Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

More science reporting idiocy

By CosmicConservative
Heh, after receiving Dr. Massey's correction to the interview quotes on the lunar eclipse, I'll be more careful about this story and assume the actual scientists involved actually know something about the earth! Because obviously the CNN reporter and editor don't have a freakin' clue.
Robot to study hole in Earth's crust - CNN.com SANTA CRUZ DE TENERIFE, Canary Islands (AP) -- British scientists have embarked on a mission to study a gigantic hole in the Atlantic seabed -- an enigma that defies traditional geophysical theory and will give researchers an unprecedented look into the center of the Earth. The 12-person team left the Canary Islands Monday with a new high-tech vessel and a robotic device named Toby that will dig up rock samples at the bottom of the crater and film what it sees. The hole is about 16,400 feet under the surface of the Atlantic and located half way between Tenerife and Barbados. It has a diameter of 10,000 to 13,000 feet. The mysterious orifice is in an undersea mountain range, the kind of structure believed to form when Atlantic tectonic plates separate and volcanic lava surges upward to fill the gap in the earth's crust. But that did not happen this time. Instead, the hole exposes the mantle, the material that makes up Earth's interior, said British geophysicist Roger Searle of Durham University, one of the lead researchers.
OK, so I italicized the parts of this excerpt from the story that make me grind my teeth. defies traditional geophysical theory - Um... how is that? There is nothing I am aware of in "traditional geophysical theory" that makes it impossible for a portion of the mantle to be exposed in this way. Unusual? certainly; rare? possibly; unheard of? of course not! According to "traditional geophysical theory" the crust is made up of material from the mantle, or below the mantle, that has cooled and crystallized. So materials from below the crust are exposed sometimes. I don't think any textbooks are being rewritten based on this discovery. center of the Earth - What the heck are you talking about? W'ere down a few thousand feet. The "center of the earth" is down 4,000 miles! If the earth were an apple, we wouldn't even be through the skin! "Center of the earth" what a maroon! mysterious orifice I bet this reporter patted himself on the back when he came up with this wildly inaccurate term. "Orifice?" An "orifice" is commonly understood to be an opening to a larger cavity of some sort. This is just a place where the mantle is exposed, there's no "cavity" to get into. At least not from what I can see of the story. the hole exposes the mantle, the material that makes up Earth's interior The Mantle makes up SOME of the earth's interior. There are several other levels in the earth's makeup, down to the core, which is what really gets mysterious. I don't know why I bother with this stuff, CNN is going to continue to hire scientifically illiterate reporters and put them on science stories because they aren't partisan enough to cover the news probably. So we'll just continue to see such nonsense reported and the public will just continue to be misinformed about the universe, but they probably don't care anyway. sigh.

Comments (3)

mtnlurker
Could it be a meteor crater? Is the hole round? I need more information.
mtnlurker
I found a better story here. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/wales/6405667.stm And even better I found a site for the ship that is investigating. http://www.noc.soton.ac.uk/gg/classroom@sea/JC007/ They just left a few days ago. This is really cool.
CosmicConservative
That is a much better story. Among other things it makes it clear that this is not an "unprecedented" event, although it is the biggest example yet found. I am looking forward to the discoveries the team makes. Hopefully those will be reported by the BBC instead of CNN.