting the relationship of Jesse and his Dad from the book. I don't know it it was intentional or not, but if it was, it was heavy-handed, and if it was not, it was just poor craftsmanship. Such merging of elements SHOULD have a reason behind it. Not "here comes the dark lord, here comes the dark lord, Oh no, Jesse tripped.... oh, it's just his dad." What the heck was that all about? I think the same effects could have been done with more overt moves from reality to imagination. It was the merging of them together so seamlessly that kept reminding me of the Blair Witch Project. ("Was that a tree, or a troll?") I enjoyed the movie. I even had to use a tissue there at the end. But I stand by my statement that the CGI was overdone, poorly integrated (by being TOO integrated) and was merely eye-candy to an otherwise touching and important story.
CosmicConservative
OK, one more comment on this, a very specific reason I think the CGI was not only gratuitously overdone, but actually interfered with the whole story. Jesse learns that his father's keys are in Terabithia, put there by his little sister with the help of Leslie (this was never in the book, by the way). His father is looking at either losing his new promotion to manager (in the book at this point, he had actually been fired, not promoted, by the way) or else having to come up with several hundred dollars to get new locks installed at the hardware store. Several hundred dollars from a family which had sent their son to school with pink sneakers because they could not afford to go to Goodwill (where I used to shop) and get a replacement pair of boy's sneakers for Jesse. Such a financial burden would likely put the family on the brink of bankruptcy. Let's avoid for a moment the issue of what Jesse's Dad did that full day without his keys while Jesse was at school, and instead focus on what Jesse did when he got home. So, he and Leslie head out to retrieve his father's keys. All the way there Jesse is ranting and raving about how his father had berated him for having his "head in the clouds" and for not having his feet on the ground. Now, knowing this, knowing his father is in dire straits, Leslie and Jesse decide to indulge themselves in an all-afternoon session of battles against every evil denizen in their imaginary menagerie, including a troll whose head was now revealed to be a facsimile of the school bully. The CGI battles are impressive and far ranging, ending with Jesse falling out of the tree only to be saved by the imaginary troll. All this while I'm thinking "Your father is right Jesse. Now is not the time to play fantasy-land. Now is the time to climb that tree, get those keys and get them back to your distraught and job-threatened Dad, so he can call the owner and tell him not to replace all those locks, which would likely be something they would be doing after hours to avoid impacting customers." To say that this caused me to stop suspending my disbelief is a severe understatement. I wanted to slap the kid.
Dadman
Sure, I'm not arguing the CGI added a great deal to the film's impact, but I don't think it detracted either. It may have been eye candy, but films essentially made and marketed for children (as was this film) need some eye candy. I still received the film as touching and important...as did most reviewers, by the way.
CosmicConservative
Just in case our posts crossed in the aether, you might want to check my last comment in case you didn't read it.
Dadman
Just read them. I think you're over-analyzing the film, although your point is valid. He should have just gone straight home with the keys. I don't remember having similar thoughts. I couldn't be sure precisely when the father would need the keys...so I continued to suspend disbelief. I liked the Leslie-Jesse relationship, the Jesse-little sister relationship and the Jesse-Father relationship. I thought they were all well-played. I didn't read the book, by the way. I almost never like movies based on books I've read. Perhaps that is the difference here...
CosmicConservative
I don't think I am overanalyzing the story. I think the producer and director were actively looking for a way to add more "jazz" to the movie and the "lost" hardware store keys plot-line gave them a chance to try to put some drama into the imaginary world. It never occurred to them to wonder if that was an appropriate time for Jess and Leslie to be playing fantasy-land. They wanted CGI, and so we got CGI, whether it made sense to the story line or not was not an issue that was even debated. It was "where do we put it?" not "Does it make sense?" That's just my opinion, but I'm 95% certain it went just like that.