Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Big Bad Carbon Dioxide?

By Dadman
One fact that is frequently lost (or perhaps conveniently ignored) in all the global warming hysteria is how much CO2 is actually in our atmosphere. Judging from the end-of-the-world rhetoric on the left one would have to conclude that CO2 increases would soon be replacing our breathable oxygen supply. So, which gas is the most plentiful in our atmosphere? That would be nitrogen at about 78%. Carbon dioxide would certainly be next on the list, right? Not even close. The next most prevalent gas in our atmosphere is oxygen at about 21%. If you're good with addition you'll notice that nitrogen and oxygen comprise nearly 99% of our atmospheric composition. Now, CO2 is so evil it must AT LEAST make up what's left. Again, not even close. Water vapor is next on the list at about 2% on average. Water vapor, better known (and despised) as humidity by those living in the Gulf States is variable and local. Sometimes water vapor is very high, sometimes nearly non-existent (like here in Arizona), but the average is around 2%. Okay, CO2 has got to be next on the list. Wrong again. Argon takes that distinction with approximately .90%. Big bad carbon dioxide is actually the 5th most abundant gas in our atmosphere at around .036%. That's a mere one thirtieth of one percent. Experts say that CO2 levels have increased about 25% over the past 300 years or so. My response to this fact: whoopdeedoo... To use a football analogy, if our atmosphere were represented by a 100 yard football field, present day CO2 levels would comprise only about one puny inch of that field. Clearly we are all dead men walking...

Comments (13)

ams182764
Water vapor alters the earth's reflectiveness, blocking out sunlight. Furthermore, it sets up a negative feedback with temperature due to increased evaporation at higher temps. It also happens to be a greenhouse gas active in the same wavelengths as CO2, and present in greater quantities.
CosmicConservative
Water vapor has a far more significant greenhouse effect on its own than CO2 has on its own. Hundreds of times more significant. So the Global Warming alarmists have theorized that CO2 is bad because it facilitates water vapor concentrations in the air, greatly multiplying its impact.
CosmicConservative
ams (aka qwerty): Water vapor actually has both greenhouse heating and reflective cooling aspects, depending on how much of it is in the form of clouds, how high the clouds are, whether they are over land or sea, and whether they are more prevalent day or night. This is one reason that I constantly try to make the point that our computer models are woefully inadequate to be truly predictive about our future temperature changes.
ams182764
Yep, pretty much my point. The atmospheric effects we should see from water vapor should overwhelm any effects seen from CO2 on humid or overcast areas, one way or the other.
Boyd
Why do your figures seem to end up somewhere above 102% total?
Dadman
Boyd: Because the percentages of each gas I cite are approximate and variable. The key point I was trying to make is that carbon dioxide comprises a mere fraction of one percent of the atmosphere's total composition. Even with the 25% increase that climatologists tell us has occured over the past 300 years, we are still talking about incredibly small amounts of CO2 relative to the entire atmosphere. I'm skeptical increased CO2 levels - given how little of it is actually in our atmosphere - can have the dire, catastrophic impact predicted by doomsday environmentalists.
Kevin in WI
So, how high would CO2 levels have to go in order to affect breathability of the atmosphere?
Dadman
So, I did a little snooping around and discovered that people can begin to sense something is amiss when CO2 levels reach about 2% concentration levels. OSHA has limited shift-long CO2 concentration exposure to about 6%. At 6% CO2 levels oxygen levels tend to drop below 20% which apparently is not a good thing. So, I would surmise that sustained exposure to CO2 levels greater or equal to 6% begin to become toxic to human beings. That's not very much CO2 by percentage. I won't be surprised if global warming alarmists begin to tell us that increasing levels of CO2 will eventually suffocate all of us...if we don't die of heat stroke first...
Kevin in WI
If levels need to get to 6% to affect breathing, then they would have to increase 170 times (17000%) over our current "elevated" levels. Sounds like we can breath easy.
Rick Larson
The link is to a speech by the foremost Conservative Congressman, and think you ought to spend the time considering his ideas. By the way, this man is coming to Manitowoc to speak at an energy summit, some of the thanks go to me! An your invited! http://bartlett.house.gov/uploadedfiles/SpclOrderJanuary17-18.pdf
Dadman
Interesting, Rick. When you're done reading Barlett's stuff you should check out this book: These guys argue that 'oil is not a product of fossils and prehistoric forests but rather the bio-product of a continuing biochemical reaction below the earth's surface that is brought to attainable depths by the centrifugal forces of the earth's rotation'. So, is this book true or the notion of peak oil?