Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The Skeptical Environmentalist

By Dadman
This controversial book is packed with statistics from reputable sources. You may have heard of it. I'd like to say I've read the whole book from cover to cover, but in fact I use it more like a desktop top reference to help me cut through all of the alarmist environmental rhetoric and understand what is really going on in our global environment. Leftists don't like the book very much. In fact, Mr. Lomborg was hauled in front of some Danish body called the Danish Committee on Scientific Dishonesty (staffed with thought police no doubt) accused of being 'systematically one-sided' and 'objectively dishonest'. These charges were later repudiated by another Danish organization call the Danish Ministry of Science, Technology and Innovation. At least the latter committee seemed to have a clue. Scientific American magazine also threatened to sue Mr. Lomborg for defending himself against a scathing 11-page editorial it published in January 2002 attacking The Skeptical Environmentalist. You can read more about his experience here. It is clear to me that doomsday environmentalism has become dogmatic, ideological, political and anti-science. It's primary goal is to enforce ideological orthodoxy rather than encourage true scientific inquiry. Mr. Lomborg's experience bears this out. So does the liberal notion that human-induced global warming deniers are somehow on par with those that deny the well-documented atrocities of the Third Reich. It's all designed to shut people up who don't believe.

Comments (19)

ams182764
I read his book. I also read the two Scientific American articles. I cheered at his rebuttal where he basically said (paraphrased, I can't remember word for word from years ago) "I've only been given two pages to defend myself against 11 pages of arguments made against my work, so I'll refer you to my website for a more complete rebuttal"
ams182764
PS. I liked his books because he was objective. Theres a certain level of understanding that he was trying to convey, which I try to get at all the time. He gave you the actual data, the graphs, the results of various studies, rather than just word salads which uses the studies as an excuse to paint a picture or give you an editorial.
pace
I've read so many differing accounts of Lomborg, that frankly I don't know what to believe. I do own his book. I have also watched Al Gore's "An Inconvenient Truth". Both seem to contain inaccuracies, if not outright misrepresentation of available data. I guess you could call me a fence-sitter on the issue of human-contribution to Global Warming, and whether it will prove catastrophic for the human race if we don't intervene in the process. I try to be open-minded on the issue, but I guess I am a little skeptical still.
Dadman
The very idea of the humanity effectively intervening into a system as huge and complex as our global climate just seems patently absurd to me. It seems roughly akin to stating we need to stop tectonic drift to prevent future earthquakes. The free market will sort things out. No need for draconian laws dictating how we can and cannot live our lives. And no need to label as evil or stupid those who are skeptical of human-induced global warming. I haven't yet seen An Inconvenient Truth, but soon will...
gjh
Nobody ever thought man could kill a Great Lake but if you look back 40 years Lake Erie was "dead". Man cleaned it up by doing on a smaller scale what is recommended now.
CosmicConservative
gjh: Lake Erie was "cleaned up" primarily by stopping the major sources of pollution. It took care of itself. It is interesting that you would use Lake Erie as an example here because back in the sixties and seventies environmentalists were calling it "dead" and saying it would take a hundred years or more to bring it back to life, at the expense of billions of dollars. But all it took was stopping the pollution and letting nature take care of itself. The lesson that should be taken from Lake Erie is that radical environmentalists are almost always wrong, almost always exaggerate the doom and gloom, almost always demand draconian measures that are not necessary and almost always forget how resilient nature is. So thanks for bringing that up.
Dadman
How are you doing today, Cosmic? You and your family are in my thoughts...
gjh
If only the reduction of the phosphates, caused the major decline, faster than anyone predicted what would the reduction of CO2 do to the atmosphere? Would the same happen as quickly? The experts predicted that Erie would never come back but here it is. The problem with Erie is that phosphates have been rising since 1997 and other problems similar to the 60's are beginning to appear on a smaller scale but very similar. The situation did nor clear itself, as you said stop the pollution and let it clear(heal) itself.
