Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Orson Scott Card against the devil...

By CosmicConservative
Civilization Watch - February 18, 2007 - Evil Fiction - The Ornery American Evil Fiction Let me tell you about an audiobook that I hated. I didn't hate it because it was badly written -- it was mediocre in the way that mediocre thrillers usually are, and that means it would ordinarily have been tolerable. No, the reason I stopped listening to Steve Berry's The Alexandria Link is that this book is evil. I don't mean it's about evil. I don't even mean that it is evil-porn, like those horror books whose authors are pervertedly devoted to thinking up cool ways to torture and kill people. I mean that this book, to the degree that it is read by people ignorant of history (i.e., practically everybody), will move us closer to a future in which our society permits or even approves of the murder of Jews and the destruction of the state of Israel.
I think this is an important essay, just as I think many of OSC's essays are important. But will it have any impact? Probably not. But you should read it anyway. (Hat tip to Little Green Footballs)

Comments (4)

ams182764
Though no one should make this decision for them, I think Israel needs to seriously consider relocating. Religious significance of the homeland or not. Whether it's just to abandon all that you have made, pack up, and leave once more, or not. I realize there is no pretty way to manage a retreat, and that the whole Arab world will likely fall on the rearguard with genocidal fervor. But they are sitting ducks, and eventually, the Arab world (or the Europeans, who have never really recovered from their centuries of antisemitism, if the Arabs fail) will destroy them all. Their allies are being swayed against them, and I'm not confident that America won't follow suit. The Jewish people, for whatever sub-rational "reason" lurking in whatever undeveloped portion of our brains governs group dynamics, have been designated for cannibalism. It seems once you have been named the scapegoat, people are more likely to do it again and again. Enough hate is ginned up against you, the problems of the world laid at your feet, people sacrifice you in a bloody frenzy, rejoice, and the process starts over once again. It doesn't help that Israel has a small, concentrated population with limited means to provide for their own rearmamanet. It doesn't help that they are wealthy (poorly defended wealth always excites the urge to prey). Historically, their industriousness has always generated wealth wherever they have settled, and genocidal envy was never far behind them. I used to think that people were basically intelligent, benign unless provoked, rational. But it seems to me anymore that this isn't the case at all! I used to think that the same rationality that applies in most cases in our personal relationships with other people also applied at larger levels of organization. But somehow we always find ourselves on the same road to tribal fuedalism. Cliques, power struggles, vendettas, zero-sum thinking, envy, purges and all. America stands by Israel now, because reason and friendship are still prevailing; but eventually these sub-rational pressures will sway people who aren't paying close concious attention into alignment against the "scapegoat", despite reason, despite our own interests in other free and democratic people. Ditto for the poor people of Iraq. Despite reason, the "people" irrational mob that people are, will be swayed into alignment with the governing popular elite eventually. We will abandon them just as we abandoned the South Vietnamese and North Koreans. For whatever reason, our rational concious forebrains are NOT in charge of large group behavior. The motives that we think of in our interpersonal relationships, friendship, trust, reciprocation, trade and voluntary agreement, do not seem to hold sway over tribes. Tribes don't feel friendship. They don't feel kindness or charity. They don't "think" collectively as individuals think individually. They don't take into account past fairness or generousity. And it is well known in psychological circles that individuals composing mobs are characterised by a complete lack of feeling responsibility or accounting for future consequences of actions. (Deindividuation). The only emotions tribes seem to feel to me are fear if you are strong and foreign (and consequently respect), or hatred if you are weak and foreign, and the urge to force members to conform. In the world of politics (at all degrees of scale), when the friendly and rational order of civilization is replaced by the screaming lockstep march of a mob, your only defense lies in power. Unapolagetic military might. Period.
ams182764
Basically, they need to move somewhere where they can amass military and political power. To some host nation that isn't already too poisoned against them. Once they have amassed enough might, perhaps some of this hatred will begin to subside (switching back over to fear/respect), before the world launches a killing blow against them once more.
CosmicConservative
ams: I have for decades told people that geopolitical affairs have all the subtle dynamics of a nursury school recess. I have seen nothing in my adult life to change that opinion. In general "diplomacy" is the attempt to disguise these base subconscious desires to grab the most candy on the table for ourselves using fancy words and empty promises. There are great and noble exceptions. But they are exceptions. In general I see the United States as one of those exceptions. And our support of Israel is specifically one. We have received nothing but hatred and violent attack for our principled stand that Jews deserve a homeland of their own, and deserve to live in peace with their neighbors. If you are trying to take the measure of a politician in the United States, their stand on Israel is the best way I know to learn if they are principled, understand history and honor the obligations their country has made. And it is sad to say that there are many on both sides of the aisle who would throw the Jews to the wolves without a second thought.
Brian
Basically, they need to move somewhere where they can amass military and political power. To some host nation that isn’t already too poisoned against them. Right. And where would that be, exactly? The only nation where millions of Jews could relocate is .. here. Which doesn't strike me as a terribly bad idea. Unless .. hey look up. See all that real estate just going to waste? The moon ... use the moon as a springboard. The really ambitious Jews settle Mars, the asteroid belt. Lunar Zionist has a ring to it, nu?