The Trouble With Physics
By CosmicConservativeIs a book by Lee Smolin.
I'm reading it. Its basic theme is that physics has been stuck in neutral for 30 years, which is the longest period of stasis in the field since Isaac Newton shook up the Aristotelian worldview with his famous book "Principia Mathematica" (More accurately: "Philosophie Naturalus Principia Mathematica" which translates more or less to "The Mathematical Principles of Natural Philosophy", "Natural Philosophy" being what people in Newton's time called what we now call "Physics.")
I'm only in the first chapter but Dr. Smolin has begun discussing what he calls "The Five Great Problems In Theoretical Physics." The first one (the only one I've read so far) is this one:
"The problem of Quantum Gravity", or as it is usually phrased, "How do we reconcile Quantum Mechanics with General Relativity?"
He identifies as the key element of this problem the fact that both General Relativity and Quantum Mechanics predict infinite physical values. This, he says, violates everything we know about reality. He then says something like "wise people have long suspected that the reason General Relativity predicts infinite physical properties is because it does not account for quantum effects."
This made me feel good because that's what I've been saying for twenty years, as I said in the post "Black Holes and the Information Paradox" a few months ago. So since he called my own perspective on this "wise" I'm inclined to think he is brilliant.
Isn't that how it always works?
Comments (4)