Dadman
gjh: First, our global climate and a lake are simply not analogous. Second, while the correlation is clear that reducing or eliminating the amount of pollution in a lake will lead to a cleaner lake, it is not so definitive that reducing human CO2 contributions to the atmosphere will lead to a cooler atmosphere. It's just not the same thing regardless of how much you may think it is...
gjh
There are about 1000 scientists world wide that think so and a handful that think not. I will side the majority. Our differences are just that. It is funny how the largest contributors of the CO2's are ones trotting out the minority of experts.
Dadman
Majority opinion is not the same as scientific proof. I know you believe that scientists skeptical of human-induced global warming have all been bought and paid for by Big Oil, but I suggest you follow the money on the other side of the argument as well. Much of the research that supports human-induced warming is funded by groups who are essentially looking for that outcome. Like Big Oil, they are simply buying the conclusions that will best support their vested interests. Science, particularly environmental science, no longer seems to be open, honest and objective. It strikes me more as propaganda these days...
Rick Larson
So you think all environmentalists are doomsdayers? Do you think conservationism is synonomous with enviromentalism? And can a conservative thinking ever be compatible with environmentalism? The problem with such a reaction is just that. The Democrats decided to make climate change a political issue and Republicans have reacted - just as they planned them too.
Dadman
First of all, Rick, I've never said I believe all environmentalists are doomsdayers. That's why I've tried to use the 'doomsday' adjective, to set normal environmentalists apart from the more hysterical ones. As a conservative, I support conservation of our natural resources and doing what we can to keep our air, water, and overall environment clean. So yes, conservatism and environmentalism are certainly compatible concepts. I am not a Republican; I consider myself a rational, reasonable independent conservative who is simply skeptical of all the hysterical rhetoric we hear almost daily about human-induced climate change. I doubt the integrity of the science. I think political motivations are involved. I believe much of the warming we are presently observing is part of a natural process. I strongly believe true science is all about challenging orthodoxy rather than propping it up and when you begin to hear the debate is over, skepticism should kick in big time.
ams182764
Err... I thought lake Erie was "dead" because an invasive species of mollusc proliferated that was so efficient at cleaning the water of food and particulates that nothing was left for the fish?
Rick Larson
Ok then, can relate to that Sean. I coined the title "Conservative Conservationist".
Dadman
Um...it was me, Dadman, who said conservatism and environmentalism are not incompatible...
CosmicConservative
I consider myself to be an environmentalist, but just as I am a rational conservative, I am also a rational environmentalist. The issues that I think need pressing attention are, in no particular order: 1. Slash and burn clearing of the equatorial rainforests. 2. Massive over-exploitation of critical sea-fisheries. 3. Worldwide poaching of endangered species. 4. Cleanup of the (mostly) Eastern European environmental disasters (what the U.S. did a generation ago with the "superfunds" to clean up things like Rocky Flats in Colorado. 5. Destruction of coastal wetlands (this is particularly bad in the U.S. in Florida and Louisiana where we are losing swampland at an alarming rate. Those swamplands provide the foundational foodsources for entire Gulf of Mexico ecosystems, and they are simply being washed away by over-controlled rivers or are being cleared for development. Take care of those five and I'll be convinced we're doing something about the environment. Global Warming, at its worst predictions, is not remotely as frightening to me as the destruction of the worldwide sea ecosystems.
ams182764
You know, oil is infinitely benign compared to what we were burning just before it's discovery. When you get right down to it, CO2 is an inert, colorless, oderless gas (when properly ventillated to the outside). Coal on the other hand was dirty, smelly, filled with particulates, sulfur compounds, ect, and put out a LOT more carbon per unit energy. Anyway, just trying to say that there are real environmental disasters (the London "yellow fog of death" back in the 1900s that suffocated people), and then there are histronics about imagined environmental disaster.