Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The myth of rising seas

By CosmicConservative
OK, so one of the main doomsday scenarios that are constantly coming up from Global Warming alarmists is the threat of rising seas due to melting glaciers and ice shelfs. As far as the ice shelfs are concerned, every single one of them could melt away into nothing and global sea levels will not change one bit. This is because ice displaces exactly the same amount of water as the water it melts into. You can test this out by measuring the level of water in a glass before and after an ice cube melts. (although you have to be careful about evaporating water during the test, but trust me ;) ) So that leaves ice that is on land that will flow into the sea. Which is what you find basically only in Greenland and Antarctica. Many people are surprised to learn that the actual land mass in antarctica has very little moisture, it's basically a desert. And if it melts, the bulk of it will form rivers and lakes on the continent, it won't all flow down into the sea. Actually unless the earth essentially becomes an oven, it won't all melt. So where does the "rising sea" come from, since there just isn't that much ice to melt and cause it to rise? When I studied this back in the 80s the answer was "from the expansion of water due to the increased temperature of the water." In other words, water, like most materials, decreases in density when it heats, it expands. This expansion can only cause the water level to go up since it can't go down or sideways. So computer models in the past factored this expansion in and that's where much of the "20 foot sea level increases" fear-mongering comes from. But there's a problem. Those models used to assume consistent density of seawater from top to bottom, and that's not what happens. What happens to sea water is that below a certain depth, the weight of the water on top of it pretty much squeezes all the heat out and it settles in to a temperature just above freezing. That's why the sea floor temperature is pretty much constant worldwide. So the only real expansion occurs at the depths that are above this level, which greatly decreases the overall expansion of the sea, therefore reducing the likely flooding. That's why the world didn't flood during the Medieval Warming Epoch. And that's why I don't think we're looking at global flooding as a likely scenario today.

Comments (8)

ams182764
"But there’s a problem. Those models used to assume consistent density of seawater from top to bottom, and that’s not what happens. What happens to sea water is that below a certain depth, the weight of the water on top of it pretty much squeezes all the heat out and it settles in to a temperature just above freezing. That’s why the sea floor temperature is pretty much constant worldwide." I'm not quite sure this is right. While the water on top compresses the water underneath, increasing the density a little bit (water isn't all that compressible one way or the other), the temperature shouldn't change. It should all level out. Of course that doesn't take into account the lack of light and solar heating at that depth, but you can't lower the temperature of something by "compressing the heat out" unless you transfer it, then expand it again subsequently, and water is a very poor refridgerant in this capacity!
CosmicConservative
Water is not very compressible, but it does compress. And when you compress it, it gets smaller. This generates heat, just like pumping a bicycle pump generates heat. That heat mostly dissipates into the shallower water. The end result is water temperature right around 32 degrees F, since salt water freezes a little colder than that. Here's a link showing the temperature gradient of seawater. It says more than 90% of sea water is below the thermocline, which is the part of the sea that would warm up. Sea Temps My explanation of why the water on the ocean floor stays just a few degrees above freezing is my own interpratation of the physics of the situation. If you have another explanation, feel free to offer it, but whatever the explanation is, the reality is the same. 90% of the seawater is not going to be affected by global warming, but the models that show the sea levels increasing do not (or did not when I looked into it) take this into account.
ams182764
"Here’s a link showing the temperature gradient of seawater. It says more than 90% of sea water is below the thermocline, which is the part of the sea that would warm up." Well, this is true. "If you have another explanation, feel free to offer it, but whatever the explanation is, the reality is the same. 90% of the seawater is not going to be affected by global warming, but the models that show the sea levels increasing do not (or did not when I looked into it) take this into account. " As to why the deep ocean is colder, I think the explaination is just that the sunlight doesn't reach down that deep, and the heat diffusion across miles of ocean water is poor, so the deep ocean is influenced more by the temperature of the sea-floor. While compressing something does squeeze some heat out, this is more relevant for gasses than for highly incompressible liquids like water. And it doesn't decrease the temperature. Compressing an ideal gas actually increases the temperature initially, and it then reaches equilibrium with it's surroundings through heat transfer. Expanding an ideal gas decreases it's temperature. Heat, temperature, pressure, entropy, enthalpy, ect are all thermodynamic variables expressing the state of a substance. You need at least two of them to express the state of a gas (and probably a liquid, though assuming incompressibility for water probably imposes some relationships of its own). So it doesn't make sense to express a relationship between temperature and heat, unless you are fixing the pressure, or between pressure and temperature unless you are fixing something else like the heat energy in the water. And I agree, the primary warming should occur in the upper layer of the ocean.
CosmicConservative
ams: You and I are saying the same thing different ways. What I'm trying to describe here is a property of water that is rare, and that property is that water is one of the few materials that is denser as a liquid than as a solid. This creates some unique dynamics in the interaction of water and ice, and some of those dynamics affect how the water can hold heat under pressure. I am guilty here of trying to explain some complex things in simple terms, and you're probably right that I've oversimplified it. I don't want to get into a thermodynamics discussion here where I try to describe how water turning to ice creates some unique physical effects that, among other things, explains why the sea floor is liquid instead of ice. I'll just leave it at the point where we both agree that global warming, even at its current worst predicted impact, is not going to affect the entire ocean, and most of the computer models that predict 20 foot ocean level increases are not dealing with the physical properties properly, and are off probably by an order of magnitude at least. I hope we can agree on that.
ams182764
http://www2.volstate.edu/CHEM/Density_of_Water.htm BTW, if a column of water were to increase temperature from 20 to 24 C (assuming incompressibility), the specific volume would increase from 1001.8 kg/m^3 to 1002.7 kg/m^3. A 0.09% increase in volume and therefore column height. So if you roughly estimated that this expansion would occur within the 500m thermocline region, you'd get something like a 45cm sea level rise. Of course, this temp increase doesn't distribute over the whole earth, ect ect, so this model is not going to be very accurate.
ams182764
Oops - unit error. specific volume (inverse of density) would be m^3/kg
ams182764
And I screwed up again - multiplied instead of divided. From 0.0010018 m^3/kg to 0.0010027 m^3/kg. But the percentage expansion was right. I think.....
Rick Larson
Would tend to think the changing weather patterns are more real to most living on the coast than the potential for rising seas. Either way, am not planning to purchase any property along the ocean any time soon!