Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The Iraq War is over and we won

By CosmicConservative
Okay, I've been out of touch for a while and have been ignoring international politics. But I'm back now. We won the Iraq War. It's over. It's been over for a long time. Saddam Hussein has been tried and executed, there's not a tiny sliver of the Iraqi army left in operation. The war is done. Over. Has been for a long time. Now it's Iraq's turn to win the peace. We can't win that because it's all up to them. People can argue all they want about whether the U.S. military victory has resulted in violence in Iraq, but by any reasonable measure there was violence in Iraq before we took Saddam out. So enough on the Iraq War. It's history. Our goal now is to help the people of Iraq govern themselves, but it's not our fault if they prove incapable of it. We tried. We gave them a chance. We lost thousands of U.S. lives doing it. If Shia and Sunni simply can't live together without fear of authoritarian despotism, then they can set another one up and we'll take it down when it becomes an international problem too.

Comments (10)

CosmicConservative
Not so much. More just getting tired of the incessant whining about the "Iraq War" having gone bad. The war went great. An historic victory. The peace has been the problem, and one reason its been a problem is because we adopted too much responsibility for becoming peacekeepers. I have to admit that I am rapidly becoming one who says "if Shia and Sunni want to kill each other, go to it. I'm tired of the U.S. trying to teach them how to live together. Let them knock each other out. If something happens that upsets the international order too much (say Iran invades Iraq, for example) then we unleash the dogs of war again and kick their ass too. And then we let them figure out how to get along. If they want to just kill each other for eternity, so long as they keep it between themselves, so be it. Have at it. We've got better things to do than to try to get two 7th century societies to live in the 21st century."
CosmicConservative
Okay Rick, what is factually wrong with my comments? I could replace "the peace" with "the occupation" if you prefer, but the war is over. War is when you have armies facing each other and battles happening. An insurgency is not a war, that's why they have the word "insurgency" in the dictionary. It's different. So I stand by my claim that the war is over and we won overwhelmingly. What I'm now wondering is what our obligation is in the long term to manage the peace, or occupation, whichever you prefer. At some point to we say "enough, you can't live with each other without a murderous despot ruling you, and we don't play that game (Cindy Sheehan and Michael Moore notwithstanding) so we're done now. If you present a threat to us again, we'll come back and kick your butt again. But it's better for everyone if you can just manage to live together like decent, civilized folks, so give that a try OK?
Rick Paffenroth
Seems like a rather symantical argument to me. Whether it's army on army or our army against the insurgents, we are losing soldiers every day, and there is no hope of Iraq becoming a beacon of democracy in the arab world which the Bush administration has predicted since the beginning of the war.
CosmicConservative
I don't think its fair to say that Bush "predicted" that. I would say that he optimistically hoped for it. And I still believe that the risk was worth the taking when you compare what the Iraq War has done compared to 70 years or more of constant appeasement and RealPolitik in the region. Something new needed to be tried, and the jury is still out on the whole thing. I have many times said that I believed the outcome of the Iraq War gamble would take a decade to prove right or wrong. I stand by that. It's still too early. There are still positive and negative things happening. And to say that Iraq is worse off today than in 2002 would definitely be news to the Kurds.
Rick Paffenroth
Cosmic...I would like to share your optomistic outlook that the jury is still out on the result of the Iraq war. I just don't think that any long term peaceful solution is possible. I do think that as long as we commit our troops to prop up the Maliki government they can survive. I also believe as soon as we leave, be it tomorrow or 10 years from now, the fragile democracy will fall and be replaced with a radical Islamic regime.
CosmicConservative
Rick: It has been my experience that things are rarely as bad as the doomsayers believe them to be, nor as good as the cheerleaders believe. The truth is always somewhere in between. And that's what I think is true here too. For whatever reason the press plays up the bad and plays down the good. I don't need to propose a media bias against Bush to explain that, just the desire to sell newspapers explains that. Nevertheless I think a pervasive media bias does play into it as well.
Rick Larson
Sean, our forces are now massing planes in Eastern Europe, and Navy ships in the middle East. The term, Iraq war, will soon become "The War for Middle East Oil